Thread Rating:
  • 0 Vote(s) - 0 Average
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
Blame for the stock drop.?
#1

There are 2 entities that caused the stock to drop in price

One Total who issued a Press Release with misleading and not complete information

Two Credit Suisse who owned puts and advised Total on the deal/ release

Hello!

Interoil was in damage control mode and did not cause the stock to drop. They cut a deal with uncapped upside with a 30

percent interest in an LNG project.

So if ya want to sue someone mark sure you sue the right parties

Hint it's not IOC

Best to not sue anyone let them close this deal and drill ahead and we make a rapid recovery.

Reply

#2

The stock fell because the company delivered a deal well below expectations.  That doesn't mean it isn't a good long term deal, but it was not in-line with expecations.  And the stock had just run from the high $60s to low $90s on a bullish cc.  Hoever, management did leave out that deal price expectations were not realistic.  And they knew that.  :Market was thinking XOM at well above $ per mcf and perhaps a 10% stake in PNG LNG  ro soome variation of that.  What we know is XOM was not even close to TOT offer.  The rest is noise or excuses.  If expectations had been reset when stock was in $60s, perhaps the stock would have risen post deal.  It's all about expectations and the current managment did not manage those properly.  They knew the XOM deal from May was not a good one and they dealt with that, but they never adressed the $ per mcf issue that, rightly or wrongly, ;many focused on.  I imagine there were some large shareholders who were not happy with MH on the guidance issue.

Reply

#3

'SamAdams' pid='35024' datel Wrote:

The stock fell because the company delivered a deal well below expectations.  That doesn't mean it isn't a good long term deal, but it was not in-line with expecations.  And the stock had just run from the high $60s to low $90s on a bullish cc.  Hoever, management did leave out that deal price expectations were not realistic.  And they knew that.  :Market was thinking XOM at well above $ per mcf and perhaps a 10% stake in PNG LNG  ro soome variation of that.  What we know is XOM was not even close to TOT offer.  The rest is noise or excuses.  If expectations had been reset when stock was in $60s, perhaps the stock would have risen post deal.  It's all about expectations and the current managment did not manage those properly.  They knew the XOM deal from May was not a good one and they dealt with that, but they never adressed the $ per mcf issue that, rightly or wrongly, ;many focused on.  I imagine there were some large shareholders who were not happy with MH on the guidance issue.

I am having trouble understanding your comment that " management did leave out that deal price expectations were not realistic."  The pps went up after an enthusiastic CC.  Everything that Hession said was true.  The market responded by a big jump in share price.  What did you want management to do, put out a press release afterwards saying "Whoa, don't get real excited.  The deal isn't THAT good?"  Imagine what the pps would have done then!

There is no question that our friends in France did us NO favors with their premature press release basically giving the lowest case scenario.  By the time IOC management could respond, the horse was out of the barn.  Yes, it SHOULD have been a joint release giving a more realistic presentation of the deal.  The stock probably would still have dropped, but nothing like what happened.  Hopefully, Total and IOC management have had discussions since about how future press releases will be handled.

Reply

#4

'Crippsfl' pid='35025' datel Wrote:

'SamAdams' pid='35024' datel Wrote:

The stock fell because the company delivered a deal well below expectations.  That doesn't mean it isn't a good long term deal, but it was not in-line with expecations.  And the stock had just run from the high $60s to low $90s on a bullish cc.  Hoever, management did leave out that deal price expectations were not realistic.  And they knew that.  :Market was thinking XOM at well above $ per mcf and perhaps a 10% stake in PNG LNG  ro soome variation of that.  What we know is XOM was not even close to TOT offer.  The rest is noise or excuses.  If expectations had been reset when stock was in $60s, perhaps the stock would have risen post deal.  It's all about expectations and the current managment did not manage those properly.  They knew the XOM deal from May was not a good one and they dealt with that, but they never adressed the $ per mcf issue that, rightly or wrongly, ;many focused on.  I imagine there were some large shareholders who were not happy with MH on the guidance issue.

I am having trouble understanding your comment that " management did leave out that deal price expectations were not realistic."  The pps went up after an enthusiastic CC.  Everything that Hession said was true.  The market responded by a big jump in share price.  What did you want management to do, put out a press release afterwards saying "Whoa, don't get real excited.  The deal isn't THAT good?"  Imagine what the pps would have done then!

There is no question that our friends in France did us NO favors with their premature press release basically giving the lowest case scenario.  By the time IOC management could respond, the horse was out of the barn.  Yes, it SHOULD have been a joint release giving a more realistic presentation of the deal.  The stock probably would still have dropped, but nothing like what happened.  Hopefully, Total and IOC management have had discussions since about how future press releases will be handled.

***********
I believe it was two things. 

First, there was an assumption that there would be a direct correlation between the deal dollars and the post deal stock price.  I am not sure that was a reasonable assumption.  "NAV" doesn't always correlate to pps...especially in a scenario where the "assets" aren't locked in as long term balance sheet type assets.  For IOC, a good chunk of the assets recevied in the deal (i.e. the cash) will have to be "used up" by the cost of expensive wells in various places, our share of the new plant costs, etc.

Secondly, and more significant I believe, is the contingent (and delayed) structure of the deal money.  It would have been a lot different if our partner would have simply paid $6B in cash for all of the PRL.  In that scenarion we wouldn't have had any equity in the new plant, but we would have known for sure that the $6B was ours.  Now we have several future events that need to turn out favorably in order to get more than the initial $613M.  We can all assume the testing will go well...or that a plant will eventually be built...but there is no current certainty.  

It is possible that no entity was willing to make an offer along those lines...and it is possible that this deal will end up being much better anyway...but I think the market wanted certainty and finality in order to reward the pps.  There is a lot more "wait and see" now...and the market is tired of that with this company.     

Reply

#5

'CAC' pid='35030' datel Wrote:

'Crippsfl' pid='35025' datel Wrote:

'SamAdams' pid='35024' datel Wrote:

The stock fell because the company delivered a deal well below expectations.  That doesn't mean it isn't a good long term deal, but it was not in-line with expecations.  And the stock had just run from the high $60s to low $90s on a bullish cc.  Hoever, management did leave out that deal price expectations were not realistic.  And they knew that.  :Market was thinking XOM at well above $ per mcf and perhaps a 10% stake in PNG LNG  ro soome variation of that.  What we know is XOM was not even close to TOT offer.  The rest is noise or excuses.  If expectations had been reset when stock was in $60s, perhaps the stock would have risen post deal.  It's all about expectations and the current managment did not manage those properly.  They knew the XOM deal from May was not a good one and they dealt with that, but they never adressed the $ per mcf issue that, rightly or wrongly, ;many focused on.  I imagine there were some large shareholders who were not happy with MH on the guidance issue.

I am having trouble understanding your comment that " management did leave out that deal price expectations were not realistic."  The pps went up after an enthusiastic CC.  Everything that Hession said was true.  The market responded by a big jump in share price.  What did you want management to do, put out a press release afterwards saying "Whoa, don't get real excited.  The deal isn't THAT good?"  Imagine what the pps would have done then!

There is no question that our friends in France did us NO favors with their premature press release basically giving the lowest case scenario.  By the time IOC management could respond, the horse was out of the barn.  Yes, it SHOULD have been a joint release giving a more realistic presentation of the deal.  The stock probably would still have dropped, but nothing like what happened.  Hopefully, Total and IOC management have had discussions since about how future press releases will be handled.

***********
I believe it was two things. 

First, there was an assumption that there would be a direct correlation between the deal dollars and the post deal stock price.  I am not sure that was a reasonable assumption.  "NAV" doesn't always correlate to pps...especially in a scenario where the "assets" aren't locked in as long term balance sheet type assets.  For IOC, a good chunk of the assets recevied in the deal (i.e. the cash) will have to be "used up" by the cost of expensive wells in various places, our share of the new plant costs, etc.

Secondly, and more significant I believe, is the contingent (and delayed) structure of the deal money.  It would have been a lot different if our partner would have simply paid $6B in cash for all of the PRL.  In that scenarion we wouldn't have had any equity in the new plant, but we would have known for sure that the $6B was ours.  Now we have several future events that need to turn out favorably in order to get more than the initial $613M.  We can all assume the testing will go well...or that a plant will eventually be built...but there is no current certainty.  

It is possible that no entity was willing to make an offer along those lines...and it is possible that this deal will end up being much better anyway...but I think the market wanted certainty and finality in order to reward the pps.  There is a lot more "wait and see" now...and the market is tired of that with this company.     

 Sam you said "It would have been a lot different if our partner would have simply paid $6B in cash for all of the PRL.  In that scenarion we wouldn't have had any equity in the new plant, but we would have known for sure that the $6B was ours."  

I do not believe ANYONE was going to give us $6B for the entire PRL without delineation wells being drilled.  But isn't that what we are doing now?  But instead of them getting the entire field they get 61.5% and we still own the rest.  If the delineation wells prove out, we could get the $6B anyway plus the 30% LNG partenership and income down the road.  If the additional exporation well at "Deep Antelope" shows that there is continuity, a HUGE bonus could occur.  In addition, Total gets the rights to first refusal on any other discoveries IOC makes.  Nothing like a little competition for resources.

I really believe that is the best overall deal.  Like everyone else, I was hoping for a big bump on the announcement. It didn't happen and I avoided jumping out the window.  I have since crawled in from the ledge.  It is going to take longer than I would have hoped but, I am confident that we will see positives in the near future.

Reply

#6

'Crippsfl' pid='35025' datel Wrote:

'SamAdams' pid='35024' datel Wrote:

The stock fell because the company delivered a deal well below expectations.  That doesn't mean it isn't a good long term deal, but it was not in-line with expecations.  And the stock had just run from the high $60s to low $90s on a bullish cc.  Hoever, management did leave out that deal price expectations were not realistic.  And they knew that.  :Market was thinking XOM at well above $ per mcf and perhaps a 10% stake in PNG LNG  ro soome variation of that.  What we know is XOM was not even close to TOT offer.  The rest is noise or excuses.  If expectations had been reset when stock was in $60s, perhaps the stock would have risen post deal.  It's all about expectations and the current managment did not manage those properly.  They knew the XOM deal from May was not a good one and they dealt with that, but they never adressed the $ per mcf issue that, rightly or wrongly, ;many focused on.  I imagine there were some large shareholders who were not happy with MH on the guidance issue.

I am having trouble understanding your comment that " management did leave out that deal price expectations were not realistic."  The pps went up after an enthusiastic CC.  Everything that Hession said was true.  The market responded by a big jump in share price.  What did you want management to do, put out a press release afterwards saying "Whoa, don't get real excited.  The deal isn't THAT good?"  Imagine what the pps would have done then!

There is no question that our friends in France did us NO favors with their premature press release basically giving the lowest case scenario.  By the time IOC management could respond, the horse was out of the barn.  Yes, it SHOULD have been a joint release giving a more realistic presentation of the deal.  The stock probably would still have dropped, but nothing like what happened.  Hopefully, Total and IOC management have had discussions since about how future press releases will be handled.

As a matter of fact they did have discussions.  It's written into the SPA in section13 as clear as the ink on the PDF.  Clearly they didn't follow their own agreement.  Why is the question.  This is the easy stuff to do in the agreement.

Reply

#7

["I do not believe ANYONE was going to give us $6B for the entire PRL without delineation wells being drilled.  But isn't that what we are doing now?  But instead of them getting the entire field they get 61.5% and we still own the rest.  If the delineation wells prove out, we could get the $6B anyway plus the 30% LNG partenership and income down the road."]

Bingo Crippls

Reply

#8

'Crippsfl' pid='35025' datel Wrote:

'SamAdams' pid='35024' datel Wrote:

The stock fell because the company delivered a deal well below expectations.  That doesn't mean it isn't a good long term deal, but it was not in-line with expecations.  And the stock had just run from the high $60s to low $90s on a bullish cc.  Hoever, management did leave out that deal price expectations were not realistic.  And they knew that.  :Market was thinking XOM at well above $ per mcf and perhaps a 10% stake in PNG LNG  ro soome variation of that.  What we know is XOM was not even close to TOT offer.  The rest is noise or excuses.  If expectations had been reset when stock was in $60s, perhaps the stock would have risen post deal.  It's all about expectations and the current managment did not manage those properly.  They knew the XOM deal from May was not a good one and they dealt with that, but they never adressed the $ per mcf issue that, rightly or wrongly, ;many focused on.  I imagine there were some large shareholders who were not happy with MH on the guidance issue.

I am having trouble understanding your comment that " management did leave out that deal price expectations were not realistic."  The pps went up after an enthusiastic CC.  Everything that Hession said was true.  The market responded by a big jump in share price.  What did you want management to do, put out a press release afterwards saying "Whoa, don't get real excited.  The deal isn't THAT good?"  Imagine what the pps would have done then!

There is no question that our friends in France did us NO favors with their premature press release basically giving the lowest case scenario.  By the time IOC management could respond, the horse was out of the barn.  Yes, it SHOULD have been a joint release giving a more realistic presentation of the deal.  The stock probably would still have dropped, but nothing like what happened.  Hopefully, Total and IOC management have had discussions since about how future press releases will be handled.

OK, so to be crystal clear,current managment knew $1 per mcf was not achievable and the price per mcf was likely to be much lower than that on the  sell down. Yes we had a bullish cc where the TIMING of the deal became more certain.  Sell side analysts were using $1 + in their reports.  Therefore,expectations were not set correctly.  This has nothing to do with the ultimate merits of the long term deal, but what many investors were looking for as indication of the resources and the urgency to buy them.  yes the TOT PR was botched.  But MH was also on a plane to Singapore when he should have been hosting a pre-open cc about the deal.  Lots to point fingers at but I'd focus on the first sentence as the most important one here in the short term.  I also think the lack of urgency to bid the resources up may be just under the surface as well and indicates a hostile deal is probably unlikely.  Just trying to keep it real.

Reply

#9
I would like to point out that IOC is to be paid 1.29$/MCF cash in 18 months +/-.
Reply

#10

'Putncalls' pid='35048' datel Wrote:I would like to point out that IOC is to be paid 1.29$/MCF cash in 18 months +/-.

No, that's only the case for gas/liquids above 6.5Tcfe

Reply



Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: