![]() |
|
Dissenting per YBCA Section 193 - Printable Version +- ShareholdersUnite Forums (http://shareholdersunite.com/mybb) +-- Forum: Companies (http://shareholdersunite.com/mybb/forumdisplay.php?fid=1) +--- Forum: InterOil Forum (http://shareholdersunite.com/mybb/forumdisplay.php?fid=4) +--- Thread: Dissenting per YBCA Section 193 (/showthread.php?tid=11669) |
RE: Dissenting per YBCA Section 193 - Kaliboo - 01-10-2017
'2126' pid='78905' dateline='<a href="tel:1483902 Wrote:. Thanks alot 2126 and what is your fee???? Ho ho. Can you help answer these questions with your best guesses? Here's my guesses. I presume that the shareholder merely follows the process up to but before the yellow highlight text. Up to this point the shareholder is then in a waiting mode to see what the offer will be. If we are being treated individually, then I suppose once we receive "the new fairer offer" we each then have option to argure this further if not happy. Is so, will that argument be simply between us and IOC or before the court? I suspect it is at this point that it becomes expensive. E.g., if the opinion and new "fair offer" is prepared by experts representing IOC, then a non expert shareholder is NOT going to win the argument with the court. Correct? The shareholder would need to hire his own experts to prepare a case as to what the "fair offer" should be AND why the IOC new "fairer offer" is still not "fair." Then a court with two sides having opposing experts has to make the call? How does that work? Does the court hire its own experts? In any case it seems the deck is stacked against shareholders and shareholders don't have access to all the data or even much of it. Would IOC/XOM cover our legal fees? Conversely if we are all pooled together, the same questions come up. Who will represent the shareholders and how is that decistion made? Would the court simply say "Hey Phil! You da man! You da speaker for all da shareholders. May God have mercy on you." And then all shareholders are (once again) all depending on Phil to get us a better deal? The joint group approach sounds like maybe a Year+ path unless there is only one shot for Phil et al. I would think that is the way the court wants it. But say Phil is still not happy. Can he and his merry band of shareholders appeal? Chac ching!!!! For the legal fees. Would IOC/XOM be required to pay his/our fees? I'm thinking no sane court would want to deal with have a dozen or more different shareholders with this lengthy process. I'd guess once it gets to e.g., >3 shareholder groups, the court would force them all together. What's your guess? Thanks, Kaliboo RE: Dissenting per YBCA Section 193 - bpjensen - 01-10-2017
'2126' pid='78907' datel Wrote:Do I have to dissent with all shares in various accounts at all brokers, or could I dissent with all the shares at just one of my brokers?
Nt RE: Dissenting per YBCA Section 193 - CAC - 01-10-2017 Kaliboo' [/quote]. Thanks alot 2126 and what is your fee???? Ho ho. Can you help answer these questions with your best guesses? Here's my guesses. I presume that the shareholder merely follows the process up to but before the yellow highlight text. Up to this point the shareholder is then in a waiting mode to see what the offer will be. If we are being treated individually, then I suppose once we receive "the new fairer offer" we each then have option to argure this further if not happy. Is so, will that argument be simply between us and IOC or before the court? I suspect it is at this point that it becomes expensive. E.g., if the opinion and new "fair offer" is prepared by experts representing IOC, then a non expert shareholder is NOT going to win the argument with the court. Correct? The shareholder would need to hire his own experts to prepare a case as to what the "fair offer" should be AND why the IOC new "fairer offer" is still not "fair." Then a court with two sides having opposing experts has to make the call? How does that work? Does the court hire its own experts? In any case it seems the deck is stacked against shareholders and shareholders don't have access to all the data or even much of it. Would IOC/XOM cover our legal fees? Thanks, Kaliboo [/quote] ********** One point of clarification. The "objection" (i.e. the letter you or your broker sends to IOC notifying them of your plan to dissent) is not the event that triggers IOC's obligation to make an offer to you. It is the actual lawsuit (the "Application" filed in Court) that triggers that obligation. RE: Dissenting per YBCA Section 193 - 2126 - 01-10-2017
'bpjensen' pid='78919' datel Wrote:Do I have to dissent with all shares in various accounts at all brokers, or could I dissent with all the shares at just one of my brokers?"[/quote]
Your simple question is actually a deceptively complex one. I'll reiterate that I am NOT a lawyer well-versed in Yukon law. I'm trying to interpret Yukon statutes and case law for my own use and am simply sharing what I find in hopes that other may find it of use. In this case, I can not give you a definitive answer, and for that I apologize in advance. Under the Section 193 of the Yukon Business Corporation Act [Right to Dissent], Subsection 4, it is stated that " A dissenting shareholder may only claim under this section with respect to all the shares of a class held by dissenting shareholder or on behalf of any one beneficial owner and registered in the name of the dissenting shareholder." In addition, under Subsection 6.1, it is also stated that a shareholder who has filed a dissent [objection] ceases to be a dissenting shareholder if: "the shareholder votes, in person or by proxy, in favor of the resolution referred to in Subsection 1 or 2 [referring to the BOD resolution to sell all the assets or shares of a corporation] Looking at these two subsections, we get from the first that:
As is often usual in statutes, this is a poorly written sentence whose lack of punctuation makes it difficult to interpret the grammatical conjuctions "and" and "or". Does this sentence mean what I have divided it into two parts as above: that a shareholder [any type of shareholder--beneficial or registered] may only make a dissent claim with respect to ALL shares of a class [in this case the class is 'common' shares] held by the dissenting shareholder; OR that [in other circumstances altogether] that a shareholder may only claim "on behalf of any one beneficial owner and registered in the name of the dissenting shareholder"? The phrase after the OR could apply to the situations where the shares are held by a brokerage who actually makes the dissent through the DTC, thus being shares that are 'registered in the name of the dissenting shareholder' but are made "on behalf of any one beneficial owner" [the actual owner of the shares held by the brokerage]. An entirely different interpretation would apply if you separate the sentence with more conjunctive emphasis on the AND:
In this interpretation, a shareholder must dissent with all shares of a class or shares held by any one beneficial owner AND the shares must be registered in the name of the shareholder. This seems to indicate that you must dissent with "all shares of a class" and that the shares must all be registered in the name of the shareholder. In general, only registered shareholders may dissent. However, there have been a number of recent Canadian appellate court decisions that have allowed beneficial shareholders the right to dissent in certain specific situations, such as when a corporation failed to provide a clear explanation of dissent rights in its MIC. To futher muddy the waters, In Matre v. Crew Gold Corp., the Supreme Court of Yukon extended dissent rights in a plan of arrangement to beneficial shareholders. It made this decision, in part, based on the fact that the corporation failed to advise its beneficial shareholders of the differing rights to dissent under Yukon law and its failure to differentiate between beneficial and registered shareholders in communications. The corporation denied dissent rights to beneficial owners who had correctly filed their dissent notices with the corporation. The court allowed these beneficial owners to dissent, but limited its decision to the particulars of the circumstances of the case at hand. Whether the Crew Gold Corp. case will apply to the Exxon/IOC situation is anybody's guess. The earlier IOC MIC clearly specified that only 'registered company shareholders as of the record date' may exercise dissent rights. However, IOC has not been forthcoming in alerting beneficial owners of the need to become registered owners before the record date. It is also a bit deceptive that the record date [January 10] takes place before the issuance of the new MIC [due by no later than 30 days before the vote on February 17 and not yet issued]. Whether you can dissent with shares in some accounts and not do so in other accounts is unclear. If you wish to dissent, you must not, in any account, or with any shares, vote YES in the upcoming shareholder vote. Sorry that I can't provide a more definitive answer than this. RE: Dissenting per YBCA Section 193 - 2126 - 01-10-2017
'CAC' pid='78923' datel Wrote:. Thanks alot 2126 and what is your fee???? Ho ho. Can you help answer these questions with your best guesses? Here's my guesses. I presume that the shareholder merely follows the process up to but before the yellow highlight text. Up to this point the shareholder is then in a waiting mode to see what the offer will be. If we are being treated individually, then I suppose once we receive "the new fairer offer" we each then have option to argure this further if not happy. Is so, will that argument be simply between us and IOC or before the court? I suspect it is at this point that it becomes expensive. E.g., if the opinion and new "fair offer" is prepared by experts representing IOC, then a non expert shareholder is NOT going to win the argument with the court. Correct? The shareholder would need to hire his own experts to prepare a case as to what the "fair offer" should be AND why the IOC new "fairer offer" is still not "fair." Then a court with two sides having opposing experts has to make the call? How does that work? Does the court hire its own experts? In any case it seems the deck is stacked against shareholders and shareholders don't have access to all the data or even much of it. Would IOC/XOM cover our legal fees? Thanks, Kaliboo [/quote] ********** One point of clarification. The "objection" (i.e. the letter you or your broker sends to IOC notifying them of your plan to dissent) is not the event that triggers IOC's obligation to make an offer to you. It is the actual lawsuit (the "Application" filed in Court) that triggers that obligation. [/quote] CAC is correct. There are two different things at work: First, one files a Notice of Dissent or Objection. Then, there is an Application made to the Supreme Court to "set the fair value of the shares" as of the close of business on the last business day before the day on which the resolution from which the shareholder dissents was adopted [December 15, 2016, I believe] After Application has been made and after a Final Order approving the Arrangement, the corporation must send to each dissenter a written offer to pay an amount considered by the BOD to be "fair-value" for the shares. This offer must be made within 10 days after the corporation is served with a copy of the originating Notice. The corporation's initial offer of "fair value" must be made to all dissenters equally and must include a statement showing how fair value was determined. A dissenter is NOT required to pay any costs for the Application or any subsequent appraisal ordered by the court. If any dissenters decide to not accept the corporation's initial dissenter fair value offer, the court
Kaliboo: You are right that the deck would be heavily stacked against the shareholders if they were required to argue that the dissent fair value offer is not fair, but I don't think that that is the process. After having dissented and made application for fair value, and then having rejected the corporation's offer, I believe that the court will thne proceed to order an independent appraisal without any requirement that the dissenters press there case for what the actual fair value is. This would be, primarily, because they would always be at a very distinct disadvantage with regard to insider information held by the corporation, be it financial records or drill test results. RE: Dissenting per YBCA Section 193 - jft310 - 01-10-2017 I was told one may dissent on any number of shares , the letters state who is dissenting and how many shares you are dissenting . It's your call on quantity . Thanks 2126 and others for sharing . Together we know more . I still believe the deal passes and the spread between the Exxon price and the NAV is quite large !! Makes most sense to dissent . I hope the courts accept the Paradigm Capital NAV estimate but that May be quite optimistic !! RE: Dissenting per YBCA Section 193 - 2126 - 01-10-2017 Just got off the phone with the Schwab Corporate Action/Reorganization and the Retirement Account Departments regarding a few questions I had about dissenting with Roth and/or IRA accounts. Both departments confirmed what I suspected: That the exercise of dissent rights requires that the dissenter's IOC share certificates actually be turned over to the Yukon Supreme Court or an IOC transfer agent; at which time physical 'dissent certificates' are issued which will be physically held by Schwab in a safe deposit box. Because of this actual requirement for transfer of the IOC shares, the dissent will constitute a distribution from the retirement account. In the case of IRA and Roth accounts, this will trigger the 60-day rollover period within which any proceeds of the dissent process may be returned to a new rollover retirement account without any negative tax consequences. It is not quite clear on which date the 60-day period will begin within this process, but as I note below, it is perhaps not all that relevant. However, if the dissent process takes over 60 days [which it will, of course, unless the dissenter chooses to accept the first dissent fair value offer from IOC], then the distribution from the Standard IRA [not ROTH] accounts will be considered a taxable event and will have extraordinary negative tax consequences. I would be very careful about dissenting with traditional IRA-held shares, as you may be put in a position of either accepting a low-ball offer from IOC or having a huge tax bill while betting on a better dissent outcome beyond the 60-day deadline. Once you have made the decision to dissent with IRA shares, and the deal passes, you will not be able to pull out of your dissent position unless and until you accept the first fair value offer from IOC. Very risky and difficult position to be in, in my opinion. Since a distribution from a ROTH account is a non-taxable event, the 60-day rollover deadline is really irrelevant for the ROTH accounts. Thus, dissent with Roth-account-held shares provides no negative tax consequences beyond what you would face otherwise from the deal going forward. Additionally, the Corporate Action Department also confirmed that for retirement accounts, Schwab itself will actually be the entity that will file the dissent notice, as they are the custodians of these type accounts and they [Schwab] are the registered shareholders of record on the record date. This is the reason for the fees that they charge as they will be preparing and actually filing the dissent notice with IOC [plus a required DTC fee for the exchange of the IOC shares for the dissent certificates]. Hope this throws a little more light on the dissent process. RE: Dissenting per YBCA Section 193 - Kaliboo - 01-10-2017
'2126' pid='78930' datel Wrote: Thanks for sharing this. I think this just put a wrench in the works for anyone dissenting from any IRA. It does affect Roth guys too unless they are over 59 1/2 years of age as regards a distribution. Correct? But I don't trust these brokerage guys on taxes. I suppose Schwab has done this enough to know. But how can it be a distribution event (for tax purposes) until there is an agreed price? It is really an exchange of one form of asset with another form of asset representing the same thing. I would not consider the 60-day rollover beginning until there is an agreed price. Then the clock would start. How can there be a distribtution if there is no sale, and how can there be a sale if there is no agreed price? Did you ask Fidelity o n this one? RE: Dissenting per YBCA Section 193 - Kaliboo - 01-10-2017
'Kaliboo' pid='78933' datel Wrote:One other point. A "distribution" results in assets (money) coming out of the IRA account and put in possession of the account owner. That is not happening here. The custodian - Schwab retains the new security until the sale is complete. So there is no distribution to the shareholder. I wouldn't trust these Schwab guys. Unfortunately, your discussion with them has provided substantial uncertainty as to what is right. Perhaps you can point this out to Schwab. But I doubt if they care whehter they are right or wrong. RE: Dissenting per YBCA Section 193 - Kaliboo - 01-10-2017
'2126' pid='78927' datel Wrote: ********** One point of clarification. The "objection" (i.e. the letter you or your broker sends to IOC notifying them of your plan to dissent) is not the event that triggers IOC's obligation to make an offer to you. It is the actual lawsuit (the "Application" filed in Court) that triggers that obligation. [/quote] CAC is correct. There are two different things at work: First, one files a Notice of Dissent or Objection. Then, there is an Application made to the Supreme Court to "set the fair value of the shares" as of the close of business on the last business day before the day on which the resolution from which the shareholder dissents was adopted [December 15, 2016, I believe] After Application has been made and after a Final Order approving the Arrangement, the corporation must send to each dissenter a written offer to pay an amount considered by the BOD to be "fair-value" for the shares. This offer must be made within 10 days after the corporation is served with a copy of the originating Notice. The corporation's initial offer of "fair value" must be made to all dissenters equally and must include a statement showing how fair value was determined. A dissenter is NOT required to pay any costs for the Application or any subsequent appraisal ordered by the court. If any dissenters decide to not accept the corporation's initial dissenter fair value offer, the court
Kaliboo: You are right that the deck would be heavily stacked against the shareholders if they were required to argue that the dissent fair value offer is not fair, but I don't think that that is the process. After having dissented and made application for fair value, and then having rejected the corporation's offer, I believe that the court will thne proceed to order an independent appraisal without any requirement that the dissenters press there case for what the actual fair value is. This would be, primarily, because they would always be at a very distinct disadvantage with regard to insider information held by the corporation, be it financial records or drill test results. [/quote] CAC and 2126, I would appreciate a little further clarification of the above stuff I put in yellow highlight. I've read the old MIC instructions and they aren't very clear. 1. I understand that my shares are held in street name in a Fidelity account. I will contact their reorganization department and tell them I want to vote no with dissent, and ask them to prepare and forward the dissent information as specifiied in the MIC. Fidelity will act on my behalf as I am the benefical shareholder. That part seems easy and clear. 2. Your next step is that someone has to file an application (or as CAC says, a lawsuit) with the court. I guess I didn't pick up on that part. I'm reading the old MIC (which could change in this regard) and I've pasted the part of concern below. It is ambiguous (at least to me). From pages 50-51 of the old MIC see below. This says either the Dissenting Shareholder (which would be Fidelity on my behalf) , or Interoil may apply to the Court to fix the fiar value....... It seems if I get Fidelity to register my dissent, shouldn't IOC apply to the court? Who is obligated to do this step? Well which one is supposed to do it? The shareholder or IOC? Rather confusing. Did I miss something? I found this on "Applications". http://www.yukoncourts.ca/pdf/rule_47_applications.pdf Haven't read it all as it is getting more and more legalese to me. Note you can appear before the court via video conference. Is this appearce required?
If the Arrangement is approved, the Dissenting Shareholder who sent a Notice of Objection, or InterOil (which for
written offer (the “Offer to Purchase&rdquo
|