ShareholdersUnite Forums
No Decision in Yukon - Printable Version

+- ShareholdersUnite Forums (http://shareholdersunite.com/mybb)
+-- Forum: Companies (http://shareholdersunite.com/mybb/forumdisplay.php?fid=1)
+--- Forum: InterOil Forum (http://shareholdersunite.com/mybb/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: No Decision in Yukon (/showthread.php?tid=11259)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6


RE: No Decision in Yukon - Northoil - 09-30-2016

[quote='2126' pid='76632' dateline='1475164945']

My take on what is happening in the Yukon court is simply that Phil has filed an objection and an application for a court appraisal. Under Yukon law, a dissent is essentially an 'objection' to the actions of the BOD in approving the sale of IOC assets. This current court hearing is the first opportunity for Phil to formally object to the Exxon/IOC Arrangement being approved by the BOD. I would imagine that he has filed a formal legal version of the details of his 'black book' presentation that he has previously posted on his webiste: concernedinteroilshareholders.com. By outlining his arguments as to why he objects to the BOD decision to sell the company, he provides the court with the reasons why a court-ordered appraisal should be required to accurately value the company. Exxon and IOC will argue that the market says the valuation is correct, but, again, Phil's argument is probably that net asset value, rather than market value, is the correct method of valuation.

I don't expect the court's review to take very long. The Yukon court, by statute, has a number of actions that it can take in a dissent/objection situation:

  • It can join all dissenters into one group
  • It can provide for a full trial on the issue of valuation
  • It can appoint independent appraisers to value the company

Finally, Exxon/IOC, again by Yukon statute, and unless the court orders otherwise, Exxon/IOC has 10 days from Phil's [or any other dissenter's] application for a court-ordered appraisal, to 'send to each dissenting shareholder a written offer to pay an amount considered by the directors to be the fair value of the shares' and such offer must include 'a statement showing how fair value was determined.'

I do not believe that the Final Order and the closing/effective date of the sale will be held up by this 10 day period.

_____________________________________________________________

2126 –What we know from the IOC website is that PM has filed an objection.  That’s all we know.  Do you know for a fact that he filed an objection AND an application for a court appraisal?

You said: “a dissent is essentially an 'objection’ ” While a “dissent” may be, in plain English, considered an objection, I’m not sure plain English applies in the reverse case.  I.e., I would think an “objection” can be many things separate from the dissent process, and perhaps part of a legal strategy or even necessity of one step at a time.  I may be all wet, but, wouldn’t the court have to deal with the objection first, before moving on to the valuation issue?

In the case of dissent, I agree the sale moves on and should have no effect on the Final Order and Effective Date.  In the case of objection (for whatever reason and grounds), everything stops, which seems to be the case.

I hope we hear what the fair value offer is.  You know what I think.




RE: No Decision in Yukon - 2126 - 09-30-2016

'Northoil' pid='76648' datel Wrote:

[quote='2126' pid='76632' dateline='1475164945']

My take on what is happening in the Yukon court is simply that Phil has filed an objection and an application for a court appraisal. Under Yukon law, a dissent is essentially an 'objection' to the actions of the BOD in approving the sale of IOC assets. This current court hearing is the first opportunity for Phil to formally object to the Exxon/IOC Arrangement being approved by the BOD. I would imagine that he has filed a formal legal version of the details of his 'black book' presentation that he has previously posted on his webiste: concernedinteroilshareholders.com. By outlining his arguments as to why he objects to the BOD decision to sell the company, he provides the court with the reasons why a court-ordered appraisal should be required to accurately value the company. Exxon and IOC will argue that the market says the valuation is correct, but, again, Phil's argument is probably that net asset value, rather than market value, is the correct method of valuation.

I don't expect the court's review to take very long. The Yukon court, by statute, has a number of actions that it can take in a dissent/objection situation:

  • It can join all dissenters into one group
  • It can provide for a full trial on the issue of valuation
  • It can appoint independent appraisers to value the company

Finally, Exxon/IOC, again by Yukon statute, and unless the court orders otherwise, Exxon/IOC has 10 days from Phil's [or any other dissenter's] application for a court-ordered appraisal, to 'send to each dissenting shareholder a written offer to pay an amount considered by the directors to be the fair value of the shares' and such offer must include 'a statement showing how fair value was determined.'

I do not believe that the Final Order and the closing/effective date of the sale will be held up by this 10 day period.

_____________________________________________________________

2126 –What we know from the IOC website is that PM has filed an objection.  That’s all we know.  Do you know for a fact that he filed an objection AND an application for a court appraisal?

You said: “a dissent is essentially an 'objection’ ” While a “dissent” may be, in plain English, considered an objection, I’m not sure plain English applies in the reverse case.  I.e., I would think an “objection” can be many things separate from the dissent process, and perhaps part of a legal strategy or even necessity of one step at a time.  I may be all wet, but, wouldn’t the court have to deal with the objection first, before moving on to the valuation issue?

In the case of dissent, I agree the sale moves on and should have no effect on the Final Order and Effective Date.  In the case of objection (for whatever reason and grounds), everything stops, which seems to be the case.

I hope we hear what the fair value offer is.  You know what I think.

A dissent is legally an 'objection'-- not just in plain English. One files a "Notice of Objection" with the corporation whose BOD has taken an action that one disagrees with. As we know from his earlier press release that Phil has, in fact, dissented, [which means that he has filed an "objection" with IOC], the only way that he gets his say in this court hearing is to file an "application" for appraisal based on his dissent/objection to the actions of the IOC BOD, as he is not a party to this actual hearing, which is brought by Exxon and IOC to obtain a Final Order from the court on the Arrangement. The court can only deal with a dissent/objection after a dissenter files an application for a fair value appraisal. Then the court may take the further steps that I mentioned in my above post [note that the court has the power take other actions as well, such as collecting the dissenters shares, issuing interim orders, etc.]. This is all laid out in the Yukon statutes on corporate dissents.




RE: No Decision in Yukon - ebster123 - 09-30-2016

2126, first thanks for your work. Can PM's action support a re-appraisal that can help us all (no votes included)?


RE: No Decision in Yukon - AU74 - 09-30-2016

I'm really getting quite peeved at this delay. The court is supposed to be protecting our interests, but conducts effectively secret hearings with unexplained multi-day delays. Either get it done or take off the gag orders and let the two sides speak.


RE: No Decision in Yukon - CAC - 10-01-2016

'2126' pid='76649' datel Wrote:

[quote='Northoil' pid='76648' dateline='1475185365']

[quote='2126' pid='76632' dateline='1475164945']

My take on what is happening in the Yukon court is simply that Phil has filed an objection and an application for a court appraisal. Under Yukon law, a dissent is essentially an 'objection' to the actions of the BOD in approving the sale of IOC assets. This current court hearing is the first opportunity for Phil to formally object to the Exxon/IOC Arrangement being approved by the BOD. I would imagine that he has filed a formal legal version of the details of his 'black book' presentation that he has previously posted on his webiste: concernedinteroilshareholders.com. By outlining his arguments as to why he objects to the BOD decision to sell the company, he provides the court with the reasons why a court-ordered appraisal should be required to accurately value the company. Exxon and IOC will argue that the market says the valuation is correct, but, again, Phil's argument is probably that net asset value, rather than market value, is the correct method of valuation.

I don't expect the court's review to take very long. The Yukon court, by statute, has a number of actions that it can take in a dissent/objection situation:

  • It can join all dissenters into one group
  • It can provide for a full trial on the issue of valuation
  • It can appoint independent appraisers to value the company

Finally, Exxon/IOC, again by Yukon statute, and unless the court orders otherwise, Exxon/IOC has 10 days from Phil's [or any other dissenter's] application for a court-ordered appraisal, to 'send to each dissenting shareholder a written offer to pay an amount considered by the directors to be the fair value of the shares' and such offer must include 'a statement showing how fair value was determined.'

I do not believe that the Final Order and the closing/effective date of the sale will be held up by this 10 day period.

_____________________________________________________________

2126 –What we know from the IOC website is that PM has filed an objection.  That’s all we know.  Do you know for a fact that he filed an objection AND an application for a court appraisal?

You said: “a dissent is essentially an 'objection’ ” While a “dissent” may be, in plain English, considered an objection, I’m not sure plain English applies in the reverse case.  I.e., I would think an “objection” can be many things separate from the dissent process, and perhaps part of a legal strategy or even necessity of one step at a time.  I may be all wet, but, wouldn’t the court have to deal with the objection first, before moving on to the valuation issue?

In the case of dissent, I agree the sale moves on and should have no effect on the Final Order and Effective Date.  In the case of objection (for whatever reason and grounds), everything stops, which seems to be the case.

I hope we hear what the fair value offer is.  You know what I think.

A dissent is legally an 'objection'-- not just in plain English. One files a "Notice of Objection" with the corporation whose BOD has taken an action that one disagrees with. As we know from his earlier press release that Phil has, in fact, dissented, [which means that he has filed an "objection" with IOC], the only way that he gets his say in this court hearing is to file an "application" for appraisal based on his dissent/objection to the actions of the IOC BOD, as he is not a party to this actual hearing, which is brought by Exxon and IOC to obtain a Final Order from the court on the Arrangement. The court can only deal with a dissent/objection after a dissenter files an application for a fair value appraisal. Then the court may take the further steps that I mentioned in my above post [note that the court has the power take other actions as well, such as collecting the dissenters shares, issuing interim orders, etc.]. This is all laid out in the Yukon statutes on corporate dissents.

******
I read the statute to require an offer 10 days from the time IOC receives notice that an "Application" has been filed in the Yukon Supreme Court.  I initially read the statute to authorize the Application to be filed in the Supreme Court after approval of the deal (which has not happened yet), but it actually says after the "adoption of the resolution".  I do not think the the "Notice of Objection", by itself, triggers anything.  I think it is just a prerequisite to filing the Application.  I do not know what consists of an "adoption of the resolution".  If that means "Court approval", then an Application may not be ripe yet.  It is also possible that the Supreme Court considers PM's "objection" to be the functional equivalent of an "Application"...but I'm not sure. 




RE: No Decision in Yukon - Getitrt2 - 10-01-2016

If they are going to delay the closing much longer, they probably should freeze the XOM conversion price if possible.


RE: No Decision in Yukon - Gator - 10-01-2016

'Getitrt2' pid='76655' datel Wrote:If they are going to delay the closing much longer, they probably should freeze the XOM conversion price if possible.

Great suggestion. While "they" are at it, lets just let them change all the terms of the deal that over 80% of shareholders voted for. We could make it $55 in ExxonMobil stock, $9.09 per Tcfe over 5 Tcfe with no cap.  I bet that would almost get you back to even.




RE: No Decision in Yukon - 2126 - 10-01-2016

(10-01-2016, 12:49 AM)CAC Wrote:

I read the statute to require an offer 10 days from the time IOC receives notice that an "Application" has been filed in the Yukon Supreme Court.  I initially read the statute to authorize the Application to be filed in the Supreme Court after approval of the deal (which has not happened yet), but it actually says after the "adoption of the resolution".  I do not think the the "Notice of Objection", by itself, triggers anything.  I think it is just a prerequisite to filing the Application.  I do not know what consists of an "adoption of the resolution".  If that means "Court approval", then an Application may not be ripe yet.  It is also possible that the Supreme Court considers PM's "objection" to be the functional equivalent of an "Application"...but I'm not sure. 

You are correct that the statute provides for filing the application for fair value after the 'adoption of the resolution.' This refers to the original resolution by the BOD to which a dissenter is objecting. In our case, this is the IOC BOD resolution accepting the Exxon bid. You are also correct that the filing of a 'Notice of Objection' by a shareholder does not actually trigger anything--other than the fact that one or more shareholders have objected/dissented from the BOD resolution. As I noted, this particular court hearing is Phil's first opportunity to get his arguments against the BOD resolution [which accepted the Exxon bid] before the court. In order to do that, I am assuming that he has filed the requisite 'application' with the court, as my reading of the statute indicates that this is the only prerequisite for his appearance before the court.

Additionally, the delay caused by Phil's objection is, I believe, because this is the first time that the Yukon court has had before it the various documents that support Phil's [and our] arguments that this deal is not a fair value for our shares. These documents would include, importantly, the Total/IOC SPA, and the many IOC press releases, conference call transcripts, AGM minutes, quarterly reports, corporate bylaws, and other IOC documents that indicate that Hession and the BOD continually told shareholders of the immense value of both E/A, but also the perceived value of the other IOC holdings, and discoveries, all of which were given no value in this deal. As it has taken this board many hundreds of postings and several years to wade through all of this material to uncover the machinations by the BOD and CEO that has led us to this situation, it will take the court some time to wade through all of this information to see what has been going on at IOC.

Most of us agree with the arguments that Phil has propounded regarding the IOC management's mendacity and insider dealings. While this delay may cause the 10-day pps weighted average for XOM to rise, it may be worth it if the court accepts Phil's arguments. As IOC is incorporated in the Yukon Territory, the court has jurisdiction over this entire deal, not just the dissent portion. It has the power to stop the deal; the power to change the deal; and the power to hold Hession and the BOD accountable for their misrepresentations, double-dealing, insider trading, malfeasance, and more. I suggest we be patient and allow the wheels of justice to begin to turn and, finally, shine a light on this entire sordid situation.




RE: No Decision in Yukon - sageo - 10-01-2016

'2126' pid='76658' datel Wrote:

'CAC' pid='76653' datel Wrote:

I read the statute to require an offer 10 days from the time IOC receives notice that an "Application" has been filed in the Yukon Supreme Court.  I initially read the statute to authorize the Application to be filed in the Supreme Court after approval of the deal (which has not happened yet), but it actually says after the "adoption of the resolution".  I do not think the the "Notice of Objection", by itself, triggers anything.  I think it is just a prerequisite to filing the Application.  I do not know what consists of an "adoption of the resolution".  If that means "Court approval", then an Application may not be ripe yet.  It is also possible that the Supreme Court considers PM's "objection" to be the functional equivalent of an "Application"...but I'm not sure. 

You are correct that the statute provides for filing the application for fair value after the 'adoption of the resolution.' This refers to the original resolution by the BOD to which a dissenter is objecting. In our case, this is the IOC BOD resolution accepting the Exxon bid. You are also correct that the filing of a 'Notice of Objection' by a shareholder does not actually trigger anything--other than the fact that one or more shareholders have objected/dissented from the BOD resolution. As I noted, this particular court hearing is Phil's first opportunity to get his arguments against the BOD resolution [which accepted the Exxon bid] before the court. In order to do that, I am assuming that he has filed the requisite 'application' with the court, as my reading of the statute indicates that this is the only prerequisite for his appearance before the court.

Additionally, the delay caused by Phil's objection is, I believe, because this is the first time that the Yukon court has had before it the various documents that support Phil's [and our] arguments that this deal is not a fair value for our shares. These documents would include, importantly, the Total/IOC SPA, and the many IOC press releases, conference call transcripts, AGM minutes, quarterly reports, corporate bylaws, and other IOC documents that indicate that Hession and the BOD continually told shareholders of the immense value of both E/A, but also the perceived value of the other IOC holdings, and discoveries, all of which were given no value in this deal. As it has taken this board many hundreds of postings and several years to wade through all of this material to uncover the machinations by the BOD and CEO that has led us to this situation, it will take the court some time to wade through all of this information to see what has been going on at IOC.

Most of us agree with the arguments that Phil has propounded regarding the IOC management's mendacity and insider dealings. While this delay may cause the 10-day pps weighted average for XOM to rise, it may be worth it if the court accepts Phil's arguments. As IOC is incorporated in the Yukon Territory, the court has jurisdiction over this entire deal, not just the dissent portion. It has the power to stop the deal; the power to change the deal; and the power to hold Hession and the BOD accountable for their misrepresentations, double-dealing, insider trading, malfeasance, and more. I suggest we be patient and allow the wheels of justice to begin to turn and, finally, shine a light on this entire sordid situation.

My thanks to you, 2126 !  While mh and our bods are guilty of a heck of a lot more, Exxon is at the very least, guilty of attempted theft !!! <img src=" border="0" class="smilie" src="http://shareholdersunite.com/mybb/images/smilies/sad.gif" />

Your health seems to be improving . If that is the case,praise to the "Almighty " <img src=" border="0" class="smilie" src="http://shareholdersunite.com/mybb/images/smilies/smile.gif" />




RE: No Decision in Yukon - Kaliboo - 10-01-2016

'2126' pid='76658' dateline='<a href="tel:1475257 Wrote:

'CAC' pid='76653' dateline='<a href="tel:1475246 Wrote:

I read the statute to require an offer 10 days from the time IOC receives notice that an "Application" has been filed in the Yukon Supreme Court.  I initially read the statute to authorize the Application to be filed in the Supreme Court after approval of the deal (which has not happened yet), but it actually says after the "adoption of the resolution".  I do not think the the "Notice of Objection", by itself, triggers anything.  I think it is just a prerequisite to filing the Application.  I do not know what consists of an "adoption of the resolution".  If that means "Court approval", then an Application may not be ripe yet.  It is also possible that the Supreme Court considers PM's "objection" to be the functional equivalent of an "Application"...but I'm not sure. 

You are correct that the statute provides for filing the application for fair value after the 'adoption of the resolution.' This refers to the original resolution by the BOD to which a dissenter is objecting. In our case, this is the IOC BOD resolution accepting the Exxon bid. You are also correct that the filing of a 'Notice of Objection' by a shareholder does not actually trigger anything--other than the fact that one or more shareholders have objected/dissented from the BOD resolution. As I noted, this particular court hearing is Phil's first opportunity to get his arguments against the BOD resolution [which accepted the Exxon bid] before the court. In order to do that, I am assuming that he has filed the requisite 'application' with the court, as my reading of the statute indicates that this is the only prerequisite for his appearance before the court.

Additionally, the delay caused by Phil's objection is, I believe, because this is the first time that the Yukon court has had before it the various documents that support Phil's [and our] arguments that this deal is not a fair value for our shares. These documents would include, importantly, the Total/IOC SPA, and the many IOC press releases, conference call transcripts, AGM minutes, quarterly reports, corporate bylaws, and other IOC documents that indicate that Hession and the BOD continually told shareholders of the immense value of both E/A, but also the perceived value of the other IOC holdings, and discoveries, all of which were given no value in this deal. As it has taken this board many hundreds of postings and several years to wade through all of this material to uncover the machinations by the BOD and CEO that has led us to this situation, it will take the court some time to wade through all of this information to see what has been going on at IOC.

Most of us agree with the arguments that Phil has propounded regarding the IOC management's mendacity and insider dealings. While this delay may cause the 10-day pps weighted average for XOM to rise, it may be worth it if the court accepts Phil's arguments. As IOC is incorporated in the Yukon Territory, the court has jurisdiction over this entire deal, not just the dissent portion. It has the power to stop the deal; the power to change the deal; and the power to hold Hession and the BOD accountable for their misrepresentations, double-dealing, insider trading, malfeasance, and more. I suggest we be patient and allow the wheels of justice to begin to turn and, finally, shine a light on this entire sordid situation.

Thanks 2126.  This is the best news I've heard for shareholders since the deal was first proposed by OSH.  But I would find it hard to believe that the court would reverse a deal which was accepted by 80+% of voting shareholders and which was viewed as a superior offer to the first deal.  Unless of course Phil makes the point that accepting the deal was the best way out of two very bad choices.  Also the same shareholders put/kept in place this BOD that has engineered all of tthis.  And some dummy financial company said, after all, "the deal is fair" as required by Yukon law.  I'm sceptical, but glad a real attorney on this MB thinks there is still hope of a more equitable outcome for all shareholders; not just dissenters.  The drama of the last chapter continues to the climactic event that no one could have imagined......just adding a closing comment to the mystery novel.  In the meantime we are getting less XOM shares.