Thread Rating:
  • 1 Vote(s) - 5 Average
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
Per Yukon law see below no charge to dissent
#1
So would you not dissent ????
Under Sec 193 of the YBCA.
Yukon Law
.
Also, FYI, Section 11(b) of Section 193 states the following:
(11) A dissenting shareholder
       (b)  except in special circumstances shall not be required to pay the costs of the application or appraisal.
Reply

#2

'jft310' pid='79051' dateline='<a href="tel:1484697 Wrote:

So would you not dissent ????
Under Sec 193 of the YBCA.
Yukon Law
.
Also, FYI, Section 11(b) of Section 193 states the following:
(11) A dissenting shareholder
       (b)  except in special circumstances shall not be required to pay the costs of the application or appraisal.

The court fee to file an application is if I recall less than 50 Ca dollars.  I think that is the cost the law speaks of; not your legal fees you pay to an attorney.  The appraisal are third party costs of determining a fair value if the court orders it.  That's my interpretation.

Reply

#3
Normally they may charge the $50 you mention but with a dissent application there is no cost is the verbage . We have 2 possible lawyers who can guide us in filing the application . They have not mentioned a fee yet for us to pay . Lawyers usually talk about fees pretty quickly in a relationship . If there is a fee for the lawyer we will deal with that.
All the appraisal fees will be paid by Exxon/Interoil.
The point of the post is get a handle on costs associated with a dissent . Per 193 they are minimal if any at all to dissent . At most pennies on the extra dollars received from that dissent .
If one thinks the assets outside E/A are worthless than they should not dissent . If you believe there is value in that area then you should dissent .
Reply

#4
JFT, can others ride on the coat tails of your efforts? I asked the same of PM but have not heard back.
Reply

#5
Has somerone the details of the fair value calculation made?
Big Grin
Reply

#6
No details on fair value from BMO that I have seen , might be in the 332 page mic .
Ebster one of our lawfirms we would release to accept others . Can't say which one yet. Glad to share details when it's decided . CAC also has a lawyer or has figured out how to be his own attorney . I think he would also help other shareholders. Or solutions will be available to the no attorney issue . Don't let that stop a dissent vote .
Reply

#7

'jft310' pid='79057' dateline='<a href="tel:1484743 Wrote:No details on fair value from BMO that I have seen , might be in the 332 page mic . Ebster one of our lawfirms we would release to accept others . Can't say which one yet. Glad to share details when it's decided . CAC also has a lawyer or has figured out how to be his own attorney . I think he would also help other shareholders. Or solutions will be available to the no attorney issue . Don't let that stop a dissent vote .

The key input in making a decision on whether to dissent is how will "fair value" be determined AND what actions will the court take to make this happen.  YBCA 193 gives the court tremendous latitude to do whatever they want to do.  E.g., they can group all the shareholders dissenting into one group and appoint legal representation, whether that would be the "deep pocket" shareholder - PM or another court appointed lawyer.  The bigger the group, the more likely I believe that to be.  As I understand it IOC will make an initial "fair value" offer, the same for everyone.  Those that refuse that offer will have the burden of arguing their case in court.  That's where legal fees start growing unless you are getting a free ride.  IOC/XOM will be working together in their positions with XOM calling the shots to argue against any increase while the shareholder counsel will use their expert witnesses to argue in favor of a higher value.  We shareholders have zero control of that.  In the end the final value approved by the judges may be higher, the same or lower.  Yes lower, according to one Yukon lawyer I talked to.  But she may be incorrect (I hope).  IOC/XOM have gone to extra lengths to make the deal pass this time.

For me personally, I want to know what are the precedents established from prior dissent cases as regards establishing "fair value."  That is what I want to know.  In a sort of textbook case "fair value" means you have to have a fair market where there are multiple willing and able buyers.  That does NOT exist in PNG.  I sure hope PM and others establish that as a trutth with the court.

Also as PM has argued, it is a well established fact that large fields tend to "grow" in volume after they have been produced for a few years.  The current deal cuts shareholders out of that.  If PM dissents I hope he will argue that point in a way that gets us more money NOW and not e.g., 10 years from now.  He also argued that IOC put wells in the wrong place, like A6, which did not give good results.  That may be hard to argue in court as to what might have been if they had done it differently.

It is not public info yet that PM will dissent.  So far he has argued that the new deal is still not fair.  So it may be that he will repeat what he did last time, making note that IOC/XOM have not addressed the above points, among others.  I hope he does that.  Of course it could back fire and XOM could simple withdraw.  But that might be a very good thing by sending a signal to all others to make their bids without fear of XOM jumping in.  But that outcome seems remote.

Lastly, YBCA 193 has a provision where the company being bought can plead that they cannot meet debt payments AND pay off dissenting shareholders.  So in that case dissenters have to get in line behind other higher priority creditors to get paid.  Since the deal is going to go forward I don't think they can play that card, but I'm not a lawyer.

Bottom line is there are a lot of questions that only a judge or a lawyer with a lot of prior dissent experience can answer.  Based on all the recent resource estimates, it seems pretty likely that nondissenting shareholders will get $45 in XOM shares + maybe another ~$5 and possibly only the shares.

I think the best action for us is to hope/encourage PM and his group to keep challenging the deal in court so that the court will NOT approve the deal.  This will drive them to an offer that really is higher in value, than the "fake offer" they just made.  Then all shareholders win and probably no one dissents.  For the next several weeks we are again watching and waiting to see what PM will do.  My prayers are with you Phil!

Reply

#8
A lot of fear monguring . Is Exxon paying anything for assets outside E/A????
If Exxon is paying zero for those assets then the NAV will come in per the Appellate Court "substanially higher". I would listen to the courts and their language !!
Any court action Phil requests will most likely not be in time for the Feb 14th deadline .
Fair value is not what a dissent is about , our letters specifically state we are asking the courts to make a Net Asset Value determination not a fair value determination , you are getting bad info Kali , the courts have already accepted Paradigm Capital's NAV work . That will be updated with current drilling or the courts could use another NAV determination .
If you have not previously dissented you would not know that .
One can change their vote , when we get our materials we will vote no and dissent because it takes time to dissent . Best to allow a week plus .
Can always change your vote you can't always dissent! because of time issues .
Just call your broker dealer and start the process ,
Reply

#9

'jft310' pid='79064' datel Wrote:A lot of fear monguring . Is Exxon paying anything for assets outside E/A???? If Exxon is paying zero for those assets then the NAV will come in per the Appellate Court "substanially higher". I would listen to the courts and their language !! Any court action Phil requests will most likely not be in time for the Feb 14th deadline . Fair value is not what a dissent is about , our letters specifically state we are asking the courts to make a Net Asset Value determination not a fair value determination , you are getting bad info Kali , the courts have already accepted Paradigm Capital's NAV work . That will be updated with current drilling or the courts could use another NAV determination . If you have not previously dissented you would not know that . One can change their vote , when we get our materials we will vote no and dissent because it takes time to dissent . Best to allow a week plus . Can always change your vote you can't always dissent! because of time issues . Just call your broker dealer and start the process ,

JFT, First of all the YBCA law fixes the valuation date based on what the company was worth as of the adoption date of the resolution which was Dec 15.  So unless the law is changed, any information from well 7 has to be ignored, positive or negative.  No new information can be used in the valuation as I read it.

I have asked Phil via their Concerned IOC Shareholder site to release any expert witness information previously presented in court  that might help shareholders to better understand value.  IF he does that, we will be in much better shape to make a decision.  Since IOC and XOM have it, I don't know why shareholders don't have it too.  Not releasing this information is in my opinion, another reason why the deal is not fair.  But this info is owned by Phil.  I don't think it is IOC's job to release it in the MIC.

You can bet this for sure.  XOM is now driving what will be said in court.  They have the Paradigm report and all the other information we don't have and will be making their counter arguments through IOC legal representation.  From reading the court summary it seems IOC lawyers were not prepared for this in the last appeal.  They will be next time.  Essentially XOM is the ventriliquist and IOC is the dummy going forward.

The dissent process throught the broker part seems easy and low/no cost.  No issue there at all other than maybe tax implications.  The problems begin with the "filing the application" and getting a Yukon lawyer, that has a clue.  Initially IOC will make the same offer to all dissenters.  IF it is a good offer (I doubt it), then we all celebrate and go home.  If it is a bad offer or minimally better offer, then one has to decide what to do.  At that point it will be determined by the court whether to group all of remaining dissenters into one case or let us each go it alone.  We have no control over that.  The court decides.  Also, the court can decide to bring in a 3rd party to decide the value and make that one stick.  That is what I read in YBCA 193.

A key legal question is after being presented the offer or litigating for a better offer, can a dissenter repeal his dissent and just accept the arrangement.  If so, then that eliminates all the downside.  It seems this is spelled out in YBCA 193 section (13) (14) and (16).  There are several triggers mentioned which once they occur, the dissenter can no longer withdraw his dissent.

I'm hunting for a Yukon lawyer.  So far I talked to one.  Not real helpful, but they offered to have someone from another firm contact me (a referral).  No call yet.  If you have any suggestions, please send me a private message.

One of Phil's strongest arguments is that you have to wait for years of production to find out the true size of the field.  I agree.  But I don't want to wait 10 years to get to that point to get paid, especially since every promise as to when we'd get to FID and first production has been broken over and over again.  So a key question is how does one take that fact AND turn it into a value to be settled in court.  That cold be a challenge.

It's one thing to have a competent, "dissent" experienced, merger & aquisitions focused business law firm leading one in the decision process.  I.e., people who know what they are doing and have been there and done it multiple times.  I suspect those guys are locked up by IOC, XOM, and PM, but will keep trying.

Good luck to all.

Reply

#10

'Kaliboo' pid='79067' datel Wrote:

'jft310' pid='79064' datel Wrote:A lot of fear monguring . Is Exxon paying anything for assets outside E/A???? If Exxon is paying zero for those assets then the NAV will come in per the Appellate Court "substanially higher". I would listen to the courts and their language !! Any court action Phil requests will most likely not be in time for the Feb 14th deadline . Fair value is not what a dissent is about , our letters specifically state we are asking the courts to make a Net Asset Value determination not a fair value determination , you are getting bad info Kali , the courts have already accepted Paradigm Capital's NAV work . That will be updated with current drilling or the courts could use another NAV determination . If you have not previously dissented you would not know that . One can change their vote , when we get our materials we will vote no and dissent because it takes time to dissent . Best to allow a week plus . Can always change your vote you can't always dissent! because of time issues . Just call your broker dealer and start the process ,

JFT, First of all the YBCA law fixes the valuation date based on what the company was worth as of the adoption date of the resolution which was Dec 15.  So unless the law is changed, any information from well 7 has to be ignored, positive or negative.  No new information can be used in the valuation as I read it.

I have asked Phil via their Concerned IOC Shareholder site to release any expert witness information previously presented in court  that might help shareholders to better understand value.  IF he does that, we will be in much better shape to make a decision.  Since IOC and XOM have it, I don't know why shareholders don't have it too.  Not releasing this information is in my opinion, another reason why the deal is not fair.  But this info is owned by Phil.  I don't think it is IOC's job to release it in the MIC.

You can bet this for sure.  XOM is now driving what will be said in court.  They have the Paradigm report and all the other information we don't have and will be making their counter arguments through IOC legal representation.  From reading the court summary it seems IOC lawyers were not prepared for this in the last appeal.  They will be next time.  Essentially XOM is the ventriliquist and IOC is the dummy going forward.

The dissent process throught the broker part seems easy and low/no cost.  No issue there at all other than maybe tax implications.  The problems begin with the "filing the application" and getting a Yukon lawyer, that has a clue.  Initially IOC will make the same offer to all dissenters.  IF it is a good offer (I doubt it), then we all celebrate and go home.  If it is a bad offer or minimally better offer, then one has to decide what to do.  At that point it will be determined by the court whether to group all of remaining dissenters into one case or let us each go it alone.  We have no control over that.  The court decides.  Also, the court can decide to bring in a 3rd party to decide the value and make that one stick.  That is what I read in YBCA 193.

A key legal question is after being presented the offer or litigating for a better offer, can a dissenter repeal his dissent and just accept the arrangement.  If so, then that eliminates all the downside.  It seems this is spelled out in YBCA 193 section (13) (14) and (16).  There are several triggers mentioned which once they occur, the dissenter can no longer withdraw his dissent.

I'm hunting for a Yukon lawyer.  So far I talked to one.  Not real helpful, but they offered to have someone from another firm contact me (a referral).  No call yet.  If you have any suggestions, please send me a private message.

One of Phil's strongest arguments is that you have to wait for years of production to find out the true size of the field.  I agree.  But I don't want to wait 10 years to get to that point to get paid, especially since every promise as to when we'd get to FID and first production has been broken over and over again.  So a key question is how does one take that fact AND turn it into a value to be settled in court.  That cold be a challenge.

It's one thing to have a competent, "dissent" experienced, merger & aquisitions focused business law firm leading one in the decision process.  I.e., people who know what they are doing and have been there and done it multiple times.  I suspect those guys are locked up by IOC, XOM, and PM, but will keep trying.

Good luck to all.

I agree with you. If the assumptions in the Paradigm report are fair, there is no reason to dissent.

Big Grin
Reply



Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: