'jft310' pid='79057' dateline='<a href="tel:1484743 Wrote:No details on fair value from BMO that I have seen , might be in the 332 page mic . Ebster one of our lawfirms we would release to accept others . Can't say which one yet. Glad to share details when it's decided . CAC also has a lawyer or has figured out how to be his own attorney . I think he would also help other shareholders. Or solutions will be available to the no attorney issue . Don't let that stop a dissent vote .
The key input in making a decision on whether to dissent is how will "fair value" be determined AND what actions will the court take to make this happen. YBCA 193 gives the court tremendous latitude to do whatever they want to do. E.g., they can group all the shareholders dissenting into one group and appoint legal representation, whether that would be the "deep pocket" shareholder - PM or another court appointed lawyer. The bigger the group, the more likely I believe that to be. As I understand it IOC will make an initial "fair value" offer, the same for everyone. Those that refuse that offer will have the burden of arguing their case in court. That's where legal fees start growing unless you are getting a free ride. IOC/XOM will be working together in their positions with XOM calling the shots to argue against any increase while the shareholder counsel will use their expert witnesses to argue in favor of a higher value. We shareholders have zero control of that. In the end the final value approved by the judges may be higher, the same or lower. Yes lower, according to one Yukon lawyer I talked to. But she may be incorrect (I hope). IOC/XOM have gone to extra lengths to make the deal pass this time.
For me personally, I want to know what are the precedents established from prior dissent cases as regards establishing "fair value." That is what I want to know. In a sort of textbook case "fair value" means you have to have a fair market where there are multiple willing and able buyers. That does NOT exist in PNG. I sure hope PM and others establish that as a trutth with the court.
Also as PM has argued, it is a well established fact that large fields tend to "grow" in volume after they have been produced for a few years. The current deal cuts shareholders out of that. If PM dissents I hope he will argue that point in a way that gets us more money NOW and not e.g., 10 years from now. He also argued that IOC put wells in the wrong place, like A6, which did not give good results. That may be hard to argue in court as to what might have been if they had done it differently.
It is not public info yet that PM will dissent. So far he has argued that the new deal is still not fair. So it may be that he will repeat what he did last time, making note that IOC/XOM have not addressed the above points, among others. I hope he does that. Of course it could back fire and XOM could simple withdraw. But that might be a very good thing by sending a signal to all others to make their bids without fear of XOM jumping in. But that outcome seems remote.
Lastly, YBCA 193 has a provision where the company being bought can plead that they cannot meet debt payments AND pay off dissenting shareholders. So in that case dissenters have to get in line behind other higher priority creditors to get paid. Since the deal is going to go forward I don't think they can play that card, but I'm not a lawyer.
Bottom line is there are a lot of questions that only a judge or a lawyer with a lot of prior dissent experience can answer. Based on all the recent resource estimates, it seems pretty likely that nondissenting shareholders will get $45 in XOM shares + maybe another ~$5 and possibly only the shares.
I think the best action for us is to hope/encourage PM and his group to keep challenging the deal in court so that the court will NOT approve the deal. This will drive them to an offer that really is higher in value, than the "fake offer" they just made. Then all shareholders win and probably no one dissents. For the next several weeks we are again watching and waiting to see what PM will do. My prayers are with you Phil!

