ShareholdersUnite Forums
Dissenting per YBCA Section 193 - Printable Version

+- ShareholdersUnite Forums (http://shareholdersunite.com/mybb)
+-- Forum: Companies (http://shareholdersunite.com/mybb/forumdisplay.php?fid=1)
+--- Forum: InterOil Forum (http://shareholdersunite.com/mybb/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Dissenting per YBCA Section 193 (/showthread.php?tid=11669)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8


RE: Dissenting per YBCA Section 193 - jft310 - 01-08-2017

Fidelity charged us nothing for retire and non retire accounts . Stock remained in Retire accounts . No taxes . Shares coded N/A for price and share count .
Schwab charged $500 per account . Both retire and non retirement with a code account added reorganization dept. very large position . Crooks !!
E trade charged several friends zero to dissent
RJ charged zero to dissent no taxes paid . No fees.
The person you spoke to at Ameritrade does not understand . You should NOT take shares out of retirement to dissent , I would call back and ask for reorg and if they insist on taking assets out of retirement you should transfer the accounts to someone who knows the rules .
Fidelity would be a good choice


RE: Dissenting per YBCA Section 193 - 2126 - 01-09-2017

I have been in contact with Schwab representatives to get a clear outline of the dissent process for beneficial owners of IOC stock [shareholders who hold their shares in brokerage accounts, which, in turn, hold the shares in the 'street name' of the brokerage]. This category of shareholder will include IOC shares held in IRA, Roth, and other 'trust-type' accounts. Shares held in this manner are not held by the shareholders as 'registered shares' and, thus, the dissent process must proceed through the brokerage itself and through the DTC [Depository Trust Company] which provides clearances/settlements for stock transfers. The process outlined below is what will be followed by most, if not all, other brokerages handling dissent for beneficial shareholders, although the fees may differ. This is a direct quote from the Reorganization Department at Schwab that provides a clear description of the dissent process for 'beneficial owners':

  • "As custodian for our clients positions, Schwab will create a dissent letter for each account.
  • Schwab will then deliver the dissent letters to our custodian DTC for certification.
  • Record date holders who dissent and hold their positions thru our custodian DTC must have these letters completed in this fashion; otherwise their dissents will not be valid.
  • Once Schwab receives the certified letters from DTC copies of the dissent letters will be sent to the individual holders who dissented along with our Schwab dissent follow up letter.
  • Dissent Letters must be delivered to Interoil prior to the shareholders meeting. [NOTE: Schwab does not provide the delivery. IOC shareholders must arrange this themselves]
  • The deadline and delivery information will be provided in the companies upcoming merger prospectus. [Note: The Exxon/IOC Material Information Circular, or MIC]
  • Our custodian DTC will in turn work with the agent for Interoil in creating physical certificates for each client’s dissent.
  • Dissenters will hold physical certificates in order to segregate their holdings from other clients that have not dissented.
  • Segregating their holdings in Interoil insures that the clients position is not processed in any upcoming merger that might be approved by the shareholders.
  • Dissenting shareholders must not vote in favor of the upcoming merger; otherwise this will invalidate their dissent. [Note: shareholders may either abstain or vote NO]
  • Any further dissent action that is required after this is between the client, the clients attorney and the company Interoil. Schwab’s responsibility is only to create and deliver the dissent letters.
  • Our custodian DTC charges $400 per dissent and the Schwab fee is $100.. [Each account will be charged a total of $500 per dissent.]"



RE: Dissenting per YBCA Section 193 - jft310 - 01-09-2017

We used the reorganization dept at Schwab last time . We used an Alan Brody head of the Dept . He charged $500 per account to dissent . With a large number of accounts it was expensive ,
I have a copy of the lettet they gave us and we delivered to Interoil's attorney. Since we went through Schwab last time and paid the fee we notified Schwab we were not going to pay again ,
Our Interoil shares in all accounts are coded reorganization as of now . There is nothing for Schwab to do for us or the DTC,
We plan on delivering a lettet to Interoil's attorney and state we re affirm our dissent with the new dates . We further will notify Schwab in writing again we are again dissenting with out fee .
Should work . The money comes from Exxon/Interoil. What's your opinion 2126 about our position !!!


RE: Dissenting per YBCA Section 193 - 2126 - 01-09-2017

Regarding the above post of mine it should also be noted that the Record Date of January 10, 2017, locks in the IOC shares held in each particular fashion and each particular account, as the 'record date' is the date on which the shares held in the IOC stock 'record' book are fixed.

Thus, if you hold shares in a brokerage account in a 'beneficial' manner [ie. the shares are actually held in the 'street name' of the brokerage] on January 10, then you must follow the above-procedure using your own brokerage and the DTC. As we are only 1 business day from the record date, it is too late to transfer shares out of beneficial ownership and into registered ownership on the IOC books, as settlement dates will be past the 'record' date.

If you already hold shares on your own as a registered [on the IOC books] shareholder, then you are free to prepare and send your own dissent notice to IOC [per the address and deadlines in the forthcoming MIC] and using a attorney if you so choose. JFT and CAC have both proceeded in this manner, I believe.

Once the MIC is available, I will post the address/date deadlines for the delivery of the Dissent Notices [which are the same regardless if you hold the shares as a 'beneficial' or 'registered' shareholder.




RE: Dissenting per YBCA Section 193 - 2126 - 01-09-2017

'jft310' pid='78906' datel Wrote:We used the reorganization dept at Schwab last time . We used an Alan Brody head of the Dept . He charged $500 per account to dissent . With a large number of accounts it was expensive , I have a copy of the lettet they gave us and we delivered to Interoil's attorney. Since we went through Schwab last time and paid the fee we notified Schwab we were not going to pay again , Our Interoil shares in all accounts are coded reorganization as of now . There is nothing for Schwab to do for us or the DTC, We plan on delivering a lettet to Interoil's attorney and state we re affirm our dissent with the new dates . We further will notify Schwab in writing again we are again dissenting with out fee . Should work . The money comes from Exxon/Interoil. What's your opinion 2126 about our position !!!

I am not 100% certain, but I believe that you still need to have DTC certification of your dissent. Check with Schwab for your particular situation, which is a bit unusual. Also, your dissent notice must be tailored to specify that you are dissenting from the new BOD resolution passed on December 15th, 2016 as well as from the original BOD resolution. You are not simply reaffirming your earlier dissent, but you are now dissenting from the new BOD decision to recommend shareholders accept the NEW Exxon/IOC Arrangement [with its minimally changed parameters]. The MIC should provide more info for the wording of a new Dissent Notice, as well as the address and deadlines for dissent.




RE: Dissenting per YBCA Section 193 - bpjensen - 01-09-2017

'2126' pid='78907' datel Wrote:

Regarding the above post of mine it should also be noted that the Record Date of January 10, 2017, locks in the IOC shares held in each particular fashion and each particular account, as the 'record date' is the date on which the shares held in the IOC stock 'record' book are fixed.

Thus, if you hold shares in a brokerage account in a 'beneficial' manner [ie. the shares are actually held in the 'street name' of the brokerage] on January 10, then you must follow the above-procedure using your own brokerage and the DTC. As we are only 1 business day from the record date, it is too late to transfer shares out of beneficial ownership and into registered ownership on the IOC books, as settlement dates will be past the 'record' date.

If you already hold shares on your own as a registered [on the IOC books] shareholder, then you are free to prepare and send your own dissent notice to IOC [per the address and deadlines in the forthcoming MIC] and using a attorney if you so choose. JFT and CAC have both proceeded in this manner, I believe.

Once the MIC is available, I will post the address/date deadlines for the delivery of the Dissent Notices [which are the same regardless if you hold the shares as a 'beneficial' or 'registered' shareholder.

Do I have to dissent with all shares in various accounts at all brokers, or could I dissent with all the shares at just one of my brokers?

Nt




RE: Dissenting per YBCA Section 193 - Li'loilady - 01-09-2017

Thank you so much 2126, jft.  As I understand it, each dissenter has the option of requesting the Yukon courts to perform its own valuation (resource evaluation??)  Further, that the courts may, at their discretion, group all the dissenters together and rule on their behalf as a whole.

Assuming my understanding is correct, how will you be working with those two facts. For instance, will you be asking Schwab to include a request for the courts to do their own valuation/evaluation in the letter they draft on your behalf, just to be thorough?  (I will not be hiring an attorney.)

What are your musings on those two aspects?




RE: Dissenting per YBCA Section 193 - CAC - 01-09-2017

[quote='Li'loilady' pid='78911' dateline='1483919910']

Thank you so much 2126, jft.  As I understand it, each dissenter has the option of requesting the Yukon courts to perform its own valuation (resource evaluation??)  Further, that the courts may, at their discretion, group all the dissenters together and rule on their behalf as a whole.

Assuming my understanding is correct, how will you be working with those two facts. For instance, will you be asking Schwab to include a request for the courts to do their own valuation/evaluation in the letter they draft on your behalf, just to be thorough?  (I will not be hiring an attorney.)

What are your musings on those two aspects?

[/quote

********

This process involves multiple distinct tasks.  Once a lawsuit is filed, the Court can combine plaintiffs if it chooses to do so and can ultimately make a decision on valuation.  In order to be eligible to even try that, you have to first satisfy the statue with regard to the dissenting prerequisites. You can't combine/streamline those two things. First, do whatever you think needs to be done to be considered a registered shareholder, and effectively serve notice of your desent by the applicable deadlines...then later you can initiate the litigation.




RE: Dissenting per YBCA Section 193 - ebster123 - 01-09-2017

Anyone have information on how to do this with Scottrade?


RE: Dissenting per YBCA Section 193 - Kaliboo - 01-10-2017

'ebster123' pid='78913' dateline='<a href="tel:1483960 Wrote:Anyone have information on how to do this with Scottrade?

Anyone dealing wiht USAA?  I have a relative there.