![]() |
|
Keubiko - Printable Version +- ShareholdersUnite Forums (http://shareholdersunite.com/mybb) +-- Forum: Companies (http://shareholdersunite.com/mybb/forumdisplay.php?fid=1) +--- Forum: Destiny Media Forum (http://shareholdersunite.com/mybb/forumdisplay.php?fid=13) +--- Thread: Keubiko (/showthread.php?tid=7210) Pages:
1
2
|
Keubiko - admin - 08-10-2014 You might have noticed that a guy called Keubiko has written several articles on Seeking Alpha, arguing that Destiny's PlayMPE and Clipstream are no good and the company is worth virtually nothing. We have refuted many of his claims, but since quite a number of these articles are not accessible without subscription to SA Pro and the discussion is scattered in comment sections of numerous articles, we'll deconstruct his claims here one by one, in an orderly and numbered fashion.
1) PlayMPE is a bloated dinosaur Keubiko's claim: PlayMPE is a bloated dinosaur full of problems, for which much cheaper alternatives exist and switching cost are negligible. I view PlayMPE as the bloated expensive dinosaur in the space. Panic Selling In Destiny Media Is Unwarranted - Destiny Media Technologies, Inc. | Seeking Alpha Reality: The studios keep on using it, extending it over the world, renewing its contracts, and cooperating with Destiny to improve functionality..
You might notice that Keubiko actually agrees with the fact that where studios go, others follow: The studios have been effectively stuffing PlayMPE down the throat of the industry. Panic Selling In Destiny Media Is Unwarranted - Destiny Media Technologies, Inc. | Seeking Alpha RE: Keubiko - admin - 08-11-2014 2) Play MPE is not a growth business Keubiko's claim: PlayMPE is not a growth business DSNY's core (>97% of revenue) PlayMPE business is not a growth business, is vulnerable to upstart competitors, faces pricing pressure, and has huge single-customer concentration risk with a contract renewal set for March/April 2015. I generously value this business in the $0.15 per share range (assuming DSNY does indeed renew its large customer) Reality: As is common, his claims are one-sided, this one is no exception. Revenue from PlayMPE has indeed been stagnant, but that's because of a threshold in the new worldwide contract with Universal. Usage has to go beyond that threshold in order to generate additional revenue and up until recently, that has not generally be the case. But in the last quarter (their fiscal Q3), two out of three months, usage was above that, and we know that chargeable usage at Univeral has grown 80%+ compared to the quarter. Here is CFO Vandenberg from the CC:
Should this continue, you might also keep in mind that additional revenue will show up as almost pure profit, as the process is highly automated. RE: Keubiko - admin - 08-11-2014 One might also realize that Destiny has no debt and the number of outstanding shares haven't changed in years, and, according to Vandenberg on the Q3 CC:
RE: Keubiko - admin - 08-11-2014 3) PlayMPE margins Keubiko's claim: I generously value this business in the $0.15 per share range (assuming DSNY does indeed renew its large customer) representing a 2.2x revenue multiple or 15x an assumed net profit margin of 15%. Reality: Margins on PlayMPE are 22% on existing business and 90% on new business if it exceeds the usage threshold in the Universal contract (which happened in two of the three months of the April-June quarter or fiscal Q3). RE: Keubiko - admin - 08-11-2014 4) Transcoding Keubiko claims: transcoding cost aren't relevant and will be supersedec by Moore's law anyway. Transcoding is a red herring thanks to Moore's Law. Has Destiny Media's Clipstream Product Failed? - Destiny Media Technologies, Inc. | Seeking Alpha
On transcoding my point is that a) it is cheap, especially for a small ad clip, and b) most transcoding is done because there is VALUE in transcoding - video can be optimized for quality, screen size, link speed, latency, etc for the best user experience. Panic Selling In Destiny Media Is Unwarranted - Destiny Media Technologies, Inc. | Seeking Alpha
Reality: 1) Transcoding cost are highly relevant you might want to see this video of an industry expert who calls transcoding the biggest problem, with hundreds of formats. Here from the summary of a market report on the transcoding market:
The cost of transcoding can run up pretty quickly and it's a billion+ dollar industry 2) It's not only transcoding cost Clipstream is treated as normal web traffic. That means that:
So, not only does Clipstream save the transcoding cost themselves, also the cost of multiple streaming servers and content delivery networks are not incurred. 3) Onesided argument It's curious to see someone invoking Moore's law to rubbish transcoding cost (and content delivery networks) and yet stress things like:
While we'll discuss these issues separately, it's very curious that Moore's law (or technological progress) only seems to operate in such a way as to diminish or rubbish Clipstream advantages and not its disadvantages. Very onesided. RE: Keubiko - admin - 08-12-2014 5) Play MPE user problems Keubiko's claim: PlayMPE delivers a very lousy user experience, and he has shown a few tweets to back this up, in his first article and in the comment section of one of ours. Reality: While there are indeed some usability issues outside the studios, the fact is that PlayMPE remains the industry standard with a growing usage. The company is also aware of these usability issues. From the CC:
What one should also realize is that if Keubiko is right, and usability is a big issue, it negates another claim of his, that switching cost are high. If alternatives are cheaper and easier to use, why have the studios converged on PlayMPE?
RE: Keubiko - admin - 08-12-2014 6) Cheaper alternatives to PlayMPE exist Keubiko's claim: PlayMPE is a bloated dinasaur for which cheaper alternatives exist. He especially touts an outfit called Haulix I believe vastly more cost-effective newcomers such as Haulix (which has a quickly improving feature set) have a good shot at winning business from the high cost dinosaurs in the space like Destiny and iPool. For example Haulix's pricing schedule is $999 per month ($12K per year) for unlimited usage. Reality:
Cheaper isn't always better. Are Haulix feature set really comparable to those of PlayMPE? Do they provide lossless quality and the sophisticated watermarking and security features that is so crucial for PlayMPE? From our own article:
Can Haulix do all this? We don't think so. RE: Keubiko - admin - 08-13-2014 7) PlayMPE has no network effects Keubiko claim: there aren't any network effects to speak off Switching costs are de minimis based on my research. These are cloud based offerings and extremely easy to use. This is not like ripping out an accounting system at all. Panic Selling In Destiny Media Is Unwarranted - Destiny Media Technologies, Inc. | Seeking Alpha While Keubiko speaks of switching cost, these include network effects and we'll take on his switching cost in the next post. Reality: Network effects are likely to be significant
The curious thing is, Keubiko does realize this at certain stages: The studios have been effectively stuffing PlayMPE down the throat of the industry. Most of the angst seems to be coming from their targets. Panic Selling In Destiny Media Is Unwarranted - Destiny Media Technologies, Inc. | Seeking Alpha
RE: Keubiko - admin - 08-16-2014 8) Switching costs are negligeable Keubiko claim: Switching costs are de minimis based on my research. These are cloud based offerings and extremely easy to use. This is not like ripping out an accounting system at all. Panic Selling In Destiny Media Is Unwarranted - Destiny Media Technologies, Inc. | Seeking Alpha I view PlayMPE as the bloated expensive dinosaur in the space. Panic Selling In Destiny Media Is Unwarranted - Destiny Media Technologies, Inc. | Seeking Alpha
Reality: If PlayMPE is indeed a bloated expensive dinosaur for which cheap alternatives (Keubiko touts Haulix) exist what prevents their customers from switching? Switching cost! So we know that these statements can't be both true, as usual, Keubiko want to have his cake and eat it too. We have already argued that PlayMPE isn't the bloated expensive dinosaur, here we will argue that switching cost are fairly high.
RE: Keubiko - admin - 08-18-2014 We actually asked the company for a comment on the last point, here is what they had to say: We have six server facilities in Europe, North America and Australia with global 24 7 telephone support with code that automatically mirrors and load balances content in real time globally, while creating automated streaming alerts and other marketing materials such as our automated http://daily.plaympe.com integration into real time charts and social media feeds - this compares with other sites with a user name and password you can download an MP3 from. Our patented watermarking is the best in the world and we're integrated with the IFPI - the global anti piracy police. It's the only watermark to survive compression, analog duplication, conversion, filtering, etc. and still be inaudible. |