Posts: 857
Threads: 139
Joined: Aug 2013
Reputation:
197
http://www.gov.yk.ca/legislation/acts/buco_c.pdf
I've been looking at the above document to try and better understand this dissent process. (I'm not a lawyer)
Since the IOC BOD have unanimously agreed that the new offer by XOM is "fair", then they are not going to contradict themselves (I don't think) by generating a separate "fair" deal for the dissenting shareholders as required by the YBCA, because it would have to be a different deal. However, it maybe that IOC might simply make an all cash offer equivalent to the new XOM offer of $45 + at most using the new GLJ volume estimate which translates to $45 + $11.31 = 56.31. In this case some or alot of dissenters would reject this. IOC already has made the case that a big attraction of the deal is getting XOM shares all the benefits therein as XOM shareholders and continuing to thereby share in E/A profits. Less likely, IOC might just average the 3 numbers as PET did in another posting arriving at $45 + $4.95 = $49.95. The all cash offers eliminate all uncertainty on the CRP but also eliminate "sharing" as an XOM shareholder. So there are some possibilities low to high, of what IOC might offer to make us go away.
But if there is a large number of dissenter votes and shareholders, I'm guessing that the court will instead dictate how this "fair deal for dissenters" is going to be done, as asis allowed by the YBCA. Based on the appeal court response and reaction to Phil's arguments and expert witnesses, I suspect the lower court will heavily rely on his input to decide the process and group all dissenters into one group. So there it may be a battle between Phil's lawyers and expert witnesses and IOC's lawyers and witnesses to define the method. In this case I think Phil has the upper hand because of his own expertise and witnesses (better than MH) AND because the Canadian courts seem to have a leaning towards accomodating shareholders rather than corporations, as I've gleaned from reading a past case regarding dissenting rights.
But a big part of Phil's testimony has been based on the outcome of A7 which we believe is a duster and was not deepened to hunt for a deeper zone. We have yet to be told the full story formally, but that will/should all come out by mid January.
In any case I will need to read back through Phil's arguments again, because I think it all depends on this final epic court battle. What better way to end the novel of the "trials and tribulations of IOC."
Also my initial reading of the Act indicates that the value of the company is to be determined as of the "close of business on the last business day before the day on which the resolution from which the shareholder dissents was adopted." (see excerpt below) To me this means the date of the shareholder meeting ~mid February 2017 - is the valuation date. In our case I think time is on our side given that OPEC/NoPECers have an agreement to restrain production. Certainly XOM shares are moving upward as other oil companies, shouldn't IOC as well? This offer from XOM is no different than before for shareholders and is now several months old, having been first announced publicly on July 21, 2016. In fact you can argue the offer is much worse since the breakup penalty is now much higher, detering any other offers. The CEO and BOD clearly will profit tremendously from this deal and so they are strongly incentivized to lock it in with the big termination penalty. The vote expected in mid February will be nearly 7 months later and XOM has not accounted for market value increase and the anticipated impacts of OPEC/NOPEC cutbacks and higher LNG prices. IMHO this is a very stale, worse offer. I think Phil could make a case that oil and gas prices have bottomed and may be moving higher. In such a market there is no compelling case to sell the company from a shareholder's view point. Only IOC management and BOD does well on this deal. Shareholders are cheated.
Shareholder's right to dissent
193(3) In addition to any other right, but subject to subsection (20), a shareholder entitled to dissent under this section and who complies with this section is entitled to be paid by the corporation the fair value of the shares in respect of which the shareholder dissents, determined as of the close of business on the last business day before the day on which the resolution from which the shareholder dissents was adopted.
For dissenters we need to help Phil build our case, if he needs any.
Posts: 1,670
Threads: 49
Joined: Jan 2012
Reputation:
91
'Kaliboo' pid='78730' datel Wrote:
http://www.gov.yk.ca/legislation/acts/buco_c.pdf
I've been looking at the above document to try and better understand this dissent process. (I'm not a lawyer)
Since the IOC BOD have unanimously agreed that the new offer by XOM is "fair", then they are not going to contradict themselves (I don't think) by generating a separate "fair" deal for the dissenting shareholders as required by the YBCA, because it would have to be a different deal. However, it maybe that IOC might simply make an all cash offer equivalent to the new XOM offer of $45 + at most using the new GLJ volume estimate which translates to $45 + $11.31 = 56.31. In this case some or alot of dissenters would reject this. IOC already has made the case that a big attraction of the deal is getting XOM shares all the benefits therein as XOM shareholders and continuing to thereby share in E/A profits. Less likely, IOC might just average the 3 numbers as PET did in another posting arriving at $45 + $4.95 = $49.95. The all cash offers eliminate all uncertainty on the CRP but also eliminate "sharing" as an XOM shareholder. So there are some possibilities low to high, of what IOC might offer to make us go away.
But if there is a large number of dissenter votes and shareholders, I'm guessing that the court will instead dictate how this "fair deal for dissenters" is going to be done, as asis allowed by the YBCA. Based on the appeal court response and reaction to Phil's arguments and expert witnesses, I suspect the lower court will heavily rely on his input to decide the process and group all dissenters into one group. So there it may be a battle between Phil's lawyers and expert witnesses and IOC's lawyers and witnesses to define the method. In this case I think Phil has the upper hand because of his own expertise and witnesses (better than MH) AND because the Canadian courts seem to have a leaning towards accomodating shareholders rather than corporations, as I've gleaned from reading a past case regarding dissenting rights.
But a big part of Phil's testimony has been based on the outcome of A7 which we believe is a duster and was not deepened to hunt for a deeper zone. We have yet to be told the full story formally, but that will/should all come out by mid January.
In any case I will need to read back through Phil's arguments again, because I think it all depends on this final epic court battle. What better way to end the novel of the "trials and tribulations of IOC."
Also my initial reading of the Act indicates that the value of the company is to be determined as of the "close of business on the last business day before the day on which the resolution from which the shareholder dissents was adopted." (see excerpt below) To me this means the date of the shareholder meeting ~mid February 2017 - is the valuation date. In our case I think time is on our side given that OPEC/NoPECers have an agreement to restrain production. Certainly XOM shares are moving upward as other oil companies, shouldn't IOC as well? This offer from XOM is no different than before for shareholders and is now several months old, having been first announced publicly on July 21, 2016. In fact you can argue the offer is much worse since the breakup penalty is now much higher, detering any other offers. The CEO and BOD clearly will profit tremendously from this deal and so they are strongly incentivized to lock it in with the big termination penalty. The vote expected in mid February will be nearly 7 months later and XOM has not accounted for market value increase and the anticipated impacts of OPEC/NOPEC cutbacks and higher LNG prices. IMHO this is a very stale, worse offer. I think Phil could make a case that oil and gas prices have bottomed and may be moving higher. In such a market there is no compelling case to sell the company from a shareholder's view point. Only IOC management and BOD does well on this deal. Shareholders are cheated.
Shareholder's right to dissent
193(3) In addition to any other right, but subject to subsection (20), a shareholder entitled to dissent under this section and who complies with this section is entitled to be paid by the corporation the fair value of the shares in respect of which the shareholder dissents, determined as of the close of business on the last business day before the day on which the resolution from which the shareholder dissents was adopted.
For dissenters we need to help Phil build our case, if he needs any.
Thank you Kaliboo ! Always appreciate your thoughts and ALL of your help in trying to stop this theft by mh and his " band of thieves" . Bless you " border="0" class="smilie" src="http://shareholdersunite.com/mybb/images/smilies/wink.gif" />
Posts: 440
Threads: 58
Joined: Aug 2013
Reputation:
198
'Kaliboo' pid='78730' datel Wrote:
http://www.gov.yk.ca/legislation/acts/buco_c.pdf
I've been looking at the above document to try and better understand this dissent process. (I'm not a lawyer)
Since the IOC BOD have unanimously agreed that the new offer by XOM is "fair", then they are not going to contradict themselves (I don't think) by generating a separate "fair" deal for the dissenting shareholders as required by the YBCA, because it would have to be a different deal. However, it maybe that IOC might simply make an all cash offer equivalent to the new XOM offer of $45 + at most using the new GLJ volume estimate which translates to $45 + $11.31 = 56.31. In this case some or alot of dissenters would reject this. IOC already has made the case that a big attraction of the deal is getting XOM shares all the benefits therein as XOM shareholders and continuing to thereby share in E/A profits. Less likely, IOC might just average the 3 numbers as PET did in another posting arriving at $45 + $4.95 = $49.95. The all cash offers eliminate all uncertainty on the CRP but also eliminate "sharing" as an XOM shareholder. So there are some possibilities low to high, of what IOC might offer to make us go away.
But if there is a large number of dissenter votes and shareholders, I'm guessing that the court will instead dictate how this "fair deal for dissenters" is going to be done, as asis allowed by the YBCA. Based on the appeal court response and reaction to Phil's arguments and expert witnesses, I suspect the lower court will heavily rely on his input to decide the process and group all dissenters into one group. So there it may be a battle between Phil's lawyers and expert witnesses and IOC's lawyers and witnesses to define the method. In this case I think Phil has the upper hand because of his own expertise and witnesses (better than MH) AND because the Canadian courts seem to have a leaning towards accomodating shareholders rather than corporations, as I've gleaned from reading a past case regarding dissenting rights.
But a big part of Phil's testimony has been based on the outcome of A7 which we believe is a duster and was not deepened to hunt for a deeper zone. We have yet to be told the full story formally, but that will/should all come out by mid January.
In any case I will need to read back through Phil's arguments again, because I think it all depends on this final epic court battle. What better way to end the novel of the "trials and tribulations of IOC."
Also my initial reading of the Act indicates that the value of the company is to be determined as of the "close of business on the last business day before the day on which the resolution from which the shareholder dissents was adopted." (see excerpt below) To me this means the date of the shareholder meeting ~mid February 2017 - is the valuation date. In our case I think time is on our side given that OPEC/NoPECers have an agreement to restrain production. Certainly XOM shares are moving upward as other oil companies, shouldn't IOC as well? This offer from XOM is no different than before for shareholders and is now several months old, having been first announced publicly on July 21, 2016. In fact you can argue the offer is much worse since the breakup penalty is now much higher, detering any other offers. The CEO and BOD clearly will profit tremendously from this deal and so they are strongly incentivized to lock it in with the big termination penalty. The vote expected in mid February will be nearly 7 months later and XOM has not accounted for market value increase and the anticipated impacts of OPEC/NOPEC cutbacks and higher LNG prices. IMHO this is a very stale, worse offer. I think Phil could make a case that oil and gas prices have bottomed and may be moving higher. In such a market there is no compelling case to sell the company from a shareholder's view point. Only IOC management and BOD does well on this deal. Shareholders are cheated.
Shareholder's right to dissent
193(3) In addition to any other right, but subject to subsection (20), a shareholder entitled to dissent under this section and who complies with this section is entitled to be paid by the corporation the fair value of the shares in respect of which the shareholder dissents, determined as of the close of business on the last business day before the day on which the resolution from which the shareholder dissents was adopted.
For dissenters we need to help Phil build our case, if he needs any.
Kaliboo: You are correct that the Yukon Statute designates the "close of business on the last business day before the day on which the resolution from which the shareholder dissents was adopted" as the date for the valuation of the assets of IOC. However, I believe that you may not be interpreting this quite correctly.
Legally, a 'dissent' is a shareholder dissent from a BOD resolution which affirmatively sets in motion the sale of all of the stock or all of the assets of a corporation. It is not a dissent from the shareholder vote, but rather a dissent from accepting the BOD resolution approving the sale of the corporation and setting up the shareholder vote procedure.
In our case, this is the IOC BOD shareholder resolution to adopt the Amended and Restated Arrangement Agreement with ExxonMobil on December 15, 2016. Specifically, this new Agreement states: "The Company Board has resolved, upon unanimous recommendation by the Transaction Committee, to recommend that the Company Shareholders vote in favour of the Arrangement." Thus, the BOD passed a 'resolution' recommending that the shareholders vote for the Arrangement. It is from this resolution that IOC shareholders will dissent.
My take on this phrase is that the "day on which the resolution from which the shareholder dissents was adopted" refers to this specific BOD resolution, which took place on December 15th. Thus, the last business day before this date would be December 14, 2016.
So we are looking at a determination of the 'fair value' [NOT market value] of the IOC shares on December 14, 2016.
Posts: 857
Threads: 139
Joined: Aug 2013
Reputation:
197
'2126' pid='78733' datel Wrote:
'Kaliboo' pid='78730' datel Wrote:
http://www.gov.yk.ca/legislation/acts/buco_c.pdf
I've been looking at the above document to try and better understand this dissent process. (I'm not a lawyer)
Since the IOC BOD have unanimously agreed that the new offer by XOM is "fair", then they are not going to contradict themselves (I don't think) by generating a separate "fair" deal for the dissenting shareholders as required by the YBCA, because it would have to be a different deal. However, it maybe that IOC might simply make an all cash offer equivalent to the new XOM offer of $45 + at most using the new GLJ volume estimate which translates to $45 + $11.31 = 56.31. In this case some or alot of dissenters would reject this. IOC already has made the case that a big attraction of the deal is getting XOM shares all the benefits therein as XOM shareholders and continuing to thereby share in E/A profits. Less likely, IOC might just average the 3 numbers as PET did in another posting arriving at $45 + $4.95 = $49.95. The all cash offers eliminate all uncertainty on the CRP but also eliminate "sharing" as an XOM shareholder. So there are some possibilities low to high, of what IOC might offer to make us go away.
But if there is a large number of dissenter votes and shareholders, I'm guessing that the court will instead dictate how this "fair deal for dissenters" is going to be done, as asis allowed by the YBCA. Based on the appeal court response and reaction to Phil's arguments and expert witnesses, I suspect the lower court will heavily rely on his input to decide the process and group all dissenters into one group. So there it may be a battle between Phil's lawyers and expert witnesses and IOC's lawyers and witnesses to define the method. In this case I think Phil has the upper hand because of his own expertise and witnesses (better than MH) AND because the Canadian courts seem to have a leaning towards accomodating shareholders rather than corporations, as I've gleaned from reading a past case regarding dissenting rights.
But a big part of Phil's testimony has been based on the outcome of A7 which we believe is a duster and was not deepened to hunt for a deeper zone. We have yet to be told the full story formally, but that will/should all come out by mid January.
In any case I will need to read back through Phil's arguments again, because I think it all depends on this final epic court battle. What better way to end the novel of the "trials and tribulations of IOC."
Also my initial reading of the Act indicates that the value of the company is to be determined as of the "close of business on the last business day before the day on which the resolution from which the shareholder dissents was adopted." (see excerpt below) To me this means the date of the shareholder meeting ~mid February 2017 - is the valuation date. In our case I think time is on our side given that OPEC/NoPECers have an agreement to restrain production. Certainly XOM shares are moving upward as other oil companies, shouldn't IOC as well? This offer from XOM is no different than before for shareholders and is now several months old, having been first announced publicly on July 21, 2016. In fact you can argue the offer is much worse since the breakup penalty is now much higher, detering any other offers. The CEO and BOD clearly will profit tremendously from this deal and so they are strongly incentivized to lock it in with the big termination penalty. The vote expected in mid February will be nearly 7 months later and XOM has not accounted for market value increase and the anticipated impacts of OPEC/NOPEC cutbacks and higher LNG prices. IMHO this is a very stale, worse offer. I think Phil could make a case that oil and gas prices have bottomed and may be moving higher. In such a market there is no compelling case to sell the company from a shareholder's view point. Only IOC management and BOD does well on this deal. Shareholders are cheated.
Shareholder's right to dissent
193(3) In addition to any other right, but subject to subsection (20), a shareholder entitled to dissent under this section and who complies with this section is entitled to be paid by the corporation the fair value of the shares in respect of which the shareholder dissents, determined as of the close of business on the last business day before the day on which the resolution from which the shareholder dissents was adopted.
For dissenters we need to help Phil build our case, if he needs any.
Kaliboo: You are correct that the Yukon Statute designates the "close of business on the last business day before the day on which the resolution from which the shareholder dissents was adopted" as the date for the valuation of the assets of IOC. However, I believe that you may not be interpreting this quite correctly.
Legally, a 'dissent' is a shareholder dissent from a BOD resolution which affirmatively sets in motion the sale of all of the stock or all of the assets of a corporation. It is not a dissent from the shareholder vote, but rather a dissent from accepting the BOD resolution approving the sale of the corporation and setting up the shareholder vote procedure.
In our case, this is the IOC BOD shareholder resolution to adopt the Amended and Restated Arrangement Agreement with ExxonMobil on December 15, 2016. Specifically, this new Agreement states: "The Company Board has resolved, upon unanimous recommendation by the Transaction Committee, to recommend that the Company Shareholders vote in favour of the Arrangement." Thus, the BOD passed a 'resolution' recommending that the shareholders vote for the Arrangement. It is from this resolution that IOC shareholders will dissent.
My take on this phrase is that the "day on which the resolution from which the shareholder dissents was adopted" refers to this specific BOD resolution, which took place on December 15th. Thus, the last business day before this date would be December 14, 2016.
So we are looking at a determination of the 'fair value' [NOT market value] of the IOC shares on December 14, 2016.
Thank you 2126 for correcting this. So you say it's mid December rather than mid February, which after re-reading it sounds right, but it is still a rather stale deal given the deal is not much different since the 1st resolution in July. In any case any court appointed evaluator evaluating the company beginning some time AFTER the vote in mid February, it would seem, cannot completely divorce from their minds the trends of what direction the energy markets are now headed, including the OPEC and NOPEC deals which all announced before Dec 14. I guess they have to put the valuation date for dissenters close to that of those who accept the deal to be equitable.
Posts: 8,568
Threads: 1,342
Joined: Dec 2011
Reputation:
380
In the Dell dissent brought by Carl Icahn in the US it took 2 years for the courts to reach NAV and pay the additional dollars to him , The Yukon Courts seem to be quicker than the US courts .
T R Price was sued by their mutual fund owners for not dissenting and lost. They paid out $200 million to their mutual fund holders for failure to dissent . Some people better be careful .
Posts: 857
Threads: 139
Joined: Aug 2013
Reputation:
197
I said previously on this MB that I was going to contact my broker Fidelity in regards to the procedure to vote No with Dissent. Well I did that today. Here's what they said.
My shares are held in a 401K brokerage account. The shares are not registered in my name but are held by the Trust that authorizes the 401K or in street name. I wasn't clear on which but it doesn't matter. There was a question by Fidelity whether my employer will allow a No vote with dissent. So they researched that and called me back later today to say there is no problem in my case. Since the MIC has not been delivered, Fidelity was unable to provide any more info for me. They did confirm that the Reorganization group will handle this (exactly as JFT said in another post). So no hiccups so far. They did mention that the record date is January 10 for those who choose to transfer ownership to their name instead of street name. That doesn't apply in my case.
So not much to share so far. I'll be calling them again after I and they receive the MIC to ensure they are working on understanding it. I've already alerted them to the fact that IOC is registered in the Yukon.
So if your broker is Fidelity, you can tell them to expect multiple requests like this.
Best regards,
Kaliboo
Posts: 8,568
Threads: 1,342
Joined: Dec 2011
Reputation:
380
We successfully dissented last time with Fidelity and Charles Schwab by calling our broker . I know for a fact several large holders successfully dissented at RJ by calling their broker . I have copies date stamped by IOC lawyers verifying receipt of our compliant letters . Fidelity delivered letters retirement and non retirement accounts on our behalf and we received letters from Charles Schwab which we delivered to their office . It works , "Just Do It ".
Posts: 857
Threads: 139
Joined: Aug 2013
Reputation:
197
'jft310' pid='78884' dateline='<a href="tel:1483712 Wrote:We successfully dissented last time with Fidelity and Charles Schwab by calling our broker . I know for a fact several large holders successfully dissented at RJ by calling their broker . I have copies date stamped by IOC lawyers verifying receipt of our compliant letters . Fidelity delivered letters retirement and non retirement accounts on our behalf and we received letters from Charles Schwab which we delivered to their office . It works , "Just Do It ". . Thanks JFT.
Posts: 16
Threads: 1
Joined: Oct 2013
Reputation:
2
I just spoke with TDAMERITRADE reorganization depth on this. My shares are in regular, Ira, and rollover accounts, and are held in street name. They said the shares must be segregated at the DTC and there is a $400 charge per account for this. The shares are then in my name and no longer in an IRA, and because of this they have to report this as a taxable withdrawl. It also sounds like the process may take several weeks. Once the shares are in my name, I have to do the rest of the dissent process myself.. They sounded very surprised that fidelity and schwab don't charge the $400 fee as this is a DTC requirement. Does anyone know more detail on fidelity and Schwab process? Much more here than just tell them to dissemination t on my behalf.
Posts: 857
Threads: 139
Joined: Aug 2013
Reputation:
197
'bpjensen' pid='78888' dateline='<a href="tel:1483720 Wrote:
I just spoke with TDAMERITRADE reorganization depth on this. My shares are in regular, Ira, and rollover accounts, and are held in street name. They said the shares must be segregated at the DTC and there is a $400 charge per account for this. The shares are then in my name and no longer in an IRA, and because of this they have to report this as a taxable withdrawl. It also sounds like the process may take several weeks. Once the shares are in my name, I have to do the rest of the dissent process myself.. They sounded very surprised that fidelity and schwab don't charge the $400 fee as this is a DTC requirement. Does anyone know more detail on fidelity and Schwab process? Much more here than just tell them to dissemination t on my behalf.
Why don't you just leave all shares in the accounts they are in and get TDA to register your dissent for you as Fidelity is doing. Better yet, transfer all your accounts to Fidelity immediately if you can do it in time. JFT says he had no problems with them previosuly.
|