ShareholdersUnite Forums
Keubiko - Printable Version

+- ShareholdersUnite Forums (http://shareholdersunite.com/mybb)
+-- Forum: Companies (http://shareholdersunite.com/mybb/forumdisplay.php?fid=1)
+--- Forum: Destiny Media Forum (http://shareholdersunite.com/mybb/forumdisplay.php?fid=13)
+--- Thread: Keubiko (/showthread.php?tid=7210)

Pages: 1 2


RE: Keubiko - MattB - 09-04-2014

(08-12-2014, 06:47 AM)admin Wrote:

6) Cheaper alternatives to PlayMPE exist

Keubiko's claim: PlayMPE is a bloated dinasaur for which cheaper alternatives exist. He especially touts an outfit called Haulix

I believe vastly more cost-effective newcomers such as Haulix (which has a quickly improving feature set) have a good shot at winning business from the high cost dinosaurs in the space like Destiny and iPool. For example Haulix's pricing schedule is $999 per month ($12K per year) for unlimited usage.

Recent Update Further Cements The Bear Case For Destiny Media - Destiny Media Technologies, Inc. (OTCMKTSBig GrinSNY) | Seeking Alpha

Reality:

  1. Cheaper alternatives have always existed, but this hasn't stopped PlayMPE to become the de-facto standard used by the big three music studios and a thousand of independent studios
  2. Does one really think that if the likes of Universal (with a 40% market share after the EMI takeover) would use Haulix they would just have to pay $999 a month? Well perhaps, but as anyone who ever responded to a web hosting service promising "unlimited usage" can testify, these pricing schemes are usally not what they seem.
  3. Keubiko touts Haulix feature set, but one should realize that the studios worked intimately with Destiny to tailor make (or, rather, re-make) PlayMPE to the specifications of the studios. The worldwide contract with Universal signed last year was conditional on these and it required Destiny to years of investment in PlayMPE.

Cheaper isn't always better. Are Haulix feature set really comparable to those of PlayMPE? Do they provide lossless quality and the sophisticated watermarking and security features that is so crucial for PlayMPE? From our own article:

PlayMPE has certain patented killer DRM (digital rights management) features:

  • An undetectable watermark in the media file without losing quality, even when the file is compressed or conversed into another format.
  • Tracking the MPE file so that any infringes can be tracked back to the violating (and receiving) party. It provides even information about the date and time of the transaction, operating system, IP address and even the date and time of the illegal transaction are available to the original owner of the content using this technology.
  • Locking the media file to a single device, preventing it to play on unauthorized machines and devices.

This isn't just garden variety technology:

One of the more important claims in this patent is the ability to uniquely recognize a particular computer. Uniquely identifying a person's computer is a common issue which is usually approached by saving cookies or beacons to the user's computer or by tracking IP addresses. These are not reliable solutions as cookies are easily deleted and IP addresses easily changed. Destiny's propriety hash code process creates a serial number that can be used to recognize the user on subsequent visits without ever saving anything to that user's computer. [10-K filing]

Destiny's watermark technology is patented and integrated with the IFPI, the global anti piracy police. It's the only watermark that survives compression, analog duplication, conversion, filtering, etc., and still be inaudible. Pirates have been stopped in the middle of downloads with the police visiting them the next day, per the company.

The watermark identifies the violator by name with details of time, IP address, etc., so the person can be arrested. Every stream and every download is individually watermarked. Other systems have either no watermark or a useless generic one saying "Copyright UMG."

Can Haulix do all this? We don't think so.


Dear Author: You're making a few blind assumptions about us in this thread. I wouldn't expect anyone from Destiny Media to have experienced the web-based Haulix encoding process because that would require a paid subscription. With that said, our watermarks are inaudible and withstand mp3 encoding, time stretching & pitch shifting, changing the sound volume, dynamics compression, trimming and DA/AD conversion including microphone recording.

-- Matt Brown - Haulix




RE: Keubiko - admin - 09-04-2014

["Dear Author: You're making a few blind assumptions about us in this thread. I wouldn't expect anyone from Destiny Media to have experienced the web-based Haulix encoding process because that would require a paid subscription. With that said, our watermarks are inaudible and withstand mp3 encoding, time stretching & pitch shifting, changing the sound volume, dynamics compression, trimming and DA/AD conversion including microphone recording.


-- Matt Brown - Haulix"]

Well, I'm sure your product is fine and can do a lot but the question was whether Haulix can do everything that PlayMPE can do.

Timing is somewhat curious as Keubiko made a similar comment just two hours ago on our SA article, and how would he know as you suggest it requires a paid subscription to your product.

Even more curoius is that:

In any case my working assumption is they keep their PlayMPE business.

But why? He produced several lengthy articles arguing it's a bloated expensive legacy product for which cheaper (Haulix!) alternatives exist and there are basically no switching cost. Does he actually trust his own analysis?




RE: Keubiko - admin - 09-13-2014

Keubiko argues that he stands by his analysis: 

I believe everything I've written 100%. Nor do I view it as contradictory, but that has been beaten to death.

Panic Selling In Destiny Media Is Unwarranted - Destiny Media Technologies, Inc. (OTCMKTSBig GrinSNY) | Seeking Alpha

Yea, right. Nothing We've written above points to any contradiction, and this is just the stuff about PlayMPE. Which leads us to more nonsense.

9. Clipstream already failed

He argued (and still does, with heaps of sofistry) that Clipstream has already failed. Here is the reality:

  • The company has identified some two dozen verticals for which Clipstream can be used
  • This often needs substantial customization (for instance, the ad vertical must be enabled to accomodate real-time reporting and auctions, the market research vertical needed the security update, etc.)
  • NONE of these verticals has really launched yet
  • What has launched is a self-uploader cloud hoster, but this had some problems (caused by ISP throttling) compromising speed or quality for some users. It also doesn't have a more sophisticated corporate billing system
  • This isn't unusual in software. Stuff gets out and bugs are discovered, usability issues, etc. See what happened to the Obamacare website. First it didn't even work at all. Now it does. Software is complex.
  • It takes time to fix this stuff, they are a small outfit. Frustrating, yes. Did it take longer than we anticipated, yes. Failed? No, certainly not yet. Jury still out.
  • Slowly but surely they're getting there:
    • There is a security update which is an important ingredient for several market verticals
    • The ISP throttling problem is getting fixed
    • They've hired Dale Borland from Microsoft as a COO for Clipstream

Has it failed? No, actually the truth is that it has hardly started. Will it succeed? We don't know for sure, but we think that Clipstream has enough advantages (advantages you would know absolutely nothing about by reading Keubiko's articles) for it to be successful in at least a few of the verticals, and consider this:

  • The market cap is under $35M
  • The streaming video market is vast (billions rather than millions) and fast growing
  • There isn't a single streaming standard
  • Since the market is so vast and margins on Clipstream are high, they need only a tiny sliver of the market for this to translate into meaningful numbers for shareholders.
  • You might also want to realize that they have plenty of contacts, for instance in the market research and ad markets and of course in the music world, contacts which actually help customizing and tailoring the product for specified end needs in market verticals.



RE: Keubiko - admin - 09-15-2014

10. Battery Drain

In his first article (only available to subscribers) he argued that Clipstream has a big disadvantage because unlike other solutions that use dedictated codec chips, Clipstream streams are processed by the CPU, which takes a lot of processing power and therefore it would be draining on the battery. He kept repeating this, for instance in his latest article:

The new version (Clipstream "G2"Wink uses JavaScript, so rather than using a plug-in or applet the browser (chewing up a lot of CPU cycles and hitting batter life on any laptop or mobile device for video of any length) renders the video.
The reality:
There are a few issues here:
  • Dedicated codec chips are handy, but less so a world where there are multiple video standards like today. For instance, your dedicated H.264 chip will not be able to decode H.265. Clipstream, relying on generic CPU and HTML5 complient browsers, has no such problems with any of that
  • Yes, relying on CPU is, needless to say, taxing CPU more.
  • The question is whether this is really taxing the battery. We were curious ourselves, so we took a test, with a 4 year old first generation Core i5 powered laptop with particularly poor battey life (less than 2 hours). We compared battery drain from constantly repeating Clipstream videos from the Destiny website, and compared that to doing the same with videos from YouTube. We also kept an eye on CPU usage.
  • Looking at CPU usage, we saw only fractional higher use when playing Clipstream. Battery drain wasn't noticable faster.
  • Important to realize is that this is a test running streams full-time, and we couldn't find a difference then.
  • We're sure that running Clipstream clips, like ads for say 30 second, it's completely irrelevant.
  • So we couldn't detect much, if any difference on a laptop. You might also realize that there are a couple of reasons why this is much less a problem on mobile phones (and to a certain extent tablets):
    • Few people watch feature length streamed movies on their mobile phones.
    • There is a lot more stuff in your mobile phone taxing the battery, radio chips, GPS, Bluetooth, WiFi, gyroscopes and other movement tracking chips, etc., making taxing the GPU less of a battery drain problem, relatively.
    • Mobile GPU's are mostly the very energy efficient ARM design chips.
Yet Keubiko continues to argue it is a problem
We couldn't detect more battery taxing when running Clipstream versus YouTube on a relatively old laptop. But don't believe us, TEST IT YOURSELF!



RE: Keubiko - ArtM72 - 09-15-2014

'admin' pid='49455' datel Wrote:

10. Battery Drain

In his first article (only available to subscribers) he argued that Clipstream has a big disadvantage because unlike other solutions that use dedictated codec chips, Clipstream streams are processed by the CPU, which takes a lot of processing power and therefore it would be draining on the battery. He kept repeating this, for instance in his latest article:

The new version (Clipstream "G2"Wink uses JavaScript, so rather than using a plug-in or applet the browser (chewing up a lot of CPU cycles and hitting batter life on any laptop or mobile device for video of any length) renders the video.
The reality:
There are a few issues here:
  • Dedicated codec chips are handy, but less so a world where there are multiple video standards like today. For instance, your dedicated H.264 chip will not be able to decode H.265. Clipstream, relying on generic CPU and HTML5 complient browsers, has no such problems with any of that
  • Yes, relying on CPU is, needless to say, taxing CPU more.
  • The question is whether this is really taxing the battery. We were curious ourselves, so we took a test, with a 4 year old first generation Core i5 powered laptop with particularly poor battey life (less than 2 hours). We compared battery drain from constantly repeating Clipstream videos from the Destiny website, and compared that to doing the same with videos from YouTube. We also kept an eye on CPU usage.
  • Looking at CPU usage, we saw only fractional higher use when playing Clipstream. Battery drain wasn't noticable faster.
  • Important to realize is that this is a test running streams full-time, and we couldn't find a difference then.
  • We're sure that running Clipstream clips, like ads for say 30 second, it's completely irrelevant.
  • So we couldn't detect much, if any difference on a laptop. You might also realize that there are a couple of reasons why this is much less a problem on mobile phones (and to a certain extent tablets):
    • Few people watch feature length streamed movies on their mobile phones.
    • There is a lot more stuff in your mobile phone taxing the battery, radio chips, GPS, Bluetooth, WiFi, gyroscopes and other movement tracking chips, etc., making taxing the GPU less of a battery drain problem, relatively.
    • Mobile GPU's are mostly the very energy efficient ARM design chips.
Yet Keubiko continues to argue it is a problem
We couldn't detect more battery taxing when running Clipstream versus YouTube on a relatively old laptop. But don't believe us, TEST IT YOURSELF!

INTC's new 14 nm Core M processors (and rumored 10 nm coming next year) should further mitigate battery and computing power concerns, especially as Intel steps with its heavy foot into the mobile computing business.




RE: Keubiko - admin - 09-16-2014

["INTC's new 14 nm Core M processors (and rumored 10 nm coming next year) should further mitigate battery and computing power concerns, especially as Intel steps with its heavy foot into the mobile computing business."]

Yea. The funny thing is, Art, that was going to be our next post here Smile




RE: Keubiko - admin - 09-16-2014

11. Moore's Law

Keubiko stresses Moore's law in a comment to one of our articles:

Transcoding is a red herring thanks to Moore's Law. Ditto for CDNs (content delivery networks) - don't need a CDN for a 15-second ad clip.

Has Destiny Media's Clipstream Product Failed? - Destiny Media Technologies, Inc. (OTCMKTSBig GrinSNY) | Seeking Alpha

We'll get to the content of that in another post, but if Moore's law is so important, why not admit it's effectiveness where Moore's law was intended, that is, getting more efficient chips (Moore's Law, after all, states that the number of transistors double every 18 months or so, exponentially increasing computing power and decreasing energy draw and cost). The new Intel chips are, once again, another big step forward:

Intel claims that Core M devices will offer 20 to 40 percent performance improvements, while system on chip (SoC) power could be cut by up to 45 percent, producing 60 percent less heat, which allows for fanless design.
Computex: Intel shows off Core M 2-in-1 reference designs [Video]- The Inquirer
As for power consumption, the power draw can go up to 6W, though Intel says the typical TDP for systems on the market will be 4.5W. As a result, the company claims you can expect up to 1.7 hours more battery life versus Haswell-Y depending on the use case, with the biggest gains coming from local 1080p video playback.
Intel's Core M chips will boost PC battery life by nearly two hours




RE: Keubiko - ArtM72 - 09-16-2014

'admin' pid='49499' datel Wrote:

["INTC's new 14 nm Core M processors (and rumored 10 nm coming next year) should further mitigate battery and computing power concerns, especially as Intel steps with its heavy foot into the mobile computing business."]

Yea. The funny thing is, Art, that was going to be our next post here Smile

First and last time I bet I get a chance to steal your thunder.Smile  You're far too quick (not to mention far more thorough and detailed)




RE: Keubiko - admin - 09-16-2014

'ArtM72' pid='49506' datel Wrote:

First and last time I bet I get a chance to steal your thunder.Smile  You're far too quick (not to mention far more thorough and detailed)

Steal as much thunder as you like, Art, no problem with that whatsoever.

As a side note, note how Keubiko stresses that content delivery networks are not only obfuscated by Moore's law (which is nonsense for the coming decade at least, needless to say), but not needed for 5 minute clips.

But do batteries drain from 5 minute clips? We couldn't even get them to drain more, compared to YouTube clips, when running constantly, so the battery drain argument is further obfuscated by his own logic.

He is a master in selective argumentation, but using his own logic (5 minute clips don't need content delivery networks), and apply it to another argument of his (Clipstream is draining batteries more than other streaming solutions) and you get contradictions galore.

It's bad faith reasoning, plain and simple. Moore's law, according to Keubiko, works only to make Clipstream advantages less significant, not the supposed disadvantages. It's more likely it's exactly the other way around.