10-25-2012, 02:21 AM
["STP, odd that you dug up American Thinker vs. Soros. At that time, you discredited American Thinker because you view them as right wing, therefore their case was un credible."]
I have to take issue with that as I don't think that's a fair rendition of what I argued at the time. It wasn't the political orientation of the American Thinker, it was the evidence presented in the article that swayed me. I spend a whole day looking at that, and I think it was particularly weak. With hindsight, I think its even weaker now.
The thesis of the American Thinker was that Soros was financing (or even masterminding, I don't remember) an anti-fracking movement because he had interests in InterOil and Petrobras which would benefit from reduced competition from American shale gas.
At the minimum, I believed that thesis was far-fetched, considering the evidence presented in it, I can't say I was impressed by it, here are my findings:
http://shareholdersunite.com/2010/10/21/soros-fracking/
But since that, we know:
- Soros isn't invested in IOC anymore (at the time, he was already out of Petrobras)
- He has significant shale gas investments in Poland
After that, I find the thesis of that article having even less merit, to be honest.
As a habit, I don't really care all that much what the political orientation of a particular author is. We ALL have political views of some sort. I'll take them in as one, but just one factor. I try to focus mostly at the merits of articles, like I did with that American Thinker piece of Soros.
I'm familiar with Mark Weisbrot, by the way (not personally, but with some of his work).
I have to take issue with that as I don't think that's a fair rendition of what I argued at the time. It wasn't the political orientation of the American Thinker, it was the evidence presented in the article that swayed me. I spend a whole day looking at that, and I think it was particularly weak. With hindsight, I think its even weaker now.
The thesis of the American Thinker was that Soros was financing (or even masterminding, I don't remember) an anti-fracking movement because he had interests in InterOil and Petrobras which would benefit from reduced competition from American shale gas.
At the minimum, I believed that thesis was far-fetched, considering the evidence presented in it, I can't say I was impressed by it, here are my findings:
http://shareholdersunite.com/2010/10/21/soros-fracking/
But since that, we know:
- Soros isn't invested in IOC anymore (at the time, he was already out of Petrobras)
- He has significant shale gas investments in Poland
After that, I find the thesis of that article having even less merit, to be honest.
As a habit, I don't really care all that much what the political orientation of a particular author is. We ALL have political views of some sort. I'll take them in as one, but just one factor. I try to focus mostly at the merits of articles, like I did with that American Thinker piece of Soros.
I'm familiar with Mark Weisbrot, by the way (not personally, but with some of his work).

