Thread Rating:
  • 2 Vote(s) - 3 Average
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
Absurd
#1

Is it just me or does anyone else find the current pps of Interoil absurd? I realize that's a rhetorical question in large part.  But as I sit here and reflect on being an IOC shareholder for 5+ years and consider when we were previosuly trading at these levels, the whole thing would be quite comical if it wasn't so pathetic.  IOC was trading at these levels as A2 was being drilled in Q4 2009 and when the PNG govt was in chaos and there was real fear Duma would void everything IOC related in Q4 2011.  Yet here we are with virtually every short argument ever conceived proved null and void trading at levels when risks were far, far greater. Absurd!

Consider:

1. IOC has a SM as a partner in PNG.

2. The PNG govt is fully supportive of IOC (&TOT)

3. All IOC licenses have either been renewed or will be renewed soon.

4. IOC will shortly be drilling in PPL 236, 237, & 238.

5.  IOC will drill 2-3 more delineation wells in a deal that pays $1.29/mcf uncapped.

6. IOC will receive over $600 million cash upon TOT deal closing.

7. IPI is 45% bought out and according to the CEO, a value neutral deal for their remainig interest is imminent.

8. IOC will own 30% of PRL 15, a pipeline, a CSP, and LNG plant.

9. Based on current certification, IOC will receive a Multi Billion $ payment in 2015.

10. IOC is now able to monetize all the additional resources they discover.

11. Triceratops is expected to be a multi-TCF resource.

12.  IOC is on a clear path to FID and booked reserves.

13. Extensive seismics have been shot on mulitple prospects.

14. Several more others will add.............

It strikes me that if IOC was operating primarily in the Permian or Bakken, the market cap on this company would be several fold of what it currently is.  It's really difficult to look across the spectrum of publicly traded companies and find one with greater value than IOC.  It really is.  What would Carl Ichan do?

Reply

#2
I agree and you get two thumbs up for this post. What is unfortunate is the pps which can only be explained as the deal is too far out in the future or everyone thought XOM would be chosen. The poor rollout did not help nor did TOT PR which has yet to be corrected. I think it is worth noting the confusion among analysts that were on cc then compounded by shareholders left to determine an 80 page contract. As the dust has settled and the facts become clear it is hard to fathom the resource being valued at stranded levels. But its where we are and the pieces need to be picked up and options explored (taking private comes to mind). I recall Pavel stating years ago the resource is worth 65 a share without a major, now its sub 53 with a major.

Strange days indeed.
Reply

#3
The simple truth is that IOC Top Management has not "protected" its shareholders by making this deal with Total. The market has concluded that this deal is inferior as compared to the previous public statements that "an accretive deal is in hand that values IOC at multiples of the current share price."

In addition, IOC has seemingly refused repeatedly to bring someone on-board to deal with the people who have been manipulating the share price for so many years.

Large individual shareholders such as Richard Chandler, Carlo Civelli and Phil Mulacek, and large institutional shareholders, must decide whether they think IOC's current Management Team has undertaken its fiduciary responsibilities by making this deal with Total. If they decide the answer is "NO", then we smaller shareholders must decide whether to support them going forward.

"The board has duties to the corporation and its shareholders. Why? Because of the fiduciary relationship between the board and shareholders. When directors breach their duties, shareholders can bring a derivative suit against the directors. In additional circumstances such as change of control transactions, mergers and acquisitions, and insolvency, directors also owe shareholders duties, including REVLON duties to achieve the best price for shareholders and to disclose material information and potential conflicts of interest."

http://www.dypadvisors.com/2011/10/03/bo...reholders/

REVLON Rule:

A legal precedence that dictates if the sale of the company is forthcoming, the main goal the company's board of directors should have is to conduct the proceedings in a manner that would yield the most benefit for the company's shareholders. Essentially, assuming that a number of situations are fulfilled (there are two or more buyers, all bids are cash-based acquisitions and that all parties have the requisite financing), the board of directors should always be picking the highest bid.
Drivel Maven with Personality
Reply

#4
IOC shorts OWN IOC, shareholders do not. Amazing that people still deny this.
Reply

#5
Would it be to much to ask for some of the directors to make an open market purchase. I would think it would show their belief in the value. I think Hession should lead the way as he doesn't have any skin in the game as of yet other than a few months of work.
Reply

#6
Gentlemen, as the bits start to turn and the deal is signed in Q1 you know what's going to happen to the pps. The only bump in the road here is the ipi deal. Once we get past that smart shorts will cover and the real smart ones will go long and there's no place but up, way up. As Tusker would say "Steady as she goes" - nice post Itvest.
Reply

#7

tarulestheday dateline='<a href="tel:1387692085">1387692085</a>' Wrote: IOC shorts OWN IOC, shareholders do not. Amazing that people still deny this.

I do not agree with this statement.  They might manipulate it but there is more going on here than just short attacks.  I agree with Stavros ans have for years said " I believe in the resource but of management I am suspect".

Reply

#8

We have a new CEO and that's new management. He's changing everything . His main focus has been in getting us a great

deal with LNG participation. He's done just that our future is bright for those that can look past their noses. How many

understand that  with a two train LNG plant IOC will have cash flow of $1.5 Billion per year.

Blasting this new CEO with comparisons to the old CEO is just stupid and not factual.

There are ways to deal with the shorts distortions and with the lack of float in the daily trading. He knows about the problem now

please give him a reasonable amount of time to implement  the plan.

Dr Hession is an under promise and over deliver guy.

First proof of that is the deal with Total with uncapped upside and LNG participation

When you ask?

This deal must close and the drill bits plural start spinning and we recover. Sounds like all of this is within .the next 60 days

or so . The climb should be slow and steady without a rocket  launch. But who knows what the drill bit will find.?

Reply

#9
Whether it matches expectation is another matter, but the critique on present management seems to be predicated on the assumption that there was a better deal out there.

At least I haven't heard anything to confirm that, but apart from that (which might just be a lack of putting my ears in the right direction), the simple question that automatically bubbles up would be, if so, why didn't management take that deal?

Some might argue that previous management has had considerable time to close a deal and for whatever reasons, they didn't, but I think none of this is very productive. We have a deal. On some respects perhaps not what many imagined ($/mcf, time to LNG plant) but I think there is plenty of things to like in the deal which provides a bright future ahead.

A future that is both de-risked to a substantial amount in many ways (licenses, balance sheet, politics), and which depends to a large extent on one of IOC's strengths, exploration.

The shorts seem to hang up their hat at one curious and awkward Total PR, which appraisal wells to be drilled pretty soon will be able to pull the rug from.

For me, the hypotheticals, the "could-have, would-have should-have's" aren't very productive, I don't think dwelling on these things will open a productive road.
Reply

#10
STP, the statements from MH and IOC said a deal multiples of PPS and accretive to shareholders. It lead all to believe this would be soon (that word again). If the plan is to have both of these end of 2015 or 2016 or later that is a bit misleading. Maybe IOC IS working with legal and SEC to combat the shorts but nothing says that. Are many of use tired of the delays, the miscommunication, the poor leadership from years of over promise and under deliver, yes. To those who say, if you are disgruntled and short term minded then sell and move on, not an appropriate comment. I am in oboist 4 years. This is not short term but I would like to see a return on my investment. I believe in the resource but of management I am suspect.
Reply



Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)