Posts: 12,025
Threads: 1,809
Joined: Apr 2008
Reputation:
227
Are we talking about the same thing here? According to the SPA, it's Pacific LNG (in several cameo's) that holds a big stake in PRL 15 (22.835%):
“PacLNG Interest” means, as at the Effective Date, an aggregate twenty two decimal eight three five percent (22.835%) interest in the PRL 15 Title and the JOA applicable to PRL 15 as at the date of this Agreement, which interest is held by the following entities:
|
|
(a) |
PAC LNG Investments Limited (2.500%); |
|
|
(b) |
PAC LNG Assets Limited (6.750%); |
|
|
© |
PAC LNG International Limited (5.100%); |
|
|
(d) |
PAC LNG Overseas Limited (5.000%); and |
|
|
(e) |
PAC LNG Holdings Limited (3.485%). |
Posts: 12,025
Threads: 1,809
Joined: Apr 2008
Reputation:
227
12-26-2013, 03:15 AM
(This post was last modified: 12-26-2013, 03:30 AM by admin.)
We know this:
Cash calls are made on IPI holders, PNGDV and PacLNG (for its 2.5% direct interest in the Elk and Antelope fields acquired during 2009)
That suggests at least PAC LNG Investment Limited is Civelli.
-
IPI Holders (1) 15.1386%
-
Pac LNG Assets Limited (2) 6.7500%
-
Pac LNG Investment Limited (3) 2.5000%
Also:
In February 2005, we entered into an agreement with the IPI Holders pursuant to which the IPI Holders paid us an aggregate of US$125.0 million and we agreed to drill eight exploration wells in Papua New Guinea on PPLs 236, 237 and 238. We have drilled four of these eight wells to date. Following various buybacks and conversions, IPI Holders currently hold interests totaling 15.1386% of each of these existing and future wells. Each IPI Holder has the right to acquire an interest in field development operations following the drilling of an exploration well in which the holder owns an IPI. So, if an exploration well is successful, by paying their share of field development costs, the IPI Holders will have the right to participate in the development of the fields discovered by that well.
In July 2003, we entered into a Drilling Participation agreement with PNGDV, whereby PNGDV has a 6.75% interest in eight exploration wells. We have drilled six of these exploration wells to date. PNGDV also has the right to participate in the next 16 wells that follow the first eight mentioned above up to an interest of 5.75% at a cost of US$112,500 for each 1% per well (with higher amounts to be paid if the depth exceeds 3,500 meters and the cost exceeds US$8,500,000). In June 2012, PNGDV transferred its interest in PRL15 to Pac LNG Assets Limited.
In August 2009, we entered into a Sale and Purchase Agreement with Pacific LNG Operations, Limited (PLOL) whereby PLOL acquired a 2.5% direct working interest in gas and condensate in the Elk and Antelope fields. In June 2012, PLOL transferred its interest in PRL15 to Pac LNG Investments Limited. PNGEI has the right to participate up to a 4.25% interest in 16 wells commencing from exploration wells numbered 9 to 24. As of March 31, 2013, we have drilled six exploration wells since the inception of our exploration program within PPL 236, 237 and 238. In order to participate, PNGEI would be required to contribute, for each exploration well, US$112,500 per 1% plus actual costs over US$1.0 million charged pro rate for each 1%. Following statements from the State questioning the continuing validly of our 2009 LNG Project Agreement, in November 2012 the State made clear that it continues to approve of the LNG Project, with modifications to be agreed upon. The State also indicated that it was interested in acquiring an additional 27.5% equity interest in the Elk and Antelope fields, over and above the 22.5% interest to which it (and the affected landowners) is entitled under the Oil and Gas Act, on terms to be negotiated with us. We are currently negotiating with the State regarding this additional 27.5% interest.IPI’s do not have a direct interest in any PPL but they are entitled to convert their interest following grant of a PRL.
Posts: 12,025
Threads: 1,809
Joined: Apr 2008
Reputation:
227
So it's IPI's 15.1386% and Civelli 9.25%, assuming Pac LNG Asset Limited is Civelli.
However, from the SPA, if these are the IPI's:
© PAC LNG International Limited (5.100%);
(d) PAC LNG Overseas Limited (5.000%); and
(e) PAC LNG Holdings Limited (3.485%).
That's only 13.585%, not 15.1386%, but the first is more current so I assume that's the right figure, meaning:
- IPI's 13.585%
- Civelli 9.25%
Posts: 12,025
Threads: 1,809
Joined: Apr 2008
Reputation:
227
12-26-2013, 03:40 AM
(This post was last modified: 12-26-2013, 04:23 AM by admin.)
Now, another interesting question is whether those two Civelli vehicles (PAC LNG Investment Limited and PAC LNG Assets Limited, if the latter is indeed Civelli but that seems very likely) fall under the same regime as the IPI's?
I think the first (PAC LNG Investment) not, as this was bought in 2009. The second (PAC LNG Assets Limited) was bought in June 2012 from "PNGDV", the original agreement (SEC filing) you can find here:
http://secfilings.nyse.com/filing.php?doc=1&attach=ON&ipage=4069797&rid=23
Posts: 8,568
Threads: 1,342
Joined: Dec 2011
Reputation:
380
Why do people ignore the 4.2 percent bought back during the 3rd quarter of 2014 for 100,000 shares?
Mentioned in the MDA for the third quarter posted on these pages
Posts: 8,568
Threads: 1,342
Joined: Dec 2011
Reputation:
380
Why do people ignore Pavel who looked at all the filing and states $248 million to buy out the IPI.?
RE: New RJ Note - We trade at 6.7Tcf Recert.
IOC: How Much Elk/Antelope Resource Is the Stock Pricing in? [IOC121713b_164445];
Analyst(s): Pavel Molchanov;
[Industry Classification: Energy/Exploration and Production];
InterOil Corp. - Outperform 2;
Companies Mentioned - IOC, TOTF.PA
* At the risk of stating the obvious, the central reason why IOC shares plummeted following the December 6 announcement of the resource selldown with Total is the uncertainty over how much value will ultimately accrue to InterOil from this deal. There is no way for the market to know how much resource at the Elk/Antelope field will be certified in 2015, and therefore how much cash Total will ultimately pay. In the meantime, it's worth posing the question: What amount of resource is the stock currently pricing in?
* For purposes of this analysis, we make several simplifying assumptions. First, we estimate that the value of the cash-generating businesses (refining and fuel distribution) is $304 million, applying the same DCF approach we've always used. Second, we assume that InterOil will pay $248 million in cash to buy out the resource stake of the remaining Indirect Participation Interest (IPI) investors, equating to a 15% annualized return since they made the investment in 2005. Third, we do not ascribe any value for the Triceratops discovery, nor any future exploration optionality. Fourth, to simplify the time value of money calculation, we apply a 10% per year discount factor, over two years, for all of the payments that Total will make beyond the $613 million upfront payment.
* The implied net present value of the resource (i.e., everything other than refining and distribution) is $2.6 billion. As the ultra-conservative scenario, let's suppose that the stock is pricing in only the monetized portion of the Elk-Antelope resource - i.e., InterOil needs to receive $2.6 billion in cash from Total, on a net present value basis and also net of the IPI buyout, to justify the current market cap. So, how much resource does Elk/Antelope need to contain for InterOil to receive this much? The math is simple, since the publicly filed Sale and Purchase Agreement specifies the valuation brackets. The answer is that Elk/Antelope needs to contain 8.6 Tcfe (gross, on a 2P basis) under this scenario, as shown on page 2 on the left. Now, let's do the same math, except ascribing some value for the Elk/Antelope resource that InterOil retains. This unmonetized gas is likely to have value only after the Total-operated LNG plant begins to produce - a project whose timetable and economics are hypothetical for the time being - so for purposes of this analysis, we value this gas at a notional $0.50/Mcfe - below the bottom bracket in the Total deal. On this basis (see page 2 on the right), 6.7 Tcfe at Elk/Antelope is priced in.
* Having estimated that the stock is implicitly pricing in between 6.7 and 8.6 Tcfe - both using conservative assumptions that ignore any value drivers beyond Elk/Antelope - we can ask whether this is too high, too low, or just right. Our own opinion of the resource base is, of course, irrelevant. Also irrelevant are the current opinions of InterOil and Total, since they will ultimately base their judgments on the future results of the certification process, involving independent third-party reserve engineers. That said, there are some historical markers that can provide context. InterOil's independent reserve engineers, GLJ Petroleum Consultants, had a year-end 2012 estimate of 9.9 Tcfe on a 2P basis (7.5 Tcfe on a 1P basis). Another independent firm, Gaffney Cline, working on behalf of the government, had an estimate (using older data) of 6.5 Tcfe on a 2P basis. It is entirely academic to argue which firm's estimate is more accurate - all such estimates for non-producing resources are more of an art than a science, although the tendency is for reserve engineers to err on the side of conservatism. What we can say is that the stock is pricing in a resource amount that is on par or below these aforementioned estimates.
Full Report - IOC: How Much Elk/Antelope Resource Is the Stock Pricing in?
Posts: 12,025
Threads: 1,809
Joined: Apr 2008
Reputation:
227
'jft310' pid='35127' datel Wrote:
Why do people ignore the 4.2 percent bought back during the 3rd quarter of 2014 for 100,000 shares?
Mentioned in the MDA for the third quarter posted on these pages
4.2% of what exactly? Here from the latest Quarterly Report:
Subsequent to quarter end, on October 24, 2013, we entered into an Exchange Agreement with PNGEI
to buyback their 4.25% indirect participation interest percentage under the Amended Indirect
Participation Interest Agreement dated May 12, 2004, including their interest and rights to future
distributions in exchange for 100,000 of our common shares
Now, why do people ignore it? Because it's got nothing to do with buying out the five different PAC LNG vehicles:
-
That still stands at 22.835% per SPA
-
I'm fairly sure the 4.25% that was bought out from PNGEI was a participation in wells 8-24, although I can no longer find the part where I found that. Actually I just did, page 9 of the 2012 year-end report
PNGEI has the right to participate up to a 4.25% interest in 16 wells commencing from exploration wells numbered 9 to 24. As of March 31, 2013, we have drilled six exploration wells since the inception of our exploration program within PPL 236, 237 and 238. In order to participate, PNGEI would be required to contribute, for each exploration well, US$112,500 per 1% plus actual costs over US$1.0 million charged pro rate for each 1%.
And I have to say InterOil isn't exactly making this very easy to assess, and that's a bit of an understatement. It's fairly irritating, unless you're fond of fairly sizeable puzzles. All the vehicles in PRL 15 are called PAC LNG something, without further ado. Finding out who is who, and under what kind of agreement they fall, well good luck to that. I tried to do that and I think the first two are Civelli's and the last three are the IPI's, but do all fall under the same agreements, with the same rights and obligations?
|