Thread Rating:
  • 3 Vote(s) - 4 Average
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
Valuing IOC Exploration Assets
#1

I just visited with a fellow retiree, who after his career with a super major, became a professor and then the dean of a major university's petroleum engineering department.  I talked about our situation of not getting sufficient value for IOC's exploration assets.  Here's a paraphrased summary of what he said.

Each of these 40 (correct me if that is the incorect number stated by Hession) drilling prospects IOC says they have has been mapped from seismic and have HC volumes associated with each one.  The calculations involve multiplying a number of probabilities, that you've heard of previously on this message board, to arrive at a probable in-place hydrocarbon volume, using the maps, fault locations and rock volume calculations.  In a given basin, in our case the Eastern Papuan Basin, as drilling success increases, the estimated in-place volumes of these prospects rise, because the probabities are rising.  When you plug higher probabilities into the same models, the numbers get a lot bigger.  Likewise better seismic data, production testing proving connectivity over large distances, etc., all of these increase the probabiites for the in-place volume calculations and the required number of wells needed to develop.  This is the approach a super major uses (as well as any company doing their business right).  To get to the right value of IOC, we need to know the individual valuations of each of these 40 prospects.  A super major would be very excited to know that 2 of 3 exploration wells were discoveries and potentially all 3 had it not been for hole problems leading to premature abandonment of Wahoo.  They would be very excited to know there are 5 discoveries on 6 leases.

When I mentioned that two of the recent single well discoveries has C2 reserves near or over 1 TCFE, his comment was that "proved reserves (essentially equivalent to the C2 number) determined from exploration always increase when appraisal drilling begins."  There you have it from an expert.  My take away.  Bobcat and Raptor will grow significantly in proved reserves.

In summary he said a super major would be real excited to have this kind of success and 40 drilling prospects still to go.

Clearly, the picture on the valuation of these prospects in the MIC is ANYTHING BUT CLEAR.  Have IOC systematically revised all of the estimates for these prospects reflecting best available data?  XOM likely has.

Reply

#2
Hession negotiated zero for our prospects
Zero got Total payments
Zero for an LNG plant contract publicly announced at deal signing .
Way to go Hession
Reply

#3
I'm glad you don't call him "Dr. Hession" - - - he got the "Degree" mail order from what I heard.
Drivel Maven with Personality
Reply

#4

'Kaliboo' pid='79209' datel Wrote:

I just visited with a fellow retiree, who after his career with a super major, became a professor and then the dean of a major university's petroleum engineering department.  I talked about our situation of not getting sufficient value for IOC's exploration assets.  Here's a paraphrased summary of what he said.

Each of these 40 (correct me if that is the incorect number stated by Hession) drilling prospects IOC says they have has been mapped from seismic and have HC volumes associated with each one.  The calculations involve multiplying a number of probabilities, that you've heard of previously on this message board, to arrive at a probable in-place hydrocarbon volume, using the maps, fault locations and rock volume calculations.  In a given basin, in our case the Eastern Papuan Basin, as drilling success increases, the estimated in-place volumes of these prospects rise, because the probabities are rising.  When you plug higher probabilities into the same models, the numbers get a lot bigger.  Likewise better seismic data, production testing proving connectivity over large distances, etc., all of these increase the probabiites for the in-place volume calculations and the required number of wells needed to develop.  This is the approach a super major uses (as well as any company doing their business right).  To get to the right value of IOC, we need to know the individual valuations of each of these 40 prospects.  A super major would be very excited to know that 2 of 3 exploration wells were discoveries and potentially all 3 had it not been for hole problems leading to premature abandonment of Wahoo.  They would be very excited to know there are 5 discoveries on 6 leases.

When I mentioned that two of the recent single well discoveries has C2 reserves near or over 1 TCFE, his comment was that "proved reserves (essentially equivalent to the C2 number) determined from exploration always increase when appraisal drilling begins."  There you have it from an expert.  My take away.  Bobcat and Raptor will grow significantly in proved reserves. 

In summary he said a super major would be real excited to have this kind of success and 40 drilling prospects still to go.

Clearly, the picture on the valuation of these prospects in the MIC is ANYTHING BUT CLEAR.  Have IOC systematically revised all of the estimates for these prospects reflecting best available data?  XOM likely has.

Here's my only response to NorthOil's rejection of the highlighted statement above.  I will clarify what my expert contact is saying as I understood his point.  Exploration wells which may include the initial wellbore and one or more sidetracks of that wellbore are, when successful, the "discovery wells".  The first borehole to find hydrocarbons is the discovery borehole.  The sidetracks and other new wells begin the appraisal process.  The point of the expert, I perhaps poorly summarized, and maybe still don't have it perfectly right, is that once there is a discovery (i.e., one penetration finding hydrocarbons in a previously untested structure) the PROVED RESOURCES OR RESERVES (C2 number in our case) assigned to that prospect always go up.  Why?  Exploration targets have "exploration volumes" assigned to them.  These are gross, unrisked, unproved, undeveloped volumes.  These are always very big numbers because the exploration department is always in the business of selling prospects to management to obtain funding for the exploration program so that everyone stays employed and the company continues to grow and prosper.  They rank the prospects and hopefully get funding to drill a few wells.  But the tendency of all explorationists is eternal hope and optimism and over stating the size.  Once a discovery occurs, then the whittling of the exploration volumes begins, finally arriving at reserves, if any, for that one well.  For that one discovery they assign a range of volumes, as we've seen on Bobcat and Raptor as well as E/A.  The proved risked reserves/resources (C2)  for a single discovery well are going to be dramatically reduced due to the minimum amount of data available and the cost burden that a single well development would have to carry to be commercial.  "Reserves" have to be commercially viable to be "reserves".  C2 resources are a close cousin to proved developed reserves.  So as appraisal BEGINS the proved volumes always increase.  It doesn't mean they continually increase with every new appraisal well.  Common sense tells anyone that.  Look at GLJs numbers on Elk Antelope in the early appraisals.  Volumes grew dramatically.  That's why we have a deal today to vote on.  Eventually, at some point limits are reached and appraisal drilling doesn't add more volume, and like A6, may reduce volume.  Then, as world USGS studies show, when you enter the development phase and begin production, very large fields, on average, grow the reserves even more as production history reveals the true size and recovery efficiency.  Gas fields tend to grow less than oil fields, but on average they grow, large fields more so than smaller fields.  E/A is a world class large field.  But the numbers on some fields shrink after production begins, but the average is net growth.  If you want to read more on that, go to the USGS site and read the papers which studied fields all over the globe with special emphasis outside of North America.

So in my view based on my expert's statements, the C2 reserves for Bobcat and Raptor are likely to grow with further appraisal and if the fields are large and get larger, they may also grow even larger in terms of their total reserves, once production history is avaiable for a few years.  This is Phil's point on E/A.  However, I don't know how many sidetracks (appraisal) were drilled from those original boreholes which were the discovery holes.  I think I recall maybe a couple.  But IOC did not elaborate as to what each one found and how each individually may have affected the C2 numbers.  That's another matter.

With the 40 prospects if more large fields are discovered, then they will get larger in the initial appraisal phase (after the 1st discovery penetration) in terms of C2 numbers, if any are assigned, AND once developed, on average the reserves will grow some more.  That's what USGS world statistical studies conclude.

With this note, I'm probably done on offering much more comment unless Phil puts something out or A7 results are reported, or some other surprise surfaces.  As a recent oil and gas retiree (14 month now) this engagement has provided a nice transition for me.  Thanks to all for making this interesting and challenging.  It's caused me to think in ways and about finanical and technical matters in ways I would have never done otherwise.  However, I surely don't want to spend the rest of my life this focused on one thing to this degree.   I've been thinking for the last 2+ years now that the IOC story is almost over, but it keeps on going and going and going.  To some degree we all keep getting "dragged back in again."  Decision day is rapidly approaching.  As Kenny Rogers sang, "you got know when to hold 'em, know when to fold 'em.........

I think my chief mistake has been counting my imagined future money "while sitting at the table," when I should have taken a small profit and "run away."  Knowing when to sell and "run away" has been my weakness.  Researchers of which I am half, are like being an explorationist......overly optimistic.  Good luck to all.

Kaliboo

Reply

#5

'Kaliboo' pid='79209' datel Wrote:

I just visited with a fellow retiree, who after his career with a super major, became a professor and then the dean of a major university's petroleum engineering department.  I talked about our situation of not getting sufficient value for IOC's exploration assets.  Here's a paraphrased summary of what he said.

Each of these 40 (correct me if that is the incorect number stated by Hession) drilling prospects IOC says they have has been mapped from seismic and have HC volumes associated with each one.  The calculations involve multiplying a number of probabilities, that you've heard of previously on this message board, to arrive at a probable in-place hydrocarbon volume, using the maps, fault locations and rock volume calculations.  In a given basin, in our case the Eastern Papuan Basin, as drilling success increases, the estimated in-place volumes of these prospects rise, because the probabities are rising.  When you plug higher probabilities into the same models, the numbers get a lot bigger.  Likewise better seismic data, production testing proving connectivity over large distances, etc., all of these increase the probabiites for the in-place volume calculations and the required number of wells needed to develop.  This is the approach a super major uses (as well as any company doing their business right).  To get to the right value of IOC, we need to know the individual valuations of each of these 40 prospects.  A super major would be very excited to know that 2 of 3 exploration wells were discoveries and potentially all 3 had it not been for hole problems leading to premature abandonment of Wahoo.  They would be very excited to know there are 5 discoveries on 6 leases.

When I mentioned that two of the recent single well discoveries has C2 reserves near or over 1 TCFE, his comment was that "proved reserves (essentially equivalent to the C2 number) determined from exploration always increase when appraisal drilling begins."  There you have it from an expert.  My take away.  Bobcat and Raptor will grow significantly in proved reserves.

In summary he said a super major would be real excited to have this kind of success and 40 drilling prospects still to go.

Clearly, the picture on the valuation of these prospects in the MIC is ANYTHING BUT CLEAR.  Have IOC systematically revised all of the estimates for these prospects reflecting best available data?  XOM likely has.

-

Kaliboo - Imho any geologist ' worth his salt ' would agree with your take=away on Raptor and Bobcat ! (...much more proved reserves) .

Loved your statement,"Xom likely has" !! If anyone doesn"t believe that , then they haven't been observing XOM for the past 43 to 44 years.

Lee Raymond, the CEO befoe Rex ,was a genius (...and he surrounded himself with very sharp people ). At this point in time, I believe I can safely say that XOM knows more about our fantastic leases than our criminal ceo or OSH ( or maybe even TOT ). Too bad,I guess,that the courts can't know the "true value" at this time for making decisions . My thanks to you again for all your help .

Reply

#6
The courts know the value determined by Paradigm they know the value determined by BMO.
Seeing holes the zero value for some assets determined by BMO should be obvious to the courts .
Reply

#7

Kaliboo, Sageo, et al:  Do you think we should roll our money and/or stock to OSH?  I'm thinking they will benefit most from all of IOC resources.  Any thoughts?  I'm expecting an accelerated schedule for PNG LNG with more gas and maybe oil finds.

Reply

#8

'will2bgreat' pid='79228' datel Wrote:

Kaliboo, Sageo, et al:  Do you think we should roll our money and/or stock to OSH?  I'm thinking they will benefit most from all of IOC resources.  Any thoughts?  I'm expecting an accelerated schedule for PNG LNG with more gas and maybe oil finds.

Will, I thought about that at one time a while back and looked at OSH's other assets which included all those Middle East properties, among others.  Those made me a little nervous.  OSH trades (OSH.AX) on the Austrailia exchange and on pink sheets (OISHY) in the OTC market in the USA.  Liquidity is poor there at around 200 shares average per day.  I wouldn't touch the OTC shares with a 10 ft pole.  I talked to Fidelity a  while back to see what was involved to acquire, hold, sell  foreign (OSH.AX) shares in my account.  In summary, no problem.  Those trade over a million per day; very liquid.

 With the recent announcement to divest themselves of their Middle East assets, this pretty much makes them a pure PNG play.

I was expecting with the PNG LNG plant ramping up that OSH would skyrocket upward.  And it did in 2014.  The first shipment was May 14, 2014 just as global oil and LNG prices were about to head downward.  OSH peaked during June 2014 around 9.80 Australian$.  Then the oil price collapse began and LNG was also falling steeply.  Around the same time the AUD was near parity with the USD at 0.94 AUD/USD,  but then began a steep decline which is now 0.75 AUD/USD.  So the OSH price per share got double hammered if you happened to own it due to commodity prices falling and due to the fall in the value of the AUD in relation to the USD.  Doing the numbers with a value in June 2014 of 9.80 X .94 = $9.21 USD/share.  Now the shares are worth 7.00 x .754 = $5.28 USD.  That's about a 43% loss in value since June 2014.

So you have to make a triple bet on what currencies will do, what commodity prices will do,  and what OSH will do.  That's a little more complex than I like.  And maybe it is a quad bet, adding what will PNG do.  The current AUD/USD exchange rate is near a 10 year low, so that's a good sign in that it likely won't get too much worse and could perhaps revert to the mean at some point.  As they commented publicly, as soon as IOC is out of the way they expect plans on LNG plant expansion in PNG to accelerate.

So it's possible due to currencies and low LNG prices that OSH.AX may be at a bargain now.  It appears highly likely that production and revenues will be growing in the future at some point.  XOM may use OSH for exploring those 40 IOC prospects they are getting cheap.  A deal would need to be made there.

As far as transparency goes OSH seems to get good grades there with monthly updates on important wells; a big improvement over IOC.  Their production was only up by ~3% in 2016 over 2015.  Maybe that's OK given the downturn in prices.

But it looks like 2017 guideance for total production is in line with 2015 and 2016, i.e., no great gains coming.  So I wouldn't expect much price movement unless commodity prices and/or currency exchange rates move in favorable directions.  Maybe better to wait another year.

In general, I'm not positive on the long term performance of the oil and gas industry due to technology and guys like Elon Musk building the largest battery factory in the world in Nevada (Gigafactories) and plans for others all over the world and Teslas which can go 0-60 mph in 2.5 seconds, not to mention an excess of oil and gas for the foreseeable future and dampening demand.  Musk is changing the way the world views and will use energy.  See this BP outlook.  http://www.bp.com/en/global/corporate/energy-economics/energy-outlook.html   ; Not mentioned is the uptake of self driving electric cars.  I think a transportation transformation is on the way along with Musk's vision of a transformation in the way we generate, store and use energy.  My analogy is Musk is the Steve Jobs of cars and energy transformation, but maybe 5-10X more impactful.  The current oil industry is Digital Equipment Corporation, inventors of the famous VAX computer.  DEC couldn't adapt to the PC world and no longer exists.  Compaq bought them, and they couldn't survive and they were taken over by HP.  We may see something like that in the oil patch in the not too distant future - more and more consolidation.

Remaining small companies in the Permian Basin are being bought up.  If I were going to invest in oil and gas, I'd look at small independent with large lease positions like Pioneer.  They are low cost operators.  I bought several but have since sold them.  Good luck.

Reply

#9

Thank you Kaliboo.  I thought of the currency issue as well and was thinking that would be beneficial to an OSH investment.  One day the world is going to wake up and realize this 18Ts of debt and counting is worth the paper that it is printed on, and not much more.

I was also thinking that OSH would get bought out sometime in the future.

Good luck with your future investments.

Reply

#10
We have ordered a Tesla 3 ,we are around number 200,000 of 375,000 reservations , expect delivery in 2018??
We bought Kina with fun money . Can't see us buying OSH.
Reply



Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)