Thread Rating:
  • 2 Vote(s) - 3 Average
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
XOM & OSH creative math
#1

Yesterday, OSH made the newspapers in Australia:

http://www.theaustralian.com.au/business...5c3ddd756c

In Paragraph 7, the article states "At spot Asian LNG prices, 2 trillion cubic feet of gas is worth about $US14bn if it is extracted and processed into LNG. Muruk is just 40km northwest of the Hides gas field, meaning its gas can easily be sent to the LNG plant near Port Moresby through the existing pipeline."

So, lets understand this:
1) If Muruk-1 has 2 Tcf then they will value it at $14Bn, but Elk/Antelope which they agree has 6Tcf plus (All estimates put the number north of 6Tcf) is only worth $2.5Bn?

2) They claim only needing a 40Km pipeline, and Elk/Ant only needs a 70Km pipeline: Is 30Km of pipeline worth the $40Bn difference?

The one thing that seems to be clear with this is that the shareholders on IOC are being sold up the river, as both OSH and XOM fully acknowledge that gas in PNG is worth far more than the IOC BOD are selling it for.

Lets be clear here, I am not against XOM making a profit. Far from it, all businesses exist to make a profit, except is seems, for InterOil. (Why is that? Perhaps the shareholders can demand to see a copy of the business plan to be sure that we have invested in a for-profit company, and not a non-profit of some kind?)

No, I fully understand that XOM needs to make a profit, and I support them in that endeavour. I just want the deal to be fair for the current owners of InterOil. I wish our BOD and Management were more like those of XOM.

Reply

#2

"I wish our BOD and Management were more like those of XOM."

Yeah… Prudent is not a word that describes IOC management.

for our cause
Reply

#3

'thg' pid='78761' dateline='<a href="tel:1483144 Wrote:

Yesterday, OSH made the newspapers in Australia:

http://www.theaustralian.com.au/business...5c3ddd756c

In Paragraph 7, the article states "At spot Asian LNG prices, 2 trillion cubic feet of gas is worth about $US14bn if it is extracted and processed into LNG. Muruk is just 40km northwest of the Hides gas field, meaning its gas can easily be sent to the LNG plant near Port Moresby through the existing pipeline."

So, lets understand this:
1) If Muruk-1 has 2 Tcf then they will value it at $14Bn, but Elk/Antelope which they agree has 6Tcf plus (All estimates put the number north of 6Tcf) is only worth $2.5Bn?

2) They claim only needing a 40Km pipeline, and Elk/Ant only needs a 70Km pipeline: Is 30Km of pipeline worth the $40Bn difference?

The one thing that seems to be clear with this is that the shareholders on IOC are being sold up the river, as both OSH and XOM fully acknowledge that gas in PNG is worth far more than the IOC BOD are selling it for.

Lets be clear here, I am not against XOM making a profit. Far from it, all businesses exist to make a profit, except is seems, for InterOil. (Why is that? Perhaps the shareholders can demand to see a copy of the business plan to be sure that we have invested in a for-profit company, and not a non-profit of some kind?)

No, I fully understand that XOM needs to make a profit, and I support them in that endeavour. I just want the deal to be fair for the current owners of InterOil. I wish our BOD and Management were more like those of XOM.

In my part of the world we call that being "sold down the river," the worst possible fate for a slave.

Reply

#4
I hope that press release by OSH is widely disseminated to IOC shareholders. It gives a strong independent assessment of the value of IOC's assets, especially its interest in Papua LNG.
Reply

#5

The entire text of the newspaper piece is here:

Oil Search and Santos have discovered $US14 billion ($19.4bn) of gas in the Papua New Guinea highlands in a find that could underpin a fifth liquefied natural gas production train at the recently started PNG LNG plant and has excited their giant partner ExxonMobil.

The discovery, called Muruk, comes little more than a month after Santos bought into the prospect for an undisclosed amount, making it a welcome piece of good news for managing director Kevin Gallagher as he tries to return investor appeal to the embattled Adelaide oil and gas producer.

Oil Search and Santos, partners with Exxon in PNG LNG, both made relatively staid announcements about the Muruk discovery, which is now thought to hold about 2 trillion cubic feet of gas and is understood to have been viewed internally as having a one-in-five chance of success.

But Exxon, which is trying to secure more gas for PNG LNG through a $4bn takeover of New York-listed InterOil, was uncharacteristically vocal, telling the New York Stock Exchange it had made a new gas discovery.

“We are excited by the results of the Muruk-1 exploration well, which confirms the presence of hydrocarbons in the same high-quality sandstone reservoirs as the Hides field that underpins the PNG LNG project,” said Steve Greenlee, Exxon’s Houston-based head of global exploration.

“Over the coming months we will work with our co-venturers to better determine the full resource potential.”

At spot Asian LNG prices, 2 trillion cubic feet of gas is worth about $US14bn if it is extracted and processed into LNG. Muruk is just 40km northwest of the Hides gas field, meaning its gas can easily be sent to the LNG plant near Port Moresby through the existing pipeline.

The Muruk discovery adds to the complex LNG situation developing in PNG, where Exxon is trying to expand the PNG LNG plant by acquiring InterOil and its stake in the onshore Elk/Antelope field, in which Oil Search and French major Total are also partners.

There is also a global glut of LNG that has been driving down spot prices as $200bn of Australasian LNG projects approved during the recent boom ramp-up.

But demand is expected again to be ahead of supply by about 2023 and PNG’s onshore gas fields provide lower development costs and higher returns than other projects, meaning new projects are expected to be approved, unlike in Australia.

The uncharacteristic excitement from Exxon, relative to its smaller Australian partners, is probably a message to both InterOil shareholders and Total that the supermajor has other expansion options if its takeover is blocked or Total wavers from its intention to develop Elk/Antelope through PNG LNG.

For Santos, which does not have a stake in Elk/Antelope, the find makes it more likely the company will participate as more than just an infrastructure owner in one of the lowest-cost and best-run LNG projects to come out of the recent Australasian investment boom.

Oil Search managing director Peter Botten said the Muluk well results had been in line with pre-drill hopes. “Log data acquisition over the reservoir interval has been largely completed, with the preliminary interpretation of this data indicating that the reservoir contains gas condensate,” he said.

Condensate is light crude oil found in gas that substantially increases its value.

Santos agreed to farm in to Muruk, which had previously been held in a 50-50 joint venture between Oil Search and Exxon, on November 17.

Exxon now holds 42.5 per cent and Oil Search, the operator, holds 37.5 per cent.

Earlier this month, Santos exploration chief Bill Ovenden said the entry into the field was about aligning early in the development phase with the company’s PNG LNG partners.

“It’s also a story about a really high quality and promising looking prospect,” he said.

The latest find makes it more likely that three new trains will be pursued by Exxon and its partners in PNG, on top of the two trains in the foundation PNG LNG project. It takes about 4 to 4.5 trillion cubic feet of gas to underpin the LNG trains at Port Moresby, which each have a nameplate capacity of 3.5 million tonnes of LNG a year.

Oil Search has said that Elk/Antelope and the P’nyang discovery about 120km west of Hides hold a combined 10 trillion cubic feet of gas.

Muruk looks set to bring the spare gas to 12 trillion cubic feet or more, meaning three expansion trains are now probably able to be considered, especially if some smaller nearby fields are brought into the development. If a deal to develop Elk/Antelope through the existing plant cannot be reached, Muruk could be combined with P’nyang, which is owned by Exxon, Oil Search and Nippon, to underpin a third train.

Exxon’s InterOil bid has been sent to a second InterOil shareholder vote after a Yukon appeals court overturned approval of the takeover on an appeal by the target’s founder and significant shareholder Phil Mulacek. The vote is scheduled for the middle of February.

Note: © for this is the Australian, but there is a pay-per-view thing that gets in the way.

Reply

#6
Geez if you were a judge in the Yukon Courts who must approve this deal and large group of shareholders objected because of poor valuations would this get your approval ?!
Yes in Canada the Courts get the last say . At least one court thinks this deal "substanially under values the assets "
Reply

#7

'oliver.gump' pid='78871' datel Wrote:

The entire text of the newspaper piece is here:

Oil Search and Santos have discovered $US14 billion ($19.4bn) of gas in the Papua New Guinea highlands in a find that could underpin a fifth liquefied natural gas production train at the recently started PNG LNG plant and has excited their giant partner ExxonMobil.

The discovery, called Muruk, comes little more than a month after Santos bought into the prospect for an undisclosed amount, making it a welcome piece of good news for managing director Kevin Gallagher as he tries to return investor appeal to the embattled Adelaide oil and gas producer.

Oil Search and Santos, partners with Exxon in PNG LNG, both made relatively staid announcements about the Muruk discovery, which is now thought to hold about 2 trillion cubic feet of gas and is understood to have been viewed internally as having a one-in-five chance of success.

But Exxon, which is trying to secure more gas for PNG LNG through a $4bn takeover of New York-listed InterOil, was uncharacteristically vocal, telling the New York Stock Exchange it had made a new gas discovery.

“We are excited by the results of the Muruk-1 exploration well, which confirms the presence of hydrocarbons in the same high-quality sandstone reservoirs as the Hides field that underpins the PNG LNG project,” said Steve Greenlee, Exxon’s Houston-based head of global exploration.

“Over the coming months we will work with our co-venturers to better determine the full resource potential.”

At spot Asian LNG prices, 2 trillion cubic feet of gas is worth about $US14bn if it is extracted and processed into LNG. Muruk is just 40km northwest of the Hides gas field, meaning its gas can easily be sent to the LNG plant near Port Moresby through the existing pipeline.

The Muruk discovery adds to the complex LNG situation developing in PNG, where Exxon is trying to expand the PNG LNG plant by acquiring InterOil and its stake in the onshore Elk/Antelope field, in which Oil Search and French major Total are also partners.

There is also a global glut of LNG that has been driving down spot prices as $200bn of Australasian LNG projects approved during the recent boom ramp-up.

But demand is expected again to be ahead of supply by about 2023 and PNG’s onshore gas fields provide lower development costs and higher returns than other projects, meaning new projects are expected to be approved, unlike in Australia.

The uncharacteristic excitement from Exxon, relative to its smaller Australian partners, is probably a message to both InterOil shareholders and Total that the supermajor has other expansion options if its takeover is blocked or Total wavers from its intention to develop Elk/Antelope through PNG LNG.

For Santos, which does not have a stake in Elk/Antelope, the find makes it more likely the company will participate as more than just an infrastructure owner in one of the lowest-cost and best-run LNG projects to come out of the recent Australasian investment boom.

Oil Search managing director Peter Botten said the Muluk well results had been in line with pre-drill hopes. “Log data acquisition over the reservoir interval has been largely completed, with the preliminary interpretation of this data indicating that the reservoir contains gas condensate,” he said.

Condensate is light crude oil found in gas that substantially increases its value.

Santos agreed to farm in to Muruk, which had previously been held in a 50-50 joint venture between Oil Search and Exxon, on November 17.

Exxon now holds 42.5 per cent and Oil Search, the operator, holds 37.5 per cent.

Earlier this month, Santos exploration chief Bill Ovenden said the entry into the field was about aligning early in the development phase with the company’s PNG LNG partners.

“It’s also a story about a really high quality and promising looking prospect,” he said.

The latest find makes it more likely that three new trains will be pursued by Exxon and its partners in PNG, on top of the two trains in the foundation PNG LNG project. It takes about 4 to 4.5 trillion cubic feet of gas to underpin the LNG trains at Port Moresby, which each have a nameplate capacity of 3.5 million tonnes of LNG a year.

Oil Search has said that Elk/Antelope and the P’nyang discovery about 120km west of Hides hold a combined 10 trillion cubic feet of gas.

Muruk looks set to bring the spare gas to 12 trillion cubic feet or more, meaning three expansion trains are now probably able to be considered, especially if some smaller nearby fields are brought into the development. If a deal to develop Elk/Antelope through the existing plant cannot be reached, Muruk could be combined with P’nyang, which is owned by Exxon, Oil Search and Nippon, to underpin a third train.

Exxon’s InterOil bid has been sent to a second InterOil shareholder vote after a Yukon appeals court overturned approval of the takeover on an appeal by the target’s founder and significant shareholder Phil Mulacek. The vote is scheduled for the middle of February.

Note: © for this is the Australian, but there is a pay-per-view thing that gets in the way.

So if an undeveloped field that has 2TCFE (Not proved) can be valued at $14Billion, then what is InterOil's 36.5% of E/A worth if it has 8TCFE? *







Tcf Elk / Antelope Value @ US$7/mcf IOC ownership 36.5% XOM Offer/Share Real Value / Share Short Fall / Share Net Realization Percentage
6.0 42,000,000,000 15,345,750,000 45.00 306.00 261 17.24%
6.2 43,400,000,000 15,857,275,000 45.00 316.20 271 16.59%
6.5 45,500,000,000 16,624,562,500 47.12 331.50 284 16.57%
7.0 49,000,000,000 17,903,375,000 50.66 357.00 306 16.54%
7.5 52,500,000,000 19,182,187,500 54.19 382.50 328 16.51%
8.0 56,000,000,000 20,461,000,000 57.73 408.00 350 16.48%
8.5 59,500,000,000 21,739,812,500 61.26 433.50 372 16.46%
9.0 63,000,000,000 23,018,625,000 64.80 459.00 394 16.44%
9.5 66,500,000,000 24,297,437,500 68.33 484.50 416 16.42%
10.0 70,000,000,000 25,576,250,000 71.87 510.00 438 16.40%
10.5 73,500,000,000 26,855,062,500 75.40 535.49 460 16.39%
11.0 77,000,000,000 28,133,875,000 78.94 560.99 482 16.37%
11.5 80,500,000,000 29,412,687,500 78.94 586.49 508 15.55%

Yellow is capped.

And XOM is paying IOC how much? And that payment includes more than the IOS's share of the E/A gas?

This is not a deal, this is robbery.

If we look at the Asian LNG price trend chart

http://shareholdersunite.com/mybb/attach...hp?aid=682

We see that the LNG price is over $7.15 now and trending up, lagging the WTI by 4 months.

RJ just released a report that shows they predict $70 WTI for this year, and the price has been moving up since May 2016.

Yeah, each day that passes makes this deal less fair to the owners.


* Note: this pricing is based on the pure resale price of the, and just as the price used for the valuation of Muruk, it does not take into account the infrastructure costs of connecting the gas to the market.

Reply

#8
A key unknown is "how much much did Santos pay for 20% of Muruk?" That should be a go-by for the true values of Bobcat, Raptor and Triceratops - - - resources the Hession is giving away to XOM for FREE!

I'm hoping that "Concerned InterOil Shareholders" will be able to ferret out that number.
Drivel Maven with Personality
Reply

#9

You guys are a cracker...

The Gas is worth what XOM is willing to Pay.. no more

Most shareholders seem to agree

No other Major has stepped up to the plate. They have had ample opportunity.

Your CEO has misled shareholders with claims of 10TCFE and more....

Your CEO has run this company into the ground, and may soon declare it Bankrupt if costs keep accumulating.

Everyone is ready to move on , and  let this Pig of a stock  Go

Reply

#10

'ioc.aussie' pid='78876' datel Wrote:

You guys are a cracker...

The Gas is worth what XOM is willing to Pay.. no more

Most shareholders seem to agree

No other Major has stepped up to the plate. They have had ample opportunity.

Your CEO has misled shareholders with claims of 10TCFE and more....

Your CEO has run this company into the ground, and may soon declare it Bankrupt if costs keep accumulating.

Everyone is ready to move on , and  let this Pig of a stock  Go

  If not for the Yukon courts I would agree.  Voting No with Dissent will likely get the shareholder a good bit more money.  This is not a "fair market" as XOM has the only means to move gas out of the country and with that investment already in place and operating, no one can compete with them with a better offer, so no one tries - not OSH and not TOT.  They see the futility of it.  Both have gas that they want to get out of the country but they don't have a plant they control.  My hope is the courts will agree that you can't get a "fair deal" in a monopolistic market.  It is a "Pig of a stock" due to current LNG market conditions AND due to rotten management.  Anyone voting just No without dissent on this board might as well move on, as there is nothing else to talk about as long as the deal is likely to pass.  But if you are dissenting, there is much to talk about.  Everyone knows these facts above.  The deal is likely to pass based on the last vote.

Reply



Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)