12-25-2013, 11:51 AM
My take is as follows: the purpose of the stock dividend/stock split (there is a legal difference, but in reality there is very little economic difference) is to try and trigger an event wherein the longs that have their shares on loan are incentivized to call their shares. When the shares are called, the shorts are then forced to cover.
I have seen stock loan agreements from two major brokerage houses. Both have language that state that the borrowers of the shares will compensate the lenders so that they are kept whole. For instance, if the company pays ordinary cash dividends, then borrowers of the shares will pay the lenders an amount that factors into account that ordinary dividends are taxed at a rate less than the compensation payed to lenders.
I do not remember specifically how the agreements treat stock splits/stock dividends. (FYI - neither event is taxable to the shareholder.) I have sent an e-mail to the loan department of one of the brokerage houses and will share when I get it. Someways it seems that if IOC pays a 50% dividend (a 3 for 2 split), as long as the borrower returns 50% more shares there is no need for the shares to be called. Again, I do not know for sure, but I should have good information in a couple of days.
On a different note, a member of IOC management has stated to me that they have to be careful about approaching major shareholders asking them to call their shares as some arcane securities laws are involved. So I wonder if management said they would, or if they were vague in answering specific questions on the topic, then it might lead one to think that they will.
Merry Christmas.

