'Crippsfl' pid='35025' datel Wrote:
'SamAdams' pid='35024' datel Wrote:The stock fell because the company delivered a deal well below expectations. That doesn't mean it isn't a good long term deal, but it was not in-line with expecations. And the stock had just run from the high $60s to low $90s on a bullish cc. Hoever, management did leave out that deal price expectations were not realistic. And they knew that. :Market was thinking XOM at well above $ per mcf and perhaps a 10% stake in PNG LNG ro soome variation of that. What we know is XOM was not even close to TOT offer. The rest is noise or excuses. If expectations had been reset when stock was in $60s, perhaps the stock would have risen post deal. It's all about expectations and the current managment did not manage those properly. They knew the XOM deal from May was not a good one and they dealt with that, but they never adressed the $ per mcf issue that, rightly or wrongly, ;many focused on. I imagine there were some large shareholders who were not happy with MH on the guidance issue.
I am having trouble understanding your comment that " management did leave out that deal price expectations were not realistic." The pps went up after an enthusiastic CC. Everything that Hession said was true. The market responded by a big jump in share price. What did you want management to do, put out a press release afterwards saying "Whoa, don't get real excited. The deal isn't THAT good?" Imagine what the pps would have done then!
There is no question that our friends in France did us NO favors with their premature press release basically giving the lowest case scenario. By the time IOC management could respond, the horse was out of the barn. Yes, it SHOULD have been a joint release giving a more realistic presentation of the deal. The stock probably would still have dropped, but nothing like what happened. Hopefully, Total and IOC management have had discussions since about how future press releases will be handled.
As a matter of fact they did have discussions. It's written into the SPA in section13 as clear as the ink on the PDF. Clearly they didn't follow their own agreement. Why is the question. This is the easy stuff to do in the agreement.

