(07-16-2015, 12:41 PM)Palm Wrote: Croozer, After looking at this more I agree that it's most likely that they will pay the balance of $69,998,000 in November to retire the notes. To finish this with a final "beating" we just need to understand that by spending the $42 million or so to buy and retire the 732k shares they in effect locked in the 7.91% bifurcated rate they disclose in the financials. The bond holders will not realize this of course, but IOC will incur the $70 million + $42 million; $112 million plus the 2.75% interest. So in effect IOC decided to be "conservative" and lock up the shares to be ready for conversion, whether initiated by bondholders or IOC (should the pps get to just over $119). Question is was it "wise" to spend the $42 million when they did (the equivalent of their share of 2 wells plus in PRL 15). Hindsight is 20-20 I know, but we have that luxury. If I were a bondholder I'd be a bit PO'd if in the end I lent this risky company for 5 years and ended up getting my money back, plus a whopping 2.75% interest annually. Will be hard to do anything like this in the future as the IBs and their clients will likely say, "You fooled us once". Some may say $42 million "isn't that much", and that is for each to decide, but still not sure what they thought was going to propel pps to the levels of the high $90s or to the $119 area given the circumstances of Aug 2014. It is done.
Glad you agree on the retirement. I also do not believe any conspiracy theory applies here.
I disagree it will be that hard to do something similar in the future. This is a totally different company than five years ago, and the bankers and clients will be looking ahead, not looking back, and the bankers looking for business.
In hindsight, I agree the buyback was not worth it, but I think most here were almost pounding the table for one, some for a much bigger one (not me), and I agree with Gator on the fundamentals of it. What could have "propelled pps" much higher is the certification in the absence of collapse in oil prices. Huge pps move up still possible, but it would certainly seem to be a long shot in that time frame I wonder if there is a way they could resell those shares in the future at a much higher price?

