Thread Rating:
  • 3 Vote(s) - 3.67 Average
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
IOC Finance Function moving to XOM???
#21
They just have to let MH do it. No need to be hostile.
Reply

#22

(11-23-2016, 02:21 PM)weaselpuppy Wrote:

(11-23-2016, 03:06 AM)AU74 Wrote:

In any renewed approval process, every shareholder would have a new chance at dissenting. Given the court's opinion leaning heavily on NAV, I would think just about every shareholder will dissent. Of course, that would mean they also vote NO, so this deal is dead, dead, dead.

Math Interlude-

I believe if I remember correctly approximately 75% of the outstanding shares voted in the deal vote, so about 37,500,000 shares. Also, if I remember correctly, that institutions/large holders make up approximately 51%, or about 25,000,000 shares. I am going to assume since the vote was 81-19 or 80-20, that all of the institution votes were in favor. This tells me that of the non-institutional shares, 12,500,000, they split 5,000,000 for and 7,500,000 against.

To kill the deal, there needs to be 33.34% of voted shares against. If we have the same voter turnout of 37,500,000 shares, then all 5,000,000 non-institutional Yes Votes need to switch. All of them. This is not a plausible scenario. Now yes, there are other factors….greater turnout % at the same or better no-yes ratios for the non-institutional would help, but how high can turnout increase? To 85%? Maybe. Probably no better than that or 90%. Even at 90% turnout, with the institutions lock-step Yes, the non-institution vote has to be 15,000,000 no and 5,000,000 yes. So, we need to double the No vote from the non-institutional ( with the biggest No vote holder(s) already accounted for) with No increase to the Yes vote total. Also, not plausible.

This, to me, then turns the entire vote to kill the deal moot. It’s really about the appeal and the dissent (again).  Unless an institution can be flipped, and a big one. I think we’ve seen how The Game works as far as MS, RJ, XOM etc etc….Big Corporations and those that feed from/on them is a private party, and if you want to be invited to the next one (merger, IPO, secondary offering, shelf financing etc), you go along to get along. That’s how this is. Small shareholders need to internalize this fact. You Aren’t Invited. Whatever you do, at least by the rules set up by the Party People, you lose.

Phil knows this. He’s not really part of the “In Crowd”, knew it and it is likely why he set up the company in the Yukon, as a leveling factor.

The vote means nothing to the Pink Pirate. He knew he had it in the bag when he signed on 3+ years ago. Think on that for a bit. If IOC can remediate the appeals court findings, it’s a done dealio.

Your true choice is whether Dissent or the CRP dice roll fits better with your personal timeline vs potential payout equation. All else, IMO, unless an institution flips, is un-reality.

I disagree. First of all, not every institutional holder is an investment banker or otherwise part of the pay-for-play system.  Second, even those that are part of the private party can read court opinions and look at the rise in oil prices and realize there's a lot more money to be had now.  Greed works in our favor in this case, IMHO.

Reply

#23
Question: Are shareholder votes confidential?
Reply

#24

[quote='2126' pid='77839' dateline='1479914943']

Weaselpuppy has it correct. My thoughts are that IOC will attempt to resurrect the current deal in a similar form, get an extension from Exxon to the December 14 cut-off date, obtain an independent fairness opinion that it hopes will satisfy the Yukon courts, and proceed with another shareholder vote. As Weasel notes, without a major defection of a prominent institutional holder, such a strateqy will likely succeed.

Which leaves a NO/Dissent vote as the favored alternative. Dissenting looks much more favorable this time around as the Yukon courts have shown their willingness to look beneath the covers of any proposed deal and would very likely use a net asset value approach to a court-ordered appraisal for dissenters. I also believe that the court will expedite such an appraisal given the history of IOC management corporate goverance problems. All in all, dissenting looks like a better option for the next round of this slow-motion trainwreck.

Our dissent letter one per account stated we were asking the courts for a Net Asset Value determination from them . We had the IOC law firm in Yukon time stamp our letters individually . Way to much money left on the table in the original deal .

Reply

#25
The difference between the deal price and net asset value could be $20 or more . I can't imagine them wanting the same deal put to shareholders again . Our guess we can prove $93 a share at NAV. Others can do their own calculations .
Reply

#26

'AU74' pid='77842' dateline='<a href="tel:1479922 Wrote:

'weaselpuppy' pid='77827' dateline='<a href="tel:1479874 Wrote:

'AU74' pid='77818' dateline='<a href="tel:1479834 Wrote:

In any renewed approval process, every shareholder would have a new chance at dissenting. Given the court's opinion leaning heavily on NAV, I would think just about every shareholder will dissent. Of course, that would mean they also vote NO, so this deal is dead, dead, dead.

Math Interlude-

I believe if I remember correctly approximately 75% of the outstanding shares voted in the deal vote, so about 37,500,000 shares. Also, if I remember correctly, that institutions/large holders make up approximately 51%, or about 25,000,000 shares. I am going to assume since the vote was 81-19 or 80-20, that all of the institution votes were in favor. This tells me that of the non-institutional shares, 12,500,000, they split 5,000,000 for and 7,500,000 against.

To kill the deal, there needs to be 33.34% of voted shares against. If we have the same voter turnout of 37,500,000 shares, then all 5,000,000 non-institutional Yes Votes need to switch. All of them. This is not a plausible scenario. Now yes, there are other factors….greater turnout % at the same or better no-yes ratios for the non-institutional would help, but how high can turnout increase? To 85%? Maybe. Probably no better than that or 90%. Even at 90% turnout, with the institutions lock-step Yes, the non-institution vote has to be 15,000,000 no and 5,000,000 yes. So, we need to double the No vote from the non-institutional ( with the biggest No vote holder(s) already accounted for) with No increase to the Yes vote total. Also, not plausible.

This, to me, then turns the entire vote to kill the deal moot. It’s really about the appeal and the dissent (again).  Unless an institution can be flipped, and a big one. I think we’ve seen how The Game works as far as MS, RJ, XOM etc etc….Big Corporations and those that feed from/on them is a private party, and if you want to be invited to the next one (merger, IPO, secondary offering, shelf financing etc), you go along to get along. That’s how this is. Small shareholders need to internalize this fact. You Aren’t Invited. Whatever you do, at least by the rules set up by the Party People, you lose.

Phil knows this. He’s not really part of the “In Crowd”, knew it and it is likely why he set up the company in the Yukon, as a leveling factor.

The vote means nothing to the Pink Pirate. He knew he had it in the bag when he signed on 3+ years ago. Think on that for a bit. If IOC can remediate the appeals court findings, it’s a done dealio.

Your true choice is whether Dissent or the CRP dice roll fits better with your personal timeline vs potential payout equation. All else, IMO, unless an institution flips, is un-reality.

I disagree. First of all, not every institutional holder is an investment banker or otherwise part of the pay-for-play system.  Second, even those that are part of the private party can read court opinions and look at the rise in oil prices and realize there's a lot more money to be had now.  Greed works in our favor in this case, IMHO.

I agree with AU the institutions have a Fiduciary responsibility to their shareholders to protect their assets . The firms now know that the deal substanially undervalued the assets . Therefore unless they want to get sued like TR Price was sued over the Dell deal with success than many will vote no with dissent. Why not ???

Reply

#27
The message I got from the bankers was "dress it up for the court a bit and re-vote the same deal".
Reply

#28

'Putncalls' pid='77849' datel Wrote:The message I got from the bankers was "dress it up for the court a bit and re-vote the same deal".

Are these the same people that thought the appeal was being heard by a single judge and that they were only deciding whether or not to grant an appeal, rather than the fact that it was the actual appeal being heard, by a panel of judges?  If so, I wouldn't give much credence to their opinions because they are obviously not paying much attention.

Reply

#29
Besides, if you read the court's opinions, it is very clear they are not going to be impressed by same deal, dressed up or not.
Reply

#30
It's the banks that vote. What can I say?
Reply



Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: