Lessons to be learned . Or dollars to be paid ! Their choice , might reference the 16.99 T's shown in the Interoil 3rd Quarter report ! Banks can't say they didn't know about the other assets outside E/A. Amazing but true stories !
|
IOC Finance Function moving to XOM???
|
|
11-24-2016, 09:47 AM
Any bank supporting the old deal terms if its approved is setting themselves up for a law suit . Look at what happened to TR Price and their $200 million lost law suit for not opposing the Dell sale ,
Lessons to be learned . Or dollars to be paid ! Their choice , might reference the 16.99 T's shown in the Interoil 3rd Quarter report ! Banks can't say they didn't know about the other assets outside E/A. Amazing but true stories !
Banks don't see to be concerned.
11-24-2016, 12:11 PM
I think JFT and AU74 have some valid points that deserve further investigation.
JFT- I would like to find out how often the situation you mention with Dell occurs when there are contested mergers. Has this case set precedent and how often has this precedent been cited/used? It' s great to not hav ethe burden of being a trailblazer in a litigation strategy, but how wide has this path been cut for IOC?
AU74- How do we identify some of the non-investment bank large holders as ones that would defect? How many shares do they hold? Given the math, if we stick at a 75% voter rate, there needs to be a net defection plus small holder vote switch of 5,,000,000 votes. I agree any further PR to shareholders, especially by Phil's group, that builds on the idea of a NAV valuation in the 90s can be a catalyst for these defections. How quickly will this come to a head? How can the resignation of the CFO and board member be messaged/leveraged to small holders and institutions as an indication of something is rotten in Singapore? I am encouraged that there are many possible paths to a no vote. I believe that given the history of how the big banks/institutions behave, as PutNCalls says, shows us they will won't do anything unless they are forced to. I am not optimistic, but allow for the chance that some of these viewpoints and actions could lead to a no vote. I don't think it's a high probability outcome unless something very different happens very quickly.
Just when I thought I was Out....They Pull Me Back In! -Michael Corleone about the mob and Weasel about investing in IOC
11-24-2016, 12:57 PM
'Putncalls' pid='77852' datel Wrote:It's the banks that vote. What can I say? If the re-vamped deal didnt impress the court, then surely the fact that the banks voted or not, is moot?
11-24-2016, 01:04 PM
'Putncalls' pid='77854' datel Wrote:Banks don't see to be concerned. The banks were not concerned when they were selling CDS's on Synthetic CDO's either, but they got concerned real quick when the ABM's started to fail and kicked the floor tranch out from under the AAA CDO's. The banks still dont understand the problem, but they will soon enough.
11-25-2016, 12:16 AM
The Dell law suit was lead by Carl Icahn and was a US law suit . In my many decades in the securities business I have never dissented before . So it's rare but their are legal precendents for dissenting.
Yukon was a brilliant place to incorporate IOC. Canada is a resource rich country . I don't know the complete history but do know Canadian law which is supported by the Canadian Courts uses its laws to protect smaller shareholders . The laws are there to protect smaller shafeholders from being taken advantage of by large oil and gas firms like Exxon . The old deal was and is a terrible deal and shareholders were tired of waiting for sustainable stock prices . The deals with Oil Search then Exxon were struck as oil and LNG prices bottomed . Today oil and LNG prices are 50 percent higher. Shareholders gave up on the bottom . Thanks to PM we get a redo . The Canadian laws allow shareholders to dissent and the buying firm pays all costs for the courts to determine NAV of the assets . That NAV dollar amount is forced upon the buyer . We have filed our dissent papers with IOC's lawyer in Yukon . They are not deal specific . It's basically a letter from the DTC verifying we own the shares and want the courts to determine NAV for us. It's effective when we file the dissent papers with the courts which we have not done yet is my understanding . Others may know more like 2126.
11-25-2016, 04:45 AM
A 'dissent' is only a dissent from a specific BOD resolution. In this case, it was a dissent from the IOC BOD resolution which approved the sale of IOC assets to Exxon under the specific Arrangement that was the subject of the MIC. It would only apply to that very specific BOD action and, thus in my opinion, a new dissent will be needed. UNLESS, the BOD relies upon the original BOD resolution and attempts to use the exact same Arrangement to push for a new shareholder vote using a new fairness opinion. In that case, as there will be a new vote, there will still also, I believe, need to be a new time period and deadline for shareholders to again dissent. Whether the original dissents will be valid is a question for a Yukon attorney and will, I believe, depend on the very specific manner in which IOC and Exxon chose to go forward. I also suspect that their legal teams are working on possible strategies to minimize the ability of shareholders to have much of a 'dissent' period [or any period at all, if they can swing it]. If there is a new dissent period [and I believe that there will have to be], Exxon and IOC will undoubtedly be looking at a much larger group of dissenters. I will be in that group this time, as I can see that the Yukon courts are going to be more shareholder-friendly than I thought.
11-25-2016, 07:31 AM
The lettet from the DTC is not deal specific. I tried to post a redacted copy but I couldn't make it work . Has no expiration date . My poor computer skills . Sorry .
We have a Yukon lawyer who will review our letters to see what's legal . I agree if the deal changes the odds if us needing a new lettet of dissent seem to a non lawyer quite high . The talk is they are just going to redo the fairness lettet and try again . If that's all they do with my reading of the lettet I can't see why the old lettet would not work . That's why we are using a lawyer to make sure we do it right . Legally they need another vote over the 30 days with new deal terms so plenty of time for others to dissent . If they just try with a new fairness opinion the judges based on what they said last time will not approve the deal again . The price is to low !! Reality check for IOC . PM wants a higher price why not follow on his coat tail ,
11-26-2016, 03:11 AM
'2126' pid='77872' datel Wrote: 2126 I will also dissent if given a second chance. The first vote I just said NO. I could not allay my fears on dissenting and getting it done correctly. I would also dissent (with my new shares -- I freaked out when the appeals court ruled and sold everything), but then there's that old problem with whether or not the shares must be in my name, not street name to do so, and if so, how can I accomplish this from with my IRAs, where virtually all of my savings reside. Did anyone solve this conundrum the last time? I'm looking for solid, specific information, not unsubstantiated claims that it should be easy. Thanks. |
|
« Next Oldest | Next Newest »
|
Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)

