On Exxon, Wall Street did not know the price and other terms. I believe management that it was inferior to the Total deal.
Agree Total deal announcement was poorly handled.
On arbitration, I don't think Total was willing to deal with the minority interests, and they were in negotiations with them and I don't think could not have known what Pac LNG and OSH would do. The important thing is they handled it in a way that enabled them to win, and moved ahead on appraisal and exploration.- Total was not responsible for buying out the minority (Pac LNG) holdings; IOC was per the SPA. Plenty of discussion here and elsewhere on how this was handled poorly by Hession et al.
Previous management could not have obtained the credit line, I feel sure. I think the new analysts are a significant plus and due in part to new management, and maybe wider holdings is better. Would agree
They inherited a company in extremely bad condition for a "normal" drilling program, especially with the rig capabilities and financial liquidity, and they saved the leases and turned it around with enormous improvements in personnel, equipment, and drilling efficiency. That was not a short-term problem. Agree
The amount of certification payment is more important than getting it six months sooner, especially given the short-term LNG market. You could be talking about $500 million or a $billion more.- Matter of opinion I suppose, but at this point there is little doubt that they have enough gas for the 2-train startup. That's the main plan and the longer you spend deliniating, the longer it takes to get rest of project planning/execution done. Also little doubt that they likely have plenty of gas for expansion; a problem PNG LNG has struggled with all along. If they prove up enough gas day one for expansion, the government could request Train 3 for PNG LNG (remember the government ownership of OSH). We really don't want that I don't think. Get the 2-train startup proven up, get the Certification payment (likely would be based on 9-10 Ts). If they don't have to tap the LOC and can avoid additional interest expense, all the better. If they have to pay off the $69,998,000 Notes in cash instead of using the acquired shares, they will be getting tight on cash after that payment. If they have to tap that LOC, that would be a shame as that plus interest would come out of the later Certification payment. Get Certification, hopefully get a deal or two in the works from Wahoo or Tri/Raptor/Bobcat and we may never have to tap that LOC. We get the added Ts from Ant7 eventually. This "delay" has been longer than "6 months" as arbitration DID hold things up as Total started coasting, and who could blame them?
1. See "drilling" above. They have gotten much better at execution, not just target setting. Little if any similarity to prior management. Better than prior management at frequency of talk. OK
2. Ant 4 due mostly to having to use a much inferior rig and governmental foot-dragging. I'm glad they used it with Ant 4 and not Ant 5. "Having to use inferior rig"? Would like to hear some of their reasoning there when Ant 5 was started later and finished before. Someone HAD to know the Ant 4 rig was a POS.
3. See above. Agree delayed things, but not sure could have been avoided, and won. They did not waste that time. Completely disagree. IOC botched the important piece they were responsible for and put Total in a tough spot. Total has/had a relationship with OSH and mentioned how that relationship was tainted through the arbitration. I realize Botten made the move, but what shrewd businessman wouldn't have jumped at that opportunity especially if there was a chance Total might cancel deal. Exit Total, enter Exxon. This delayed this by close to a year as far as things like Total being appointed Operator, etc. Old JV was in place until arbitration was settled. Etc., etc., etc.
4. Agree in hindsight buyback not handled well by them and/or advisor. Share price not controllable by them, and shall see where it goes. They can handle $70 million payoff if necessary. $70 million plus the approx. $47 million they spent on the share buyback. Wasted $$$ is wasted $$$ and it's not a small amount.
5. See drilling and certification payment comment above. Agree with final comment."

