ShareholdersUnite Forums
IOC updates ICCC on purchase - Printable Version

+- ShareholdersUnite Forums (http://shareholdersunite.com/mybb)
+-- Forum: Companies (http://shareholdersunite.com/mybb/forumdisplay.php?fid=1)
+--- Forum: InterOil Forum (http://shareholdersunite.com/mybb/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: IOC updates ICCC on purchase (/showthread.php?tid=11719)

Pages: 1 2


IOC updates ICCC on purchase - Li'loilady - 01-23-2017

It's hard for me to believe that PNG would stand in XOM's way in this acquisition but....

From PNG's  "The National".

Firm updates ICCC on purchase

INTEROIL executive director Isikeli Taureka has provided the Independent Consumer and Competition Commission with additional information to assist it in its assessment of the company’s acquisition by ExxonMobil.
ICCC chief executive officer Paulus Ain said in a statement yesterday senior officials from InterOil met with him yesterday for an update on the progress of ExxonMobil’s proposed acquisition of InterOil’s interests.
Ain thanked Taureka (pictured) for paying a courtesy call on ICCC and for InterOil’s transparent conduct of complying with the provisions of the ICCC Act in providing information since the ICCC began its investigation into the proposed acquisition last year.
The continued corporation and assistance provided by InterOil and its partners through their senior officials had benefited the ICCC assessments of the proposed acquisition.
“The ICCC encourages similar cooperation from other local and foreign businesses in Papua New Guinea who are in the process of undertaking mergers and acquisitions to ensure that they comply with the provisions of the ICCC Act,” he said.
“Businesses who fail to seek either a clearance or authorisation from the ICCC for a merger or acquisition, will be liable for penalties under the ICCC Act if the ICCC determines that the merger or acquisition is anticipative.”
The ICCC is conducting its own investigation and assesment into ExxonMobil’s proposed acquisition of InterOil and would inform all parties after completion.
http://www.thenational.com.pg/firm-updates-iccc-purchase/



RE: IOC updates ICCC on purchase - Stavros - 01-23-2017

ExxonMobil's ownership of 30+% of PNG LNG & 30+% of Papua LNG & a high percentage of the resources in the Highlands & ALL OF IOC's other acreages can certainly be a position that negatively impacts competition in PNG.

EM should be acquiring ONLY IOC's remaining holding in Elk/Antelope - - - the rest should be retained by a smaller IOC WITHOUT THE CRIMINAL HESSION.


RE: IOC updates ICCC on purchase - Northoil - 01-24-2017

'Stavros' pid='79109' datel Wrote:ExxonMobil's ownership of 30+% of PNG LNG & 30+% of Papua LNG & a high percentage of the resources in the Highlands & ALL OF IOC's other acreages can certainly be a position that negatively impacts competition in PNG. EM should be acquiring ONLY IOC's remaining holding in Elk/Antelope - - - the rest should be retained by a smaller IOC WITHOUT THE CRIMINAL HESSION.

_____________________________________________________________________________

You can’t compare consumer/competition groups in PNG with similar watchdogs in developed countries.  To imagine the “I”in ICCC is truly Independent is a little optimistic.

PNG is a poor, 3rd world country.  They’re not doing bad compared to most Pacific island nations, but that’s because of oil and gas.  For the last 30 years or so, they have used a strategy of encouraging exploration through smaller independents.  The small companies take acreage nobody wants, do some work, develop some prospects, maybe take partners and drill.  Maybe make a discovery (see below  **), then try to interest larger companies to fund the development.  That’s pretty much the story with IOC.

Gas is a special case.  LNG requires massive capital, expertise and market credibility with end users, none of which IOC has.  Hessian was brought in TO SELL THE COMPANY, was given a large incentive to do so, so he did.  Many people don’t like the price, but there were only a few interested buyers (who just happened to have LNG facilities) and an uncertain pricing outlook.

I don’t know what the price should have been or what the dissent path will result in, but I’m pretty sure the PNG ministries and politicians are sick to death of IOC and Phil.  PNG needs XOM or someone similar to take over and begin development.  If the deal is approved by shareholders and the Yukon courts, notwithstanding the sideshow of ongoing dissent, the ICCC will approve the deal.

The thought of splitting IOC’s interests and IOC’s continuing exploration is total fancy.  Many say we got nothing for the other discoveries and future exploration potential.  That’s not true.  Exxon put a value on each piece, and that was embedded in their offer.  We just don’t like the price.  No way will the deal be broken up.

** Finally, a view about PM’s exploratory genius.  I hate to say it, and in spite of the staggering technology that goes into it, exploration in new basins is a crap-shoot.  I compare it to the game at the carnival where everyone is throwing darts at a wall of balloons, except from 100 feet away.  Throw enough darts and someone will hit a balloon.  In exploration, that person is hailed as a genius, an inborn “oil finder” who can repeat the success at will.  Hah!

I will say PM was a good salesman.  It’s just that no one seems to be very excited about these additional “discoveries” which were probably over-hyped anyway.  Another case of declining reserve estimates?




RE: IOC updates ICCC on purchase - wapitidropiti - 01-24-2017

'Northoil' pid='79114' datel Wrote:

'Stavros' pid='79109' datel Wrote:ExxonMobil's ownership of 30+% of PNG LNG & 30+% of Papua LNG & a high percentage of the resources in the Highlands & ALL OF IOC's other acreages can certainly be a position that negatively impacts competition in PNG. EM should be acquiring ONLY IOC's remaining holding in Elk/Antelope - - - the rest should be retained by a smaller IOC WITHOUT THE CRIMINAL HESSION.

_____________________________________________________________________________

You can’t compare consumer/competition groups in PNG with similar watchdogs in developed countries.  To imagine the “I”in ICCC is truly Independent is a little optimistic.

PNG is a poor, 3rd world country.  They’re not doing bad compared to most Pacific island nations, but that’s because of oil and gas.  For the last 30 years or so, they have used a strategy of encouraging exploration through smaller independents.  The small companies take acreage nobody wants, do some work, develop some prospects, maybe take partners and drill.  Maybe make a discovery (see below  **), then try to interest larger companies to fund the development.  That’s pretty much the story with IOC.

Gas is a special case.  LNG requires massive capital, expertise and market credibility with end users, none of which IOC has.  Hessian was brought in TO SELL THE COMPANY, was given a large incentive to do so, so he did.  Many people don’t like the price, but there were only a few interested buyers (who just happened to have LNG facilities) and an uncertain pricing outlook.

I don’t know what the price should have been or what the dissent path will result in, but I’m pretty sure the PNG ministries and politicians are sick to death of IOC and Phil.  PNG needs XOM or someone similar to take over and begin development.  If the deal is approved by shareholders and the Yukon courts, notwithstanding the sideshow of ongoing dissent, the ICCC will approve the deal.

The thought of splitting IOC’s interests and IOC’s continuing exploration is total fancy.  Many say we got nothing for the other discoveries and future exploration potential.  That’s not true.  Exxon put a value on each piece, and that was embedded in their offer.  We just don’t like the price.  No way will the deal be broken up.

** Finally, a view about PM’s exploratory genius.  I hate to say it, and in spite of the staggering technology that goes into it, exploration in new basins is a crap-shoot.  I compare it to the game at the carnival where everyone is throwing darts at a wall of balloons, except from 100 feet away.  Throw enough darts and someone will hit a balloon.  In exploration, that person is hailed as a genius, an inborn “oil finder” who can repeat the success at will.  Hah!

I will say PM was a good salesman.  It’s just that no one seems to be very excited about these additional “discoveries” which were probably over-hyped anyway.  Another case of declining reserve estimates?

Well said and sadly all true. Do you still hold? Are you dissenting?




RE: IOC updates ICCC on purchase - Northoil - 01-24-2017

'wapitidropiti' pid='79116' datel Wrote:

'Northoil' pid='79114' datel Wrote:

[quote='Stavros' pid='79109' dateline='1485161829'] ExxonMobil's ownership of 30+% of PNG LNG & 30+% of Papua LNG & a high percentage of the resources in the Highlands & ALL OF IOC's other acreages can certainly be a position that negatively impacts competition in PNG. EM should be acquiring ONLY IOC's remaining holding in Elk/Antelope - - - the rest should be retained by a smaller IOC WITHOUT THE CRIMINAL HESSION.

_____________________________________________________________________________

You can’t compare consumer/competition groups in PNG with similar watchdogs in developed countries.  To imagine the “I”in ICCC is truly Independent is a little optimistic.

PNG is a poor, 3rd world country.  They’re not doing bad compared to most Pacific island nations, but that’s because of oil and gas.  For the last 30 years or so, they have used a strategy of encouraging exploration through smaller independents.  The small companies take acreage nobody wants, do some work, develop some prospects, maybe take partners and drill.  Maybe make a discovery (see below  **), then try to interest larger companies to fund the development.  That’s pretty much the story with IOC.

Gas is a special case.  LNG requires massive capital, expertise and market credibility with end users, none of which IOC has.  Hessian was brought in TO SELL THE COMPANY, was given a large incentive to do so, so he did.  Many people don’t like the price, but there were only a few interested buyers (who just happened to have LNG facilities) and an uncertain pricing outlook.

I don’t know what the price should have been or what the dissent path will result in, but I’m pretty sure the PNG ministries and politicians are sick to death of IOC and Phil.  PNG needs XOM or someone similar to take over and begin development.  If the deal is approved by shareholders and the Yukon courts, notwithstanding the sideshow of ongoing dissent, the ICCC will approve the deal.

The thought of splitting IOC’s interests and IOC’s continuing exploration is total fancy.  Many say we got nothing for the other discoveries and future exploration potential.  That’s not true.  Exxon put a value on each piece, and that was embedded in their offer.  We just don’t like the price.  No way will the deal be broken up.

** Finally, a view about PM’s exploratory genius.  I hate to say it, and in spite of the staggering technology that goes into it, exploration in new basins is a crap-shoot.  I compare it to the game at the carnival where everyone is throwing darts at a wall of balloons, except from 100 feet away.  Throw enough darts and someone will hit a balloon.  In exploration, that person is hailed as a genius, an inborn “oil finder” who can repeat the success at will.  Hah!

I will say PM was a good salesman.  It’s just that no one seems to be very excited about these additional “discoveries” which were probably over-hyped anyway.  Another case of declining reserve estimates?

Well said and sadly all true. Do you still hold? Are you dissenting?

_______________________________________________________

I sold out close to 18K shares  between 49 and 50, before the first shareholder vote.  While I was intrigued by the contingent right, PNG is a geologic dog's breakfast and A7 results -so far- are not a huge surprise.  So, I don't put my faith or money in appraisal wells(take the cash and let the credit go.)  I still have March 50 and 60 options, which are probably a dead loss although A7 still has life.

I've opined many times on the dissent option.  The NPV argument is so full of holes it's difficult to know where to start.  This is not the US or even the Yukon.  This is gas that has no possible use except in one of two LNG facilities.  One owner has outbid the other.  If the judge recognizes that (having cured the major deficiency of an independent fairness opinion), it could be game over.  So you get $45 and maybe some CRP upside.  If the NPV argument holds (which I don't believe) then NPV of what?  Stranded gas?  Exploration potential? What price, what time period, what discount factor, what's the asset worth in the first place?  Exxon will challenge every shareholder's status, every assumption.  Then there's time.  It's not going to be fast.  The deal will go forward while Exxon will challenge, delay, bring in expert witnesses, continue, appeal , delay -the dissent could go for years.   In the meantime, the yes and the no votes will immediately get their $45 in Exxon stock, which is a great price now and which has made 15%/yr since John D. Rockefeller, while the dissenters tie up their money and wait to see if their ship comes in.  I wish the dissenters well and everything I said could be wrong.  But I'm taking the IOC money and putting it in the Permian Basin amd maybe Northern Dynasty.




RE: IOC updates ICCC on purchase - Kaliboo - 01-25-2017

'Northoil' pid='79124' dateline='<a href="tel:1485224 Wrote:

'wapitidropiti' pid='79116' dateline='<a href="tel:1485189 Wrote:

'Northoil' pid='79114' dateline='<a href="tel:1485184 Wrote:

[quote='Stavros' pid='79109' dateline='1485161829'] ExxonMobil's ownership of 30+% of PNG LNG & 30+% of Papua LNG & a high percentage of the resources in the Highlands & ALL OF IOC's other acreages can certainly be a position that negatively impacts competition in PNG. EM should be acquiring ONLY IOC's remaining holding in Elk/Antelope - - - the rest should be retained by a smaller IOC WITHOUT THE CRIMINAL HESSION.

_____________________________________________________________________________

You can’t compare consumer/competition groups in PNG with similar watchdogs in developed countries.  To imagine the “I”in ICCC is truly Independent is a little optimistic.

PNG is a poor, 3rd world country.  They’re not doing bad compared to most Pacific island nations, but that’s because of oil and gas.  For the last 30 years or so, they have used a strategy of encouraging exploration through smaller independents.  The small companies take acreage nobody wants, do some work, develop some prospects, maybe take partners and drill.  Maybe make a discovery (see below  **), then try to interest larger companies to fund the development.  That’s pretty much the story with IOC.

Gas is a special case.  LNG requires massive capital, expertise and market credibility with end users, none of which IOC has.  Hessian was brought in TO SELL THE COMPANY, was given a large incentive to do so, so he did.  Many people don’t like the price, but there were only a few interested buyers (who just happened to have LNG facilities) and an uncertain pricing outlook.

I don’t know what the price should have been or what the dissent path will result in, but I’m pretty sure the PNG ministries and politicians are sick to death of IOC and Phil.  PNG needs XOM or someone similar to take over and begin development.  If the deal is approved by shareholders and the Yukon courts, notwithstanding the sideshow of ongoing dissent, the ICCC will approve the deal.

The thought of splitting IOC’s interests and IOC’s continuing exploration is total fancy.  Many say we got nothing for the other discoveries and future exploration potential.  That’s not true.  Exxon put a value on each piece, and that was embedded in their offer.  We just don’t like the price.  No way will the deal be broken up.

** Finally, a view about PM’s exploratory genius.  I hate to say it, and in spite of the staggering technology that goes into it, exploration in new basins is a crap-shoot.  I compare it to the game at the carnival where everyone is throwing darts at a wall of balloons, except from 100 feet away.  Throw enough darts and someone will hit a balloon.  In exploration, that person is hailed as a genius, an inborn “oil finder” who can repeat the success at will.  Hah!

I will say PM was a good salesman.  It’s just that no one seems to be very excited about these additional “discoveries” which were probably over-hyped anyway.  Another case of declining reserve estimates?

Well said and sadly all true. Do you still hold? Are you dissenting?

_______________________________________________________

I sold out close to 18K shares  between 49 and 50, before the first shareholder vote.  While I was intrigued by the contingent right, PNG is a geologic dog's breakfast and A7 results -so far- are not a huge surprise.  So, I don't put my faith or money in appraisal wells(take the cash and let the credit go.)  I still have March 50 and 60 options, which are probably a dead loss although A7 still has life.

I've opined many times on the dissent option.  The NPV argument is so full of holes it's difficult to know where to start.  This is not the US or even the Yukon.  This is gas that has no possible use except in one of two LNG facilities.  One owner has outbid the other.  If the judge recognizes that (having cured the major deficiency of an independent fairness opinion), it could be game over.  So you get $45 and maybe some CRP upside.  If the NPV argument holds (which I don't believe) then NPV of what?  Stranded gas?  Exploration potential? What price, what time period, what discount factor, what's the asset worth in the first place?  Exxon will challenge every shareholder's status, every assumption.  Then there's time.  It's not going to be fast.  The deal will go forward while Exxon will challenge, delay, bring in expert witnesses, continue, appeal , delay -the dissent could go for years.   In the meantime, the yes and the no votes will immediately get their $45 in Exxon stock, which is a great price now and which has made 15%/yr since John D. Rockefeller, while the dissenters tie up their money and wait to see if their ship comes in.  I wish the dissenters well and everything I said could be wrong.  But I'm taking the IOC money and putting it in the Permian Basin amd maybe Northern Dynasty.

.

 Allow me to use this post to collect my thoughts.  I'm not trying to sway anyone.    I've put a tremendous amount of time into this dissent question, not to mention years of holding the stock and posting and reading posts on this board.  Looks like overall I will have a significant loss.  I talked to a lawyer at the firm representing PM.  She said this dissenting can cut both ways.  I.e., you can end up with more, the same or less.  Is she right?  Who knows?  The law seems to say that but is vague on the "less side" of it.

Problem 1 is I can't generate a high enough confidence that a case can be won on a higher valuation.  I just don't have specific information or knowledge to assemble that case.  I don't have knowledge as to how the court thinks and acts on these cases.

Problem 2 is I have no means to present the case.  Attempts so far to get representation have failed.  As 2126 noted - XOM, IOC and PM have them locked up.  I've talked to some of you via private message.  I may be calling next. If I have to pay a lawyer to present a case, then I can't justify that cost.

Problem 3 is that the biggest value in these assets has yet to be discovered, but almost certainly will be by XOM and TOT.  It's difficult to capture that value and make a case for a much larger, higher valuation.  Clearly it's not in the MIC.  I have reviewed USGS papers that show that large developed oil and gas fields tend to grow reserves in subsequent years, oil fields more so than gas fields.  And some shrink, but overall they grow.  Our field is not yet developed and unfortunately the last two wells A6 & 7 are pushing the numbers down.  I and others have made many postings noting the opportunity in PNG must be great based on the 5 discoveries on 6 leases.  It's why we all have invested  in IOC.  I won't be surprised if TOT and XOM and OSH extract 3X+ the volume of Elk/Antelope from these leases in the coming decades.

If the Paradigm report impressed the court that there should be a higher value, and if that evidence was shared with IOC and XOM, why can't we have it?  It is in PM's control is it not?  It may be at this point that PM is concerned that the report might sway too many votes and kill the deal if released?  If the deal does not go through, we all lose more.  It may be that PM wants that just for his own use to help his price but NOT kill the deal.  So far PM has not said what he is doing.  He's only publicly said the deal is still not fair.  So it seems for dissenters this is all about a bet on Phil and his ability to win in court.  If the deal is deemed unfair again by the court (I think highly unlikely), then the next offer(if there is one) maybe less depending on A7.

As I understand it the process goes like this.

1) You dissent with IOC and vote NO or don't vote.  Countless postings have discussed that.

2) You have to file an application with the court in Yukon yourself or use a Yukon lawyer.  Hard to get one as 2126 noted and I'm seeing that.

3). Once the shareholders vote and the votes favor the deal, IOC has a short period of time to make a new "fair" offer to all dissenters.  It has to be the same offer made to all per YBCA 193.

4). If you accept their offer, then you are done and you get paid what ever those agreed terms are.  You can also still wihtdraw your dissent at this point.  I have no idea what IOC will do.  Out of respect for the court and to lower their costs, it may be that they just up the offer 5 or 10% or maybe they (of course in reality XOM is in control; IOC is merely the dummy and XOM the ventriliquist) just make it an all stock immediate payment or all cash.  Any or none of those could happen.  But this happens very fast.

5) If you reject their offer, then it gets foggy and the time for it to conclude is very  uncertain.   Additional time is months to years.  The court starts making decisions that it thinks are best to conclude the matter.  It may group all the holdouts into one group and assign one deep pocket dissenter (Phil) to represent all per YBCA 193.  It may hire a 3rd party to make the new assessment (to me this is real dangerous and likely to result in a lower offer).  Or they can do whatever they think is best.  When the assessment is done, the court makes the new value the deal you must accept.  You are stuck with it for better or worse.  Too late now to withdraw dissent.  What is unclear is to what degree do the dissenters have the ability to argue the value.  For guys like me you are hoping and betting  on PM to win the battle.  Who knows how it will turn out this time?

I need more  IOC-specific, evidentiary substance from experts to go forward with dissent and legal representation.   Phil is the only one who can provide it.




RE: IOC updates ICCC on purchase - Martinistocks - 01-25-2017

GLTA I walked away.


RE: IOC updates ICCC on purchase - Northoil - 01-25-2017

_____________________________________________________________________________

You can’t compare consumer/competition groups in PNG with similar watchdogs in developed countries.  To imagine the “I”in ICCC is truly Independent is a little optimistic.

PNG is a poor, 3rd world country.  They’re not doing bad compared to most Pacific island nations, but that’s because of oil and gas.  For the last 30 years or so, they have used a strategy of encouraging exploration through smaller independents.  The small companies take acreage nobody wants, do some work, develop some prospects, maybe take partners and drill.  Maybe make a discovery (see below  **), then try to interest larger companies to fund the development.  That’s pretty much the story with IOC.

Gas is a special case.  LNG requires massive capital, expertise and market credibility with end users, none of which IOC has.  Hessian was brought in TO SELL THE COMPANY, was given a large incentive to do so, so he did.  Many people don’t like the price, but there were only a few interested buyers (who just happened to have LNG facilities) and an uncertain pricing outlook.

I don’t know what the price should have been or what the dissent path will result in, but I’m pretty sure the PNG ministries and politicians are sick to death of IOC and Phil.  PNG needs XOM or someone similar to take over and begin development.  If the deal is approved by shareholders and the Yukon courts, notwithstanding the sideshow of ongoing dissent, the ICCC will approve the deal.

The thought of splitting IOC’s interests and IOC’s continuing exploration is total fancy.  Many say we got nothing for the other discoveries and future exploration potential.  That’s not true.  Exxon put a value on each piece, and that was embedded in their offer.  We just don’t like the price.  No way will the deal be broken up.

** Finally, a view about PM’s exploratory genius.  I hate to say it, and in spite of the staggering technology that goes into it, exploration in new basins is a crap-shoot.  I compare it to the game at the carnival where everyone is throwing darts at a wall of balloons, except from 100 feet away.  Throw enough darts and someone will hit a balloon.  In exploration, that person is hailed as a genius, an inborn “oil finder” who can repeat the success at will.  Hah!

I will say PM was a good salesman.  It’s just that no one seems to be very excited about these additional “discoveries” which were probably over-hyped anyway.  Another case of declining reserve estimates?

[/quote]

Well said and sadly all true. Do you still hold? Are you dissenting?

_______________________________________________________

I sold out close to 18K shares  between 49 and 50, before the first shareholder vote.  While I was intrigued by the contingent right, PNG is a geologic dog's breakfast and A7 results -so far- are not a huge surprise.  So, I don't put my faith or money in appraisal wells(take the cash and let the credit go.)  I still have March 50 and 60 options, which are probably a dead loss although A7 still has life.

I've opined many times on the dissent option.  The NPV argument is so full of holes it's difficult to know where to start.  This is not the US or even the Yukon.  This is gas that has no possible use except in one of two LNG facilities.  One owner has outbid the other.  If the judge recognizes that (having cured the major deficiency of an independent fairness opinion), it could be game over.  So you get $45 and maybe some CRP upside.  If the NPV argument holds (which I don't believe) then NPV of what?  Stranded gas?  Exploration potential? What price, what time period, what discount factor, what's the asset worth in the first place?  Exxon will challenge every shareholder's status, every assumption.  Then there's time.  It's not going to be fast.  The deal will go forward while Exxon will challenge, delay, bring in expert witnesses, continue, appeal , delay -the dissent could go for years.   In the meantime, the yes and the no votes will immediately get their $45 in Exxon stock, which is a great price now and which has made 15%/yr since John D. Rockefeller, while the dissenters tie up their money and wait to see if their ship comes in.  I wish the dissenters well and everything I said could be wrong.  But I'm taking the IOC money and putting it in the Permian Basin amd maybe Northern Dynasty.

[/quote].

 Allow me to use this post to collect my thoughts.  I'm not trying to sway anyone.    I've put a tremendous amount of time into this dissent question, not to mention years of holding the stock and posting and reading posts on this board.  Looks like overall I will have a significant loss.  I talked to a lawyer at the firm representing PM.  She said this dissenting can cut both ways.  I.e., you can end up with more, the same or less.  Is she right?  Who knows?  The law seems to say that but is vague on the "less side" of it.

Problem 1 is I can't generate a high enough confidence that a case can be won on a higher valuation.  I just don't have specific information or knowledge to assemble that case.  I don't have knowledge as to how the court thinks and acts on these cases.

Problem 2 is I have no means to present the case.  Attempts so far to get representation have failed.  As 2126 noted - XOM, IOC and PM have them locked up.  I've talked to some of you via private message.  I may be calling next. If I have to pay a lawyer to present a case, then I can't justify that cost.

Problem 3 is that the biggest value in these assets has yet to be discovered, but almost certainly will be by XOM and TOT.  It's difficult to capture that value and make a case for a much larger, higher valuation.  Clearly it's not in the MIC.  I have reviewed USGS papers that show that large developed oil and gas fields tend to grow reserves in subsequent years, oil fields more so than gas fields.  And some shrink, but overall they grow.  Our field is not yet developed and unfortunately the last two wells A6 & 7 are pushing the numbers down.  I and others have made many postings noting the opportunity in PNG must be great based on the 5 discoveries on 6 leases.  It's why we all have invested  in IOC.  I won't be surprised if TOT and XOM and OSH extract 3X+ the volume of Elk/Antelope from these leases in the coming decades.

If the Paradigm report impressed the court that there should be a higher value, and if that evidence was shared with IOC and XOM, why can't we have it?  It is in PM's control is it not?  It may be at this point that PM is concerned that the report might sway too many votes and kill the deal if released?  If the deal does not go through, we all lose more.  It may be that PM wants that just for his own use to help his price but NOT kill the deal.  So far PM has not said what he is doing.  He's only publicly said the deal is still not fair.  So it seems for dissenters this is all about a bet on Phil and his ability to win in court.  If the deal is deemed unfair again by the court (I think highly unlikely), then the next offer(if there is one) maybe less depending on A7.

As I understand it the process goes like this.

1) You dissent with IOC and vote NO or don't vote.  Countless postings have discussed that.

2) You have to file an application with the court in Yukon yourself or use a Yukon lawyer.  Hard to get one as 2126 noted and I'm seeing that.

3). Once the shareholders vote and the votes favor the deal, IOC has a short period of time to make a new "fair" offer to all dissenters.  It has to be the same offer made to all per YBCA 193.

4). If you accept their offer, then you are done and you get paid what ever those agreed terms are.  You can also still wihtdraw your dissent at this point.  I have no idea what IOC will do.  Out of respect for the court and to lower their costs, it may be that they just up the offer 5 or 10% or maybe they (of course in reality XOM is in control; IOC is merely the dummy and XOM the ventriliquist) just make it an all stock immediate payment or all cash.  Any or none of those could happen.  But this happens very fast.

5) If you reject their offer, then it gets foggy and the time for it to conclude is very  uncertain.   Additional time is months to years.  The court starts making decisions that it thinks are best to conclude the matter.  It may group all the holdouts into one group and assign one deep pocket dissenter (Phil) to represent all per YBCA 193.  It may hire a 3rd party to make the new assessment (to me this is real dangerous and likely to result in a lower offer).  Or they can do whatever they think is best.  When the assessment is done, the court makes the new value the deal you must accept.  You are stuck with it for better or worse.  Too late now to withdraw dissent.  What is unclear is to what degree do the dissenters have the ability to argue the value.  For guys like me you are hoping and betting  on PM to win the battle.  Who knows how it will turn out this time?

I need more  IOC-specific, evidentiary substance from experts to go forward with dissent and legal representation.   Phil is the only one who can provide it.

___________________________________________________________________________________

Kaliboo - Really, really good analysis and clear thinking.  Thanks.  I just posted some additional points on the "MIC delivered today" thread.




RE: IOC updates ICCC on purchase - sageo - 01-25-2017

'Martinistocks' pid='79137' datel Wrote:GLTA I walked away.

Martini - Good luck . Perhaps you are one of the 'wise' ones . As Northoil said recently," A 7 still has life" ......but with the'nastinest' of the Orubadi shale, that 'life' is ebbing somewhat as of late .  Maybe with a little luck (or a whole LOT of luck) ,the well could still end on a positive note .....".the good Lord willin' and the creek don't rise"  ! <img src=" border="0" class="smilie" src="http://shareholdersunite.com/mybb/images/smilies/biggrin.gif" /> Best to you .                            [Yes,I know, I sure have a bunch of "maybes" in my basket lately ! ]   Ha,ha.




RE: IOC updates ICCC on purchase - jft310 - 01-25-2017

'Northoil' pid='79139' dateline='<a href="tel:1485279 Wrote:

_____________________________________________________________________________

You can’t compare consumer/competition groups in PNG with similar watchdogs in developed countries.  To imagine the “I”in ICCC is truly Independent is a little optimistic.

PNG is a poor, 3rd world country.  They’re not doing bad compared to most Pacific island nations, but that’s because of oil and gas.  For the last 30 years or so, they have used a strategy of encouraging exploration through smaller independents.  The small companies take acreage nobody wants, do some work, develop some prospects, maybe take partners and drill.  Maybe make a discovery (see below  **), then try to interest larger companies to fund the development.  That’s pretty much the story with IOC.

Gas is a special case.  LNG requires massive capital, expertise and market credibility with end users, none of which IOC has.  Hessian was brought in TO SELL THE COMPANY, was given a large incentive to do so, so he did.  Many people don’t like the price, but there were only a few interested buyers (who just happened to have LNG facilities) and an uncertain pricing outlook.

I don’t know what the price should have been or what the dissent path will result in, but I’m pretty sure the PNG ministries and politicians are sick to death of IOC and Phil.  PNG needs XOM or someone similar to take over and begin development.  If the deal is approved by shareholders and the Yukon courts, notwithstanding the sideshow of ongoing dissent, the ICCC will approve the deal.

The thought of splitting IOC’s interests and IOC’s continuing exploration is total fancy.  Many say we got nothing for the other discoveries and future exploration potential.  That’s not true.  Exxon put a value on each piece, and that was embedded in their offer.  We just don’t like the price.  No way will the deal be broken up.

** Finally, a view about PM’s exploratory genius.  I hate to say it, and in spite of the staggering technology that goes into it, exploration in new basins is a crap-shoot.  I compare it to the game at the carnival where everyone is throwing darts at a wall of balloons, except from 100 feet away.  Throw enough darts and someone will hit a balloon.  In exploration, that person is hailed as a genius, an inborn “oil finder” who can repeat the success at will.  Hah!

I will say PM was a good salesman.  It’s just that no one seems to be very excited about these additional “discoveries” which were probably over-hyped anyway.  Another case of declining reserve estimates?

Well said and sadly all true. Do you still hold? Are you dissenting?

_______________________________________________________

I sold out close to 18K shares  between 49 and 50, before the first shareholder vote.  While I was intrigued by the contingent right, PNG is a geologic dog's breakfast and A7 results -so far- are not a huge surprise.  So, I don't put my faith or money in appraisal wells(take the cash and let the credit go.)  I still have March 50 and 60 options, which are probably a dead loss although A7 still has life.

I've opined many times on the dissent option.  The NPV argument is so full of holes it's difficult to know where to start.  This is not the US or even the Yukon.  This is gas that has no possible use except in one of two LNG facilities.  One owner has outbid the other.  If the judge recognizes that (having cured the major deficiency of an independent fairness opinion), it could be game over.  So you get $45 and maybe some CRP upside.  If the NPV argument holds (which I don't believe) then NPV of what?  Stranded gas?  Exploration potential? What price, what time period, what discount factor, what's the asset worth in the first place?  Exxon will challenge every shareholder's status, every assumption.  Then there's time.  It's not going to be fast.  The deal will go forward while Exxon will challenge, delay, bring in expert witnesses, continue, appeal , delay -the dissent could go for years.   In the meantime, the yes and the no votes will immediately get their $45 in Exxon stock, which is a great price now and which has made 15%/yr since John D. Rockefeller, while the dissenters tie up their money and wait to see if their ship comes in.  I wish the dissenters well and everything I said could be wrong.  But I'm taking the IOC money and putting it in the Permian Basin amd maybe Northern Dynasty.

[/quote].

 Allow me to use this post to collect my thoughts.  I'm not trying to sway anyone.    I've put a tremendous amount of time into this dissent question, not to mention years of holding the stock and posting and reading posts on this board.  Looks like overall I will have a significant loss.  I talked to a lawyer at the firm representing PM.  She said this dissenting can cut both ways.  I.e., you can end up with more, the same or less.  Is she right?  Who knows?  The law seems to say that but is vague on the "less side" of it.

Problem 1 is I can't generate a high enough confidence that a case can be won on a higher valuation.  I just don't have specific information or knowledge to assemble that case.  I don't have knowledge as to how the court thinks and acts on these cases.

Problem 2 is I have no means to present the case.  Attempts so far to get representation have failed.  As 2126 noted - XOM, IOC and PM have them locked up.  I've talked to some of you via private message.  I may be calling next. If I have to pay a lawyer to present a case, then I can't justify that cost.

Problem 3 is that the biggest value in these assets has yet to be discovered, but almost certainly will be by XOM and TOT.  It's difficult to capture that value and make a case for a much larger, higher valuation.  Clearly it's not in the MIC.  I have reviewed USGS papers that show that large developed oil and gas fields tend to grow reserves in subsequent years, oil fields more so than gas fields.  And some shrink, but overall they grow.  Our field is not yet developed and unfortunately the last two wells A6 & 7 are pushing the numbers down.  I and others have made many postings noting the opportunity in PNG must be great based on the 5 discoveries on 6 leases.  It's why we all have invested  in IOC.  I won't be surprised if TOT and XOM and OSH extract 3X+ the volume of Elk/Antelope from these leases in the coming decades.

If the Paradigm report impressed the court that there should be a higher value, and if that evidence was shared with IOC and XOM, why can't we have it?  It is in PM's control is it not?  It may be at this point that PM is concerned that the report might sway too many votes and kill the deal if released?  If the deal does not go through, we all lose more.  It may be that PM wants that just for his own use to help his price but NOT kill the deal.  So far PM has not said what he is doing.  He's only publicly said the deal is still not fair.  So it seems for dissenters this is all about a bet on Phil and his ability to win in court.  If the deal is deemed unfair again by the court (I think highly unlikely), then the next offer(if there is one) maybe less depending on A7.

As I understand it the process goes like this.

1) You dissent with IOC and vote NO or don't vote.  Countless postings have discussed that.

2) You have to file an application with the court in Yukon yourself or use a Yukon lawyer.  Hard to get one as 2126 noted and I'm seeing that.

3). Once the shareholders vote and the votes favor the deal, IOC has a short period of time to make a new "fair" offer to all dissenters.  It has to be the same offer made to all per YBCA 193.

4). If you accept their offer, then you are done and you get paid what ever those agreed terms are.  You can also still wihtdraw your dissent at this point.  I have no idea what IOC will do.  Out of respect for the court and to lower their costs, it may be that they just up the offer 5 or 10% or maybe they (of course in reality XOM is in control; IOC is merely the dummy and XOM the ventriliquist) just make it an all stock immediate payment or all cash.  Any or none of those could happen.  But this happens very fast.

5) If you reject their offer, then it gets foggy and the time for it to conclude is very  uncertain.   Additional time is months to years.  The court starts making decisions that it thinks are best to conclude the matter.  It may group all the holdouts into one group and assign one deep pocket dissenter (Phil) to represent all per YBCA 193.  It may hire a 3rd party to make the new assessment (to me this is real dangerous and likely to result in a lower offer).  Or they can do whatever they think is best.  When the assessment is done, the court makes the new value the deal you must accept.  You are stuck with it for better or worse.  Too late now to withdraw dissent.  What is unclear is to what degree do the dissenters have the ability to argue the value.  For guys like me you are hoping and betting  on PM to win the battle.  Who knows how it will turn out this time?

I need more  IOC-specific, evidentiary substance from experts to go forward with dissent and legal representation.   Phil is the only one who can provide it.

___________________________________________________________________________________

Kaliboo - Really, really good analysis and clear thinking.  Thanks.  I just posted some additional points on the "MIC delivered today" thread.

[/quote

Phil is preparing a response , the history of the Yukon Courts is not years to settle a dissent . Last time both court decisions were Within 8 weeks in total . No fear mongering Needed . Phil is like most who wants to continue with life Post IOC. He dissented last time. Let's see what he says this time , Expect something this week best guess ,