Thread Rating:
  • 3 Vote(s) - 2.33 Average
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
Appeals Decision
#4

'2126' pid='77539' datel Wrote:

The pertinent parts of this long court decision are, in my opinion, below:

34. ... "A board engaged in a proper and robust review and consideration of a proposed transformative transaction should have obtained independent advice on the value of the CRP, the Elk-Antelope asset, and the 10 CFE’s impact on the CRP..Moreover, those estimates of value should have been disclosed to shareholders so that shareholders could decide whether the US$45 plus the capped CRP adequately reflected the value of the company. In the absence of this guidance, shareholders would not know the value of the Elk-Antelope asset, what they gave up by agreeing to capped the CRP at 10 CFE, and whether the terms of the Transaction fairly reflected the value of the Elk-Antelope asset. In circumstances where a financial expert’s compensation depends in part on the success or failure of a transaction, shareholders must be in a position to evaluate whether the advice is influenced by these terms of payment. In the circumstances of this transaction, it is my view that the Board should have disclosed the details of the compensation payable to Morgan Stanley. It should also have engaged a second financial advisor whose compensation would not be dependent upon the success or failure of the transaction."

40. "...court approval was also required by the Act to ensure the decision was fair and reasonable in the sense of being based on information and advice that was adequate, objective and not undermined by conflicts of interest. Given the ‘red flags’ in this case – the absence of a fairness opinion from an independent expert, the failure of Morgan Stanley to assess the value of the CRP as compared with the value of the PRL prospects (again, the company’s primary asset); the deficiencies pointed out by Mr. Dey; the unchallenged report of Mr. Booth; the fact the CEO was in a position of conflict; the probability the “independent” special committee was not independent of management; and the lack of “necessity” for the deal – the Court was required to do more than accept the vote of the majority as a “proxy” for fairness, or the cash amount of Exxon’s offer as a proxy for reasonableness."

This indicates the route for IOC to take to correct this deal:

1. Obtain independent advice on the value of the CRP [particularly as compared to the value of the PRL prospects], the Elk-Antelope asset, and the 10 CFE cap's impact on the CRP.

2. Disclose this advice to shareholders [presumably in a new MIC]

3. Disclose the details of the compensation payable to Morgan Stanley [or a new firm]

4. Engage a second financial advisor whose compensation would not be dependent upon the success or failure of the transaction.

In reading through this decision, I am struck by the quality of Phil's legal team. They clearly outclassed the Exxon/IOC lawyers at every turn. Their use of Paradigm Capital and Peter Dey,  former Chair of the Ontario Securities Commission and also a former chairman of Morgan Stanley, was brilliant and unopposed by Exxon's legal team. This opinion should set IOC back on its heels and particularly damage MH with its clear indication of Hession's conflict of interest in this deal.

Thank you! Awesome information. I have read through a lot of this information and what I don't see is the valuation of TBR-W, the fact Hession was paid a bonus on those assets and subsequently value them at $0 in the transaction. Many here agree that the transaction should be E/A or PRL 15 only.....not a peep about that in any of the Phil info or the courts etc....

Just when I thought I was Out....They Pull Me Back In! -Michael Corleone about the mob and Weasel about investing in IOC
Reply



Messages In This Thread
Appeals Decision - by 2126 - 11-11-2016, 02:08 AM
RE: Appeals Decision - by thg - 11-11-2016, 02:12 AM
RE: Appeals Decision - by 2126 - 11-11-2016, 02:48 AM
RE: Appeals Decision - by weaselpuppy - 11-11-2016, 03:29 AM
RE: Appeals Decision - by sageo - 11-11-2016, 03:42 AM
RE: Appeals Decision - by Martinistocks - 11-11-2016, 03:31 AM
RE: Appeals Decision - by 2126 - 11-11-2016, 03:35 AM
RE: Appeals Decision - by 2126 - 11-11-2016, 05:18 AM
RE: Appeals Decision - by Martinistocks - 11-11-2016, 04:13 AM
RE: Appeals Decision - by thg - 11-11-2016, 04:28 AM
RE: Appeals Decision - by Poman - 11-11-2016, 06:11 AM
RE: Appeals Decision - by Getitrt2 - 11-11-2016, 07:25 AM
RE: Appeals Decision - by Poman - 11-11-2016, 09:22 AM
RE: Appeals Decision - by CAC - 11-11-2016, 07:46 AM
RE: Appeals Decision - by admin - 11-11-2016, 04:20 AM
RE: Appeals Decision - by Putncalls - 11-11-2016, 05:10 AM
RE: Appeals Decision - by admin - 11-11-2016, 05:48 AM
RE: Appeals Decision - by Getitrt2 - 11-11-2016, 06:44 AM
RE: Appeals Decision - by jft310 - 11-11-2016, 10:57 PM
RE: Appeals Decision - by jft310 - 11-11-2016, 11:16 PM
RE: Appeals Decision - by Putncalls - 11-12-2016, 04:49 AM
RE: Appeals Decision - by Getitrt2 - 11-12-2016, 09:03 AM
RE: Appeals Decision - by Putncalls - 11-12-2016, 09:21 AM
RE: Appeals Decision - by ArtM72 - 11-12-2016, 01:25 PM
RE: Appeals Decision - by Putncalls - 11-12-2016, 01:59 PM
RE: Appeals Decision - by admin - 11-12-2016, 02:26 PM
RE: Appeals Decision - by Relker - 11-12-2016, 11:46 PM
RE: Appeals Decision - by jft310 - 11-12-2016, 11:44 PM
RE: Appeals Decision - by admin - 11-12-2016, 11:50 PM
RE: Appeals Decision - by jft310 - 11-12-2016, 11:54 PM
RE: Appeals Decision - by admin - 11-13-2016, 12:42 AM
RE: Appeals Decision - by jft310 - 11-13-2016, 04:11 AM
RE: Appeals Decision - by Putncalls - 11-13-2016, 04:53 AM
RE: Appeals Decision - by ArtM72 - 11-13-2016, 11:02 AM
RE: Appeals Decision - by sageo - 11-14-2016, 02:26 AM
RE: Appeals Decision - by jft310 - 11-13-2016, 11:27 AM
RE: Appeals Decision - by Putncalls - 11-13-2016, 12:33 PM
RE: Appeals Decision - by Relker - 11-13-2016, 07:33 PM
RE: Appeals Decision - by Kaliboo - 11-14-2016, 01:06 AM
RE: Appeals Decision - by jft310 - 11-14-2016, 01:33 AM
RE: Appeals Decision - by Kaliboo - 11-14-2016, 01:56 AM
RE: Appeals Decision - by jft310 - 11-14-2016, 02:10 AM

Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)