Posts: 12,025
Threads: 1,809
Joined: Apr 2008
Reputation:
227
Well, welcome aboard Haggerston and thanks for the perspective. It all seems to hinge on two issues:
- Whether the cash is there (and if it is, that greatly reduces the chance of NQ having inflated revenues, as the books have to add up)
- Whether Yidatong is de-facto part of, or cooperating in some nefarious practices with NQ.
On the first note, the fact that they've been classified by Level 2 isn't in and by itself reason to assume the cash isn't there, but we have to await further confirmation.
On the second note, I'm encouraged what Macquarie said about that this morning, although it isn't an iron clad guarantee either.
Posts: 278
Threads: 22
Joined: Dec 2012
Reputation:
17
I personally dont think YTD is even a factor. The reality is, NQ gets great pricing from YTD as a SP. If anything, that signals to me that they at a minimum have an at-arms length deal.
Posts: 549
Threads: 16
Joined: Aug 2012
Reputation:
119
I agree, YTD has been vetted before and is really old news. Major institutional investors have no inncentive to step in now and buy as NQ is not in any relevant small cap benchmark index. I have heard some smaller insitutional oweners just threw in the towel. There is a herd mentality as even smart institutional investors can be scared. The cash is there and has been audited by PWC. It's a red herring. For an experienced China investor like CB to not be aware of the accounting changes and that other major Chinese companies are applying the same rules is incredulous. We know why he had not "seen" this before. Does IOC need to have their gas re-certified every time someone says they have no gas (oh, that's what they used to say). MW has made the victim (NQ) seem like the criminal when the crime has been committed by them. Stronger insitutional owndership could have cushioned this a bit but many retail investors were stampeded in the rush to get out. I welcome the independant review but hope they hold thier analyst day and earnings calls as scheduled. A brief statement from PWC would be nice as well but I feel confident in the results in any event.