Thread Rating:
  • 2 Vote(s) - 3 Average
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
IS A STOCK DIVIDEND GOING TO HELP US OR HURT US?
#1

Question for the real accountants if there are any on this site.  I copied the below from Note 13 of the last quarter financial report.  I'm wondering how a "stock dividend" would work out for our case.  I don't see any entry on the balance sheet called "Treasury Shares" which are shares the company has bought back but not retired but also are no longer counted as "outstanding" shares (according 2 financial dictionaries).  I don't recall ever seeing a company having an "unlimited number of common shares" that it has authorized.  So it seems at anytime they could put another 48 mil or even 48 billion shares on the market to raise money or pay a stock dividend with no further regulatory delay in terms of extending their authorization.  So any stock dividend is basically a dilution that is a taxable event in taxable accounts.  It costs the company nothing.  I didn't check the tax code, but I assume for tax purposes the basis will be the closing price of the day of the transfer.  So the dilutions I've seen often have a tail of decline to them on the PPS.  The announcement causes a big drop followed by multiple days of additional drop, and then depending on the situation, it may recover if the company is viewed favovably as to what the dilution is intended for.  In our case this is supposed to be a reward for shareholders and a deterent to shorts.  I don't really want a dilution of an already down stock that will be pushed further down since it currently is out of favor and still sinking.  I want them to do something to stop the short influence.  I think people are thinking the stock dividend will hurt the shorts.  Wouldn't a stock split do the same without creating a taxable event and driving the price further down?  I'm not an accountant.  We don't need another stupid miscalculation delivering unintended/unexpected consequences.  Any other time I've received a stock dividend (typically a small fractional share per share owned), it's been uneventful.  I'm highly skeptical the same will apply here, especially if as JFT310 says it could be a 50% dividend.  Do you really want that big tax event if it could drive PPS down further?

   Interoil Q3 Financial Report Excerpt - Note 13

http://www.interoil.com/iocfiles/documen...FINAL_.pdf

13. Share capital

The authorized share capital of the Company consists of an unlimited number of common shares with no par value and an unlimited number of preferred shares, of which 1,035,554 series A preferred shares are authorized. Each common share entitles the holder to one vote.
Common shares - Changes to issued share capital were as follows:
September 30, 2013
Number of shares:  48,824,038
$942,190,761
Preferred shares - No preferred shares are issued, or were issued at any time during the nine months ended September 30, 2013 (September 2012 – nil).
Reply

#2

Study the history of stock dividends and see how stocks react to such dividends.

better yet study the history of heavily shorted stocks and the effect dividends have on the stock price

Reply

#3
Can you please give some names of heavily shorted stocks that began dividends so that I (we) may research. Thanks.
Reply

#4
Here's the basics needed to understand a dividend and it's effects
Stock Short Sale
A stock short sale involves a trader borrowing shares from his broker, then selling the shares. If the stock declines in value, the trader buys the shares back at a lower price, returns the shares to the broker and makes a profit from difference between the price at which the shares were sold short and the lower price when the shares were repurchased. Selling stock short can only be done in a brokerage account approved for margin loan trading -- a margin account.
Sources of Shares to Short
The shares a trader borrows to sell short are loaned to the trader from the accounts of other customers of the broker. Part of a margin account agreement authorizes the broker to lend shares owned in a customer's margin account. If the broker does not have customers holding shares a trader wants to sell short, the broker can also borrow the shares from another brokerage firm. The shares a short seller sells short belong to another investor or brokerage firm.
Sponsored Links
Dividend Investing
AllianzGI® Specializes in Dividend Investment Strategies. Learn More.
Dividend Payments
If a short-sold stock declares and pays a dividend, the owner of the lent shares expects to receive the dividend amount. The trader who sold short the stock must pay the amount of the dividend to her broker, who will transfer the payment to the owner of the shares. The payment to the share owner are not the actual dividends from the stock. The stock has been sold to another investor with the short sale. The payment is referred to as a payment in lieu of dividends. ****For the owner of the stock, payment in lieu of dividends does not have the same tax advantages as receiving the real dividend payment.***
****this is why the loaned shares get recalled*** adverse tax consequences*****
Effects of Stock Dividend
****The trader with short shares will be required to make the payment in lieu of dividend amount. ****The cash will be deducted from the trader's cash account balance. The stock price will decline by the amount of the dividend payment on the ex-dividend date, so the trader's profit on the short sale will increase by the amount of the dividend on that date. There is a possibility the broker could recall lent shares before the ex-dividend date on a stock that has just declared a large dividend. This move would be to prevent adverse tax consequences for the broker's customers from whose accounts the shares were borrowed.
****This means those short must buy long shares and deliver them to the longs***
Reply

#5

'Movieguy' pid='35085' dateline='<a href="tel:1387905 Wrote:Can you please give some names of heavily shorted stocks that began dividends so that I (we) may research. Thanks.

Looks like you amd I got no responses providing anything useful or specific to the issues raised.  Must be the holiday break or no one really knows.  I guess we'll find out in time.  I doubt seriously any company would ever pay a 50% stock dividend or if they did, that this info would be leaked weeks ahead of time.  Does anyone seriously believe that?  Cheers!

Reply

#6
Start tracking Santa now!
I just spotted him in Zambia...

http://www.noradsanta.org/
Reply

#7
I saw him on Noradsanta.com in Norway!!! Merry Christmas everyone. May 2014 bring us peace, love, happiness and a healthy consistent pps Smile
Reply

#8
My take is as follows: the purpose of the stock dividend/stock split (there is a legal difference, but in reality there is very little economic difference) is to try and trigger an event wherein the longs that have their shares on loan are incentivized to call their shares. When the shares are called, the shorts are then forced to cover.
I have seen stock loan agreements from two major brokerage houses. Both have language that state that the borrowers of the shares will compensate the lenders so that they are kept whole. For instance, if the company pays ordinary cash dividends, then borrowers of the shares will pay the lenders an amount that factors into account that ordinary dividends are taxed at a rate less than the compensation payed to lenders.
I do not remember specifically how the agreements treat stock splits/stock dividends. (FYI - neither event is taxable to the shareholder.) I have sent an e-mail to the loan department of one of the brokerage houses and will share when I get it. Someways it seems that if IOC pays a 50% dividend (a 3 for 2 split), as long as the borrower returns 50% more shares there is no need for the shares to be called. Again, I do not know for sure, but I should have good information in a couple of days.
On a different note, a member of IOC management has stated to me that they have to be careful about approaching major shareholders asking them to call their shares as some arcane securities laws are involved. So I wonder if management said they would, or if they were vague in answering specific questions on the topic, then it might lead one to think that they will.
Merry Christmas.
Reply



Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: