Thread Rating:
  • 1 Vote(s) - 5 Average
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
Dissent Voters & After the Vote Thoughts
#1

A few parting thoughts as I "wax philosophically."  Definitely feeling like a rudderless ship at this moment.

I guess I'll be continuing to check this MB for commentary on how the process is going forward, in addition to checking elswhere.

I find it interesting that JFT voted No with dissent (more power to you) but 2126, the attorney, who did tremendous amount of research and leg work laying out the whole dissent process, calling legal firms, etc., etc., etc., decided to just vote NO WITHOUT dissent.  I fully respect everyone's choice and am eager to learn how the dissenters work out, it not solely to learn something in case I ever end up with that option again.

Any other dissenters out there?  I admitted previously I voted NO. Legal entanglements are not my cup of tea.   I'd gather there aren't many dissenters.

I wish I could fast forward the drilling and the consultant's evaluation to be wrapped up by next week to get all of this over with and  move on.  The next chapter has started, which should be the final chapter of the "Trials and Tribulations of InterOil".

Is there any bright side to this?  I have a saying when things don't go well, that goes like this - In the midst of my great misfortune I have been very fortunate.  What it means is that bad things and crap happen all the time, but when I stop and reflect, I can always find in the midst of it all, a blessing or more.

The blessings?  Well I'll take a shot at it for the benefit on anyone needing some encouragement.

1.  Getting XOM stock at a good price and dividend and not OSH shares.

2.  Becoming an XOM shareholder again.  Being part of a company with winning, trustworthy management.  XOM management are brilliant and maybe very lucky too.  Kudos to them for making this deal and convincing 80+% of the shareholders and institutions.

3.  Hopefully receiving a CRP.  The CRP will be using Phil's improved well plan and location for Well 7, resulting in increased likelihood of increasing volume.  So I have an improved chance of making a little money.  The prior location had a good chance of being too far west and being completely out of the reservoir.

4.  I got the business/financial/investing education of a lifetime reading all the postings by a broad range of some highly experienced and knowledgeable people as well as observing senior management thieves in action.  I learned that institutional and other large shareholders don't know squat about the value of their investments and should not be trusted.  I doubt I will ever have such an opportunity and experience, especially of such duration, again in my life.  I imagine we all could agree on this one.

5.  There have been some really fine people on this MB, all total faceless, anonymous strangers in cyberspace.  It's been nice entertainment.  Thanks for all your sharing.

6.  When I started this my original investment was much greater.  Along the way I decided to sell down to where I am now.  Had I not done that, my losses would be a good bit greater.  I can live with this.

7.  Lastly, it's only money.  That can be replaced.  It's a minor matter compared to other problems in life.

Keep in touch.  I may be interested in participating in another MB.  As I mentioned in another posting a couple of weeks ago or so, and agreed to by PETE, we need a new gig.  Reportedly the Permian Basin is once again rising from the ashes to become the biggest, best oil field in the USA.  Some key companies are positioned to do well there.  Rather than focusing on a single company, a consideration is to focus on the top players in the Permian.  Just a thought.

As I noted almost 2 years ago when this glut began, and as you have been reading, we are headed to a great oil shortage eventually.  Today's news showed how incompetent government is at forecasing or even measuring existing storage volumes, leading to large price increases today.  The Perfect Storm Oil Crisis is coming (IMHO).  It will be hard to catch up.

Best to all,

Kaliboo

Reply

#2
Per an interview with Phil Mulacek we know he and PIE controlled by Phil voted dissent . I think the number of dissenters is small which helps our chances of a sweetened deal . We will decline all offers that are not superior to the Hession deal . We await their first offer .
Reply

#3

[quote='Kaliboo' pid='76460' dateline='1474517427']

A few parting thoughts as I "wax philosophically."  Definitely feeling like a rudderless ship at this moment.

I guess I'll be continuing to check this MB for commentary on how the process is going forward, in addition to checking elswhere.

I find it interesting that JFT voted No with dissent (more power to you) but 2126, the attorney, who did tremendous amount of research and leg work laying out the whole dissent process, calling legal firms, etc., etc., etc., decided to just vote NO WITHOUT dissent.  I fully respect everyone's choice and am eager to learn how the dissenters work out, it not solely to learn something in case I ever end up with that option again.

Any other dissenters out there?  I admitted previously I voted NO. Legal entanglements are not my cup of tea.   I'd gather there aren't many dissenters.

I wish I could fast forward the drilling and the consultant's evaluation to be wrapped up by next week to get all of this over with and  move on.  The next chapter has started, which should be the final chapter of the "Trials and Tribulations of InterOil".

Is there any bright side to this?  I have a saying when things don't go well, that goes like this - In the midst of my great misfortune I have been very fortunate.  What it means is that bad things and crap happen all the time, but when I stop and reflect, I can always find in the midst of it all, a blessing or more.

The blessings?  Well I'll take a shot at it for the benefit on anyone needing some encouragement.

1.  Getting XOM stock at a good price and dividend and not OSH shares.

2.  Becoming an XOM shareholder again.  Being part of a company with winning, trustworthy management.  XOM management are brilliant and maybe very lucky too.  Kudos to them for making this deal and convincing 80+% of the shareholders and institutions.

3.  Hopefully receiving a CRP.  The CRP will be using Phil's improved well plan and location for Well 7, resulting in increased likelihood of increasing volume.  So I have an improved chance of making a little money.  The prior location had a good chance of being too far west and being completely out of the reservoir.

4.  I got the business/financial/investing education of a lifetime reading all the postings by a broad range of some highly experienced and knowledgeable people as well as observing senior management thieves in action.  I learned that institutional and other large shareholders don't know squat about the value of their investments and should not be trusted.  I doubt I will ever have such an opportunity and experience, especially of such duration, again in my life.  I imagine we all could agree on this one.

5.  There have been some really fine people on this MB, all total faceless, anonymous strangers in cyberspace.  It's been nice entertainment.  Thanks for all your sharing.

6.  When I started this my original investment was much greater.  Along the way I decided to sell down to where I am now.  Had I not done that, my losses would be a good bit greater.  I can live with this.

7.  Lastly, it's only money.  That can be replaced.  It's a minor matter compared to other problems in life.

Keep in touch.  I may be interested in participating in another MB.  As I mentioned in another posting a couple of weeks ago or so, and agreed to by PETE, we need a new gig.  Reportedly the Permian Basin is once again rising from the ashes to become the biggest, best oil field in the USA.  Some key companies are positioned to do well there.  Rather than focusing on a single company, a consideration is to focus on the top players in the Permian.  Just a thought.

As I noted almost 2 years ago when this glut began, and as you have been reading, we are headed to a great oil shortage eventually.  Today's news showed how incompetent government is at forecasing or even measuring existing storage volumes, leading to large price increases today.  The Perfect Storm Oil Crisis is coming (IMHO).  It will be hard to catch up.

Best to all,

Kaliboo

*********

Kaliboo --

I served my Notice of Dissent last week and will be glad to communicate about it with anyone who wants to contact me privately.

For others who are pursuing this avenue, I do not agree with JFT's assertion that this "first step" triggers an obligation for XOM/IOC to make an offer within 10 days.  Under the statute, there is more to it than that.  I also disagreed with his statement last week that there "is no appeal" for XOM as part of this process. Be careful.

Reply

#4

Kaliboo - Thanks for your fine post .All 7 points were very good,imo .....I especially liked 1 ,3 ,and 7 ! ! !  Best to you and your loved ones , sageo

Reply

#5

'CAC' pid='76466' dateline='<a href="tel:1474545 Wrote:

[quote='Kaliboo' pid='76460' dateline='1474517427']

*********

Kaliboo --

I served my Notice of Dissent last week and will be glad to communicate about it with anyone who wants to contact me privately.

For others who are pursuing this avenue, I do not agree with JFT's assertion that this "first step" triggers an obligation for XOM/IOC to make an offer within 10 days.  Under the statute, there is more to it than that.  I also disagreed with his statement last week that there "is no appeal" for XOM as part of this process. Be careful.

Thanks for the generous offer CAC.  I'm sure you will have many who are interested to learn.  Good luck to you, JFT and the others.  I agree with JFT's comment that the offer may be sweeter and faster due to the few number of dissenters.  So XOM may be encouraged to be done and move on quickly.  On the other hand, they may be patting themselves on the back thinking they are invincible and aren't going to make this easy for dissenters by suddenly becoming charitable.  They wouldn't want to encourage future dissenters.  They operate fully lawyered up and have played out these moves many times before, I would presume.

Reply

#6

[quote='CAC' pid='76466' dateline='1474545185']

Kaliboo --

I served my Notice of Dissent last week and will be glad to communicate about it with anyone who wants to contact me privately.

For others who are pursuing this avenue, I do not agree with JFT's assertion that this "first step" triggers an obligation for XOM/IOC to make an offer within 10 days.  Under the statute, there is more to it than that.  I also disagreed with his statement last week that there "is no appeal" for XOM as part of this process. Be careful.

___________________________________________________________________________________________

CAC - You are spot on regarding erroneous information.  Any offer is not automatically a better offer than the existing deal or the market price.  Similarly, there certainly is a right of appeal.

In spite of some blather, on the whole, this is an outstanding message board, yourself included.  Kaliboo's post was certainly heartfelft.  2126 and the engineer were outstanding contributors, and numerous others as well.  Bonjour Tristesse.

 I could be mistaken but I don't think there would be any gag order on either the ongoing dissent procedure itself or any ultimate settlement.    Thanks for your offer to share privately; however, even private communications can be published by the recipient, so if you can say it privately, would it be possible to perhaps post it yourself?  I think all of us would be interested in, and would appreciate, any feedback you can give on this board regarding dissent events.  And from a reliable source.

Reply

#7
What was said was offers not superior would be declined . Exxon can offer what they want.
A deal with a cap is not net asset value
A deal with no value for what's below E/A is not net asset value
A deal with no value for whats's outside E/A is not net asset value
Exxon is paying for both sides of the legal defense and for additional appraisal's. Exxon being prudent should make an offer for us to go away to limit their exposure to these costs ,
There is a small group of dissenters which means Exxon's dollar expenditure in total is limited to not 51 million shares but a much smaller group .
Odds look good . Not for sure .
Reply

#8

Further after each offer and there should be more than 1 offer each dissenter gets to decide to accept or reject . Or their most likely will be different prices paid to different dissenters based on their acceptance or rejection election .

In the Exxon Valdez case Exxon was only paying their costs and the delay over paying the fine for 17 years was prudent . In this. Case Exxon is paying both sides legal costs plus court expenses . Apples and Oranges comparison . If Exxon appeals they pay both sides of the appeal . Why spend that money if Exxon ???

Reply

#9

[quote='jft310' pid='76473' dateline='1474557225']

Further after each offer and there should be more than 1 offer each dissenter gets to decide to accept or reject . Or their most likely will be different prices paid to different dissenters based on their acceptance or rejection election .

In the Exxon Valdez case Exxon was only paying their costs and the delay over paying the fine for 17 years was prudent . In this. Case Exxon is paying both sides legal costs plus court expenses . Apples and Oranges comparison . If Exxon appeals they pay both sides of the appeal . Why spend that money if Exxon ???

__________________________________

There is only ONE mandatory offer.  After that, it's at Exxon's option.

You have to know how many shares are dissenting before you can dismiss settlement costs versus court costs.  You claim to know PM is dissenting.   If there are him plus some more, say a total of 10% dissenting, that's 5 million shares.  An acceptable offer is say $60 (you don't get the CVR), then the settlement cost is $75 million.  You can pay a lot of court costs for that.  And if you don't have representation, as you claim, then there aren't really "both" sides.

Reply



Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: