|
Appeals Decision
|
|
11-11-2016, 05:10 AM
If they tried to put this before the Canadian court the LNG project(s) would be on hold forever?
(11-11-2016, 03:35 AM)2126 Wrote: A final note on the importance of this: The Appeals Court, in stating that such an independent appraisal firm assesses the "value of the CRP compared to the PRL prospects" is, in my opinion, stating that an 'asset value' approach should be taken in any new 'fairness opinion' and NOT a 'market value' approach. This is very significant, as one of the main IOC BOD arguments as to why the deal was fair was that it would pay a premium on the past, depressed market value of IOC shares--$45 as opposed to the average Spring 2016 pps of around $30. A independent comparison of the proposed CRP with its 10 T cap to the actual asset value of the 'PRL prospects' would clearly reveal the gross undervaluing of the deal.
11-11-2016, 05:48 AM
Insofar as you are right (and I have no reason to assume otherwise), this is indeed quite significant. However, insofar as an asset value approach indeed exposes the gross undervaluation of the deal, the whole deal might also be off. While we do have Total to fall back on, it's a bit of a mixed blessing as to the immediate prospects though.
(11-11-2016, 04:13 AM)Martinistocks Wrote: I agree what about TBR? Is that just a throw into the deal. Thought we had discoveries and real value. This whole thing is BS. The IOC/XOM position is that the $45 in XOM shares include the value of all the TBR assets and future value of LNG production, etc.
11-11-2016, 06:44 AM
It seems to me that to get the kind of independent fairness opinions the Court seems to be calling for, they would need not just the kind of financial firm as Morgan Stanley, but input from an independent resource engineering firm. It almost seems as if they need to wait for the Total agreement certifications to properly value E/A, which might be a time frame not too much different from properly meeting the Court's requirements. Without one or the other, how could they even meet the Court requirements with a 10 Tcfe cap, especially given GLJ's estimate without Ant. 7?
Am I hearing there is a lack of challenge in the appeal for not getting any value for other assets beyond E/A, such as other PRL 15 potential, the Triceratops PRL, and discoveries at Raptor and Bobcat? Given the expected delay now, does anyone need to be addressing the PRL 15 renewal?
11-11-2016, 07:25 AM
'Poman' pid='77551' datel Wrote: If I remember correctly, Petrengr1 sees the $45 as paying only for the first 6.2 Tcfe of E/A, and full payment from Total still leaves IOC with about 36% gross of the LNG project.
11-11-2016, 07:46 AM
'Poman' ========== The IOC/XOM position is that the $45 in XOM shares include the value of all the TBR assets and future value of LNG production, etc. ******* I believe this is correct. Because of the interplay between the TOT deal and the XOM offer, I think there has been an assumption by some on this Board that the $45 was reflective soley on the value of E/A (thus creating a straw man argument that IOC was getting nothing for all the other assets) but I don't think that was ever specicially stated by IOC, XOM, or the deal-terms themselves.
11-11-2016, 09:22 AM
'Getitrt2' pid='77553' datel Wrote: There is a valid argument that the $45 is too low, but it was something like a 30% premium from where we were trading. Just another reason to have a independent valuation we can trust.
11-11-2016, 10:57 PM
This is the part I like . PM thinks he can prove $93 a share in current value .
30] As mentioned, the case at bar does not involve a conflict between different classes of securityholders or the ‘balancing’ of conflicting legal rights. Rather, it involves conflicting views as to the financial situation and prospects of InterOil and the degree of risk to which shareholders wish their investments to be subject going forward. (One assumes the shares were acquired with the understanding they were “speculative” in the first place.]On the one hand, Mr. Mulacek sees the company as “well-positioned” to develop its share in the Elk-Antelope fields with its joint venture partners. He deposed: The project development timeline anticipates completion of appraisal drilling in 2016, resource confirmation in 2017, and commercial production in 2022. The terms and structure of the ExxonMobil Transaction unfairly and inappropriately deny Interoil shareholders any reasonable retained participation in, or compensation for, the vast upside of potential value of the resource. This is particularly egregious given the fact that I believe a development decision on this gas field asset is imminent, which will materially de-risk the project and unlock additional value. In my view, the terms and structure of the ExxonMobil Transaction fail to provide fair consideration to Interoil shareholders. Under the … Transaction, Interoil shareholders will receive for each common share of Interoil (a) a fixed component comprised of ExxonMobil shares worth $45; and (b) a capped contingent component based on a one-time interim resource estimate. The absence of any subsequent contingent payments tied to future growth in resource estimates based on recertification after production is underway unfairly denies Interoil’s shareholders any participation in the value upside created through commercialization of this key gas resource asset. This Transaction structure effectively shifts the entire upside potential value of this gas resource to ExxonMobil after the initial recertification payment. In addition, the … Transaction fails to ensure that the interim resource certification process for the contingent payment calculation is fair, transparent, and focused on accurately assessing the potential resource. Among other things, ExxonMobil will run the interim resource certification process without the participation of Interoil’s long-time independent resource appraiser and with no effective oversight or involvement of any Interoil shareholder nominee. The structure and terms of the Transaction in respect of the interim resource certification for the contingent payment unfairly favours ExxonMobil, who is incentivized to achieve a low contingent payment. [Emphasis added.]
11-11-2016, 11:16 PM
Mr Booth of Paradigm Capital stated
When examining the resource estimates summarized in the Company’s AIFs from 2008 to 2015, it is evident that there has been a history of positive estimate revisions, with GLJ consistently increasing its 1C, 2C and 3C volumes. Indeed, from 2008 to 2015, the 2C volumes were increased from 631 mmboe gross (3.79 Tcfe) to 1,663 mmboe gross (9.98 Tcfe). In our opinion, this indicates an increasing confidence in the resource estimate due to a lack of negative revisions over time. It reflected new developments and information, such as the availability of seismic data and the completion of five Antelope wells and three Elk wells. Based on this historical trend, it is reasonable to expect further positive estimate revisions with the scheduled completion of two new Antelope wells and the resulting test data. |
|
« Next Oldest | Next Newest »
|
Users browsing this thread:

