RE: Dissenting per YBCA Section 193 - Kaliboo - 01-11-2017
'CAC' pid='78956' datel Wrote:
[quote='2126' pid='78954' dateline='1484070212']
Under YBCA 193, a few subsections are relevant to this discussion:
-
5: A dissenter must send the corporation a written dissent [objection] from the BOD resolution to sell or exchange all of its property
-
6: An application MAY be made to the Supreme Court AFTER adoption of the BOD resolution; such application may be made by a] the corporation or b] a shareholder if shareholder has sent an objection under subsection 5 and such objection has not been deemed invalid because the shareholder a] voted YES or b] withdrew the objection
-
7: If an application is made under 6, the corporation SHALL send "to each dissenting shareholder a written offer to pay an amount considered by the directors to be the fair value of the shares to that shareholder".
-
8: Unless court orders otherwise, the offer noted in 7 SHALL be sent to EACH dissenting shareholder and [when the applicant is a shareholder] within 10 days after the corporation is served with a copy of the originating notice [Notice of Application].
-
9: Every offer under subsection 7 SHALL be made on a] the same terms and b] contain a statement showing how fair value was determined.
The way I read this statutory language is that if ANY shareholder makes application to the court for a fair value, then IOC is required to proceed to send EVERY dissenting shareholder an identical fair value offer for their shares. Such offers must be made within 10 days after IOC receives notice of the application having been made to the court.
****
That may be correct. However I wouldn't necessarily assume that someone else's Application protects all dissenters (even if they don't subsequently file themselves). I think Section 7 is arguably ambiguous. Does "an Application" mean "anybody's Application"...or is it poorly drafted and intended to refer to "the Application each individual dissenter filed as discussed in Section 6"? I don't know how this might be interpreted.
The statute does not seem to provide a stated time-limit/deadline for filing an Application (as it does for serving the Notice of Objection) so I suppose one could just wait for 10 days after the first Application is filed by someone else (assuming there's a way to definitively know this has been done) and then see if IOC sends out the mass offers to everyone. If not, you could still file an Application on your own at that point.
Glad to see it is all now crystal clear on how to go forward. 
RE: Dissenting per YBCA Section 193 - jft310 - 01-11-2017
The path forward should be clear
Call your broker dealer and tell them you want to dissent .They handle the paperwork . The issuing of shares is not a taxable event, The sale or exchange of your shares is taxable when that happens. The dissent itself is not taxable .
After verifying your notice had been received by IOC's attorney one will need to use an attorney to tell the courts you are a dissenter.
Attorney's are available to handle that application with the courts . We have an attorney on stand by . Phil M might let you use his attorney . That's the future and that hurdle can be cleared later .
RE: Dissenting per YBCA Section 193 - bpjensen - 01-12-2017
'CAC' pid='78940' datel Wrote:
'Kaliboo' pid='78935' dateline='<a href="tel:1484004 Wrote:
'2126' pid='78927' dateline='<a href="tel:1483992 Wrote:
'CAC' pid='78923' dateline='<a href="tel:1483985 Wrote:
Kaliboo' . Thanks alot 2126 and what is your fee???? Ho ho. Can you help answer these questions with your best guesses?
Here's my guesses. I presume that the shareholder merely follows the process up to but before the yellow highlight text. Up to this point the shareholder is then in a waiting mode to see what the offer will be. If we are being treated individually, then I suppose once we receive "the new fairer offer" we each then have option to argure this further if not happy. Is so, will that argument be simply between us and IOC or before the court? I suspect it is at this point that it becomes expensive. E.g., if the opinion and new "fair offer" is prepared by experts representing IOC, then a non expert shareholder is NOT going to win the argument with the court. Correct? The shareholder would need to hire his own experts to prepare a case as to what the "fair offer" should be AND why the IOC new "fairer offer" is still not "fair." Then a court with two sides having opposing experts has to make the call? How does that work? Does the court hire its own experts? In any case it seems the deck is stacked against shareholders and shareholders don't have access to all the data or even much of it. Would IOC/XOM cover our legal fees?
Thanks, Kaliboo
**********
One point of clarification. The "objection" (i.e. the letter you or your broker sends to IOC notifying them of your plan to dissent) is not the event that triggers IOC's obligation to make an offer to you. It is the actual lawsuit (the "Application" filed in Court) that triggers that obligation.
CAC is correct. There are two different things at work: First, one files a Notice of Dissent or Objection. Then, there is an Application made to the Supreme Court to "set the fair value of the shares" as of the close of business on the last business day before the day on which the resolution from which the shareholder dissents was adopted [December 15, 2016, I believe]
After Application has been made and after a Final Order approving the Arrangement, the corporation must send to each dissenter a written offer to pay an amount considered by the BOD to be "fair-value" for the shares. This offer must be made within 10 days after the corporation is served with a copy of the originating Notice. The corporation's initial offer of "fair value" must be made to all dissenters equally and must include a statement showing how fair value was determined. A dissenter is NOT required to pay any costs for the Application or any subsequent appraisal ordered by the court.
If any dissenters decide to not accept the corporation's initial dissenter fair value offer, the court
-
may join all dissenters together as a group;
-
may arrange for representation of dissenters who are in need of representation;
-
may conduct a trial; and
-
may order an independent appraisal.
-
The court also has the power to assign the burden of proof, which in this case will be a significant decision, as it will determine if IOC must "prove" that its initial dissent offer is "fair".
Kaliboo: You are right that the deck would be heavily stacked against the shareholders if they were required to argue that the dissent fair value offer is not fair, but I don't think that that is the process. After having dissented and made application for fair value, and then having rejected the corporation's offer, I believe that the court will thne proceed to order an independent appraisal without any requirement that the dissenters press there case for what the actual fair value is. This would be, primarily, because they would always be at a very distinct disadvantage with regard to insider information held by the corporation, be it financial records or drill test results.
CAC and 2126,
I would appreciate a little further clarification of the above stuff I put in yellow highlight. I've read the old MIC instructions and they aren't very clear.
1. I understand that my shares are held in street name in a Fidelity account. I will contact their reorganization department and tell them I want to vote no with dissent, and ask them to prepare and forward the dissent information as specifiied in the MIC. Fidelity will act on my behalf as I am the benefical shareholder. That part seems easy and clear.
2. Your next step is that someone has to file an application (or as CAC says, a lawsuit) with the court. I guess I didn't pick up on that part. I'm reading the old MIC (which could change in this regard) and I've pasted the part of concern below. It is ambiguous (at least to me). From pages 50-51 of the old MIC see below. This says either the Dissenting Shareholder (which would be Fidelity on my behalf) , or Interoil may apply to the Court to fix the fiar value....... It seems if I get Fidelity to register my dissent, shouldn't IOC apply to the court? Who is obligated to do this step?
Well which one is supposed to do it? The shareholder or IOC? Rather confusing. Did I miss something?
I found this on "Applications". http://www.yukoncourts.ca/pdf/rule_47_applications.pdf Haven't read it all as it is getting more and more legalese to me.
Note you can appear before the court via video conference. Is this appearce required?
******
You would be the one to file with the Supreme Court as IOC would certainly have no incentive to push that process. In my case, I was allowed to participate in a pre trial conference via phone (IOC's White Horse counsel appeared in person). The Court seems very accommodating to pro se (and foreign) claimants and also authorized "service" on me via fax...even though the local rules indicate a Yukon address is to be provided by the Plaintiff. If you call the Yukon Supreme Court Clerk (they have a toll free number) they will help you quite a bit with accepted/recommended procedure.
[/quote]
CAC, could you by any chance share the template that you used to self file? Thanks in advance!!!
RE: Dissenting per YBCA Section 193 - 2126 - 01-12-2017
Here are the Yukon court rules for filing an Application:
Yukon Supreme Court Local Rules
RULE 47 – APPLICATIONS
How an application must be brought
(1) If an application in a proceeding is authorized to be made to the court, it must be made by application in Form 52.
An application by consent or if notice not required
(2) An application referred to in Rule 43(10), (11), (12) or (13) may be made in accordance with that rule.
Notice of application
(3) Subject to subrule (2), a party wishing to bring an application must serve or deliver a notice of application at or before the time at which the notice of hearing is filed under Rule 48.
More than one matter may be included
(4) A party may include, in one application, claims for relief in respect of more than one matter.
Service or delivery
(5) Unless these rules provide otherwise, the applicant must deliver to each party of record and must serve on each other person, other than a party, who may be affected by the order sought
(a) a copy of the notice of application,
(b) a copy of each affidavit in support of the application that has not already been filed and served, and
© any notice that the applicant is required to give under Rule 19(8).
Response
(6) Subject to subrule (11), a party or person who receives documents under subrule (5) and who wishes to receive notice of the time and date of the hearing of the application or who wishes to respond to it must deliver to the applicant 2 copies, and to every other party of record one copy, of
(a) a response in Form 11,
(b) each affidavit that has not already been filed and served on which the respondent intends to rely, and
© any notice that that person is required to give under Rule 19(8),
on or before the 8th day after the date on which the notice of application was served or delivered.
Reply by applicant
(7) An applicant who wishes to respond to any document provided under subrule (6) must, no later than the date on which the notice of hearing is delivered to the respondent in accordance with Rule 48, deliver any affidavits in reply to each person who delivered a response under subrule (6).
No additional affidavits
(8) Unless all parties of record consent or the court otherwise orders, a party or person must not deliver any affidavits additional to those delivered under subrules (5), (6) and (7).
Place of hearing of application
(9) The application shall be heard at Whitehorse, unless otherwise ordered.
Appearance at hearing
(10) A party or person may appear in person, or by telephone or videoconference with leave of the court or by consent of the parties.
Application for directions
(11) A party or person may apply for directions for an application at an appearance day or a case management meeting.
RE: Dissenting per YBCA Section 193 - 2126 - 01-12-2017
Here is the official Yukon Supreme Court Form for Notice of Application. I do not have a template for the actual Application.
Form 52 (Rule 47 (1) ) S.C.__________
SUPREME COURT OF YUKON
Between
Plaintiff/ Petitioner
and
Defendant/ Respondent
NOTICE OF APPLICATION
To [party or person affected]
TAKE NOTICE that an application will be made by [party] _________________ to the presiding judge at the The Law Courts, 2134 Second Avenue, Whitehorse, Yukon at a date and time to be set for an order that [set out orders sought in numbered paragraphs or attach a draft order in numbered paragraphs] _______
_______________________________________________________________.
The applicant will rely on [set out Act, Statute, Regulation or Rule relied upon] _______________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________________.
At the hearing of the application, the applicant will rely on the following affidavit(s) and other documents [set out affidavits delivered with the Notice of Application and any other affidavits and other documents already in the court file on which the applicant will rely] _______________________________.
The applicant estimates that the application will take ________ minutes (hours).
If you wish to receive notice of the time and date of the hearing or to respond to the application, you must, within the proper time for response:
(a) deliver to the applicant
(i) 2 copies of a Response in Form 11, and
(ii) 2 copies of each of the affidavits and other documents, not already in the court file, on which you intend to rely at the hearing, and
(b) deliver to every other party of record
(i) one copy of a Response in Form 11, and
(ii) one copy of each affidavit and other document, not already in the court file, on which you intend to rely at the hearing.
TIME FOR RESPONSE
The Response must be delivered on or before the 8th day after the later of
(a) the last date fixed for entry of appearance by you, and
(b) the date on which the Notice of Application was delivered to you.
Dated _______________________ _______________________
Party [or party’s lawyer]
RE: Dissenting per YBCA Section 193 - CAC - 01-12-2017
'bpjensen' pid='78962' dateline='<a href="tel:1484146 Wrote:
'CAC' pid='78940' dateline='<a href="tel:1484009 Wrote:
'Kaliboo' pid='78935' dateline='<a href="tel:1484004 Wrote:
'2126' pid='78927' dateline='<a href="tel:1483992 Wrote:
'CAC' pid='78923' dateline='<a href="tel:1483985 Wrote:
Kaliboo' . Thanks alot 2126 and what is your fee???? Ho ho. Can you help answer these questions with your best guesses?
Here's my guesses. I presume that the shareholder merely follows the process up to but before the yellow highlight text. Up to this point the shareholder is then in a waiting mode to see what the offer will be. If we are being treated individually, then I suppose once we receive "the new fairer offer" we each then have option to argure this further if not happy. Is so, will that argument be simply between us and IOC or before the court? I suspect it is at this point that it becomes expensive. E.g., if the opinion and new "fair offer" is prepared by experts representing IOC, then a non expert shareholder is NOT going to win the argument with the court. Correct? The shareholder would need to hire his own experts to prepare a case as to what the "fair offer" should be AND why the IOC new "fairer offer" is still not "fair." Then a court with two sides having opposing experts has to make the call? How does that work? Does the court hire its own experts? In any case it seems the deck is stacked against shareholders and shareholders don't have access to all the data or even much of it. Would IOC/XOM cover our legal fees?
Thanks, Kaliboo
**********
One point of clarification. The "objection" (i.e. the letter you or your broker sends to IOC notifying them of your plan to dissent) is not the event that triggers IOC's obligation to make an offer to you. It is the actual lawsuit (the "Application" filed in Court) that triggers that obligation.
CAC is correct. There are two different things at work: First, one files a Notice of Dissent or Objection. Then, there is an Application made to the Supreme Court to "set the fair value of the shares" as of the close of business on the last business day before the day on which the resolution from which the shareholder dissents was adopted [December 15, 2016, I believe]
After Application has been made and after a Final Order approving the Arrangement, the corporation must send to each dissenter a written offer to pay an amount considered by the BOD to be "fair-value" for the shares. This offer must be made within 10 days after the corporation is served with a copy of the originating Notice. The corporation's initial offer of "fair value" must be made to all dissenters equally and must include a statement showing how fair value was determined. A dissenter is NOT required to pay any costs for the Application or any subsequent appraisal ordered by the court.
If any dissenters decide to not accept the corporation's initial dissenter fair value offer, the court
-
may join all dissenters together as a group;
-
may arrange for representation of dissenters who are in need of representation;
-
may conduct a trial; and
-
may order an independent appraisal.
-
The court also has the power to assign the burden of proof, which in this case will be a significant decision, as it will determine if IOC must "prove" that its initial dissent offer is "fair".
Kaliboo: You are right that the deck would be heavily stacked against the shareholders if they were required to argue that the dissent fair value offer is not fair, but I don't think that that is the process. After having dissented and made application for fair value, and then having rejected the corporation's offer, I believe that the court will thne proceed to order an independent appraisal without any requirement that the dissenters press there case for what the actual fair value is. This would be, primarily, because they would always be at a very distinct disadvantage with regard to insider information held by the corporation, be it financial records or drill test results.
CAC and 2126,
I would appreciate a little further clarification of the above stuff I put in yellow highlight. I've read the old MIC instructions and they aren't very clear.
1. I understand that my shares are held in street name in a Fidelity account. I will contact their reorganization department and tell them I want to vote no with dissent, and ask them to prepare and forward the dissent information as specifiied in the MIC. Fidelity will act on my behalf as I am the benefical shareholder. That part seems easy and clear.
2. Your next step is that someone has to file an application (or as CAC says, a lawsuit) with the court. I guess I didn't pick up on that part. I'm reading the old MIC (which could change in this regard) and I've pasted the part of concern below. It is ambiguous (at least to me). From pages 50-51 of the old MIC see below. This says either the Dissenting Shareholder (which would be Fidelity on my behalf) , or Interoil may apply to the Court to fix the fiar value....... It seems if I get Fidelity to register my dissent, shouldn't IOC apply to the court? Who is obligated to do this step?
Well which one is supposed to do it? The shareholder or IOC? Rather confusing. Did I miss something?
I found this on "Applications". http://www.yukoncourts.ca/pdf/rule_47_applications.pdf Haven't read it all as it is getting more and more legalese to me.
Note you can appear before the court via video conference. Is this appearce required?
******
You would be the one to file with the Supreme Court as IOC would certainly have no incentive to push that process. In my case, I was allowed to participate in a pre trial conference via phone (IOC's White Horse counsel appeared in person). The Court seems very accommodating to pro se (and foreign) claimants and also authorized "service" on me via fax...even though the local rules indicate a Yukon address is to be provided by the Plaintiff. If you call the Yukon Supreme Court Clerk (they have a toll free number) they will help you quite a bit with accepted/recommended procedure.
CAC, could you by any chance share the template that you used to self file? Thanks in advance!!!
[/quote]
*******
I used the exact form posted by 2126. There is a modest filing fee and then you will need to pay a separate fee to have the sheriff serve it for you. If you call the Clerk as a pro se they will walk you through a lot of it.
RE: Dissenting per YBCA Section 193 - Kaliboo - 01-12-2017
'2126' pid='78964' dateline='<a href="tel:1484147 Wrote:Here is the official Yukon Supreme Court Form for Notice of Application. I do not have a template for the actual Application. Form 52 (Rule 47 (1) ) S.C.__________ SUPREME COURT OF YUKON Between Plaintiff/ Petitioner and Defendant/ Respondent NOTICE OF APPLICATION To [party or person affected] TAKE NOTICE that an application will be made by [party] _________________ to the presiding judge at the The Law Courts, 2134 Second Avenue, Whitehorse, Yukon at a date and time to be set for an order that [set out orders sought in numbered paragraphs or attach a draft order in numbered paragraphs] _______ _______________________________________________________________. The applicant will rely on [set out Act, Statute, Regulation or Rule relied upon] _______________________________________________________________ _______________________________________________________________. At the hearing of the application, the applicant will rely on the following affidavit(s) and other documents [set out affidavits delivered with the Notice of Application and any other affidavits and other documents already in the court file on which the applicant will rely] _______________________________. The applicant estimates that the application will take ________ minutes (hours). If you wish to receive notice of the time and date of the hearing or to respond to the application, you must, within the proper time for response: (a) deliver to the applicant (i) 2 copies of a Response in Form 11, and (ii) 2 copies of each of the affidavits and other documents, not already in the court file, on which you intend to rely at the hearing, and (b) deliver to every other party of record (i) one copy of a Response in Form 11, and (ii) one copy of each affidavit and other document, not already in the court file, on which you intend to rely at the hearing. TIME FOR RESPONSE The Response must be delivered on or before the 8th day after the later of (a) the last date fixed for entry of appearance by you, and (b) the date on which the Notice of Application was delivered to you. Dated _______________________ _______________________ Party [or party’s lawyer]
Thanks. So there is (1) filing a dissent, (2) a Notice of Application, and (3) the actual Application with fees tucked in here and there to accomplish this, and an unknown outcome. I would bet this intimidates and knocks probably 99.99% of retail shareholders out of the picture as dissenters unless they've done this before or are lawyers. As this chain gets longer and longer, it seems there are more and more things that one has to do to have a chance a getting properly compensated. I think CACs comment to call the Yukon will be my ultimate decider on dissenting. I don't want to open a "bar tab" with an attorney to do this.
RE: Dissenting per YBCA Section 193 - CAC - 01-12-2017
'Kaliboo' pid='78966' datel Wrote:
[quote='2126' pid='78964' dateline='1484147574'] Here is the official Yukon Supreme Court Form for Notice of Application. I do not have a template for the actual Application. Form 52 (Rule 47 (1) ) S.C.__________ SUPREME COURT OF YUKON Between Plaintiff/ Petitioner and Defendant/ Respondent NOTICE OF APPLICATION To [party or person affected] TAKE NOTICE that an application will be made by [party] _________________ to the presiding judge at the The Law Courts, 2134 Second Avenue, Whitehorse, Yukon at a date and time to be set for an order that [set out orders sought in numbered paragraphs or attach a draft order in numbered paragraphs] _______ _______________________________________________________________. The applicant will rely on [set out Act, Statute, Regulation or Rule relied upon] _______________________________________________________________ _______________________________________________________________. At the hearing of the application, the applicant will rely on the following affidavit(s) and other documents [set out affidavits delivered with the Notice of Application and any other affidavits and other documents already in the court file on which the applicant will rely] _______________________________. The applicant estimates that the application will take ________ minutes (hours). If you wish to receive notice of the time and date of the hearing or to respond to the application, you must, within the proper time for response: (a) deliver to the applicant (i) 2 copies of a Response in Form 11, and (ii) 2 copies of each of the affidavits and other documents, not already in the court file, on which you intend to rely at the hearing, and (b) deliver to every other party of record (i) one copy of a Response in Form 11, and (ii) one copy of each affidavit and other document, not already in the court file, on which you intend to rely at the hearing. TIME FOR RESPONSE The Response must be delivered on or before the 8th day after the later of (a) the last date fixed for entry of appearance by you, and (b) the date on which the Notice of Application was delivered to you. Dated _______________________ _______________________ Party [or party’s lawyer]
Thanks. So there is (1) filing a dissent, (2) a Notice of Application, and (3) the actual Application with fees tucked in here and there to accomplish this, and an unknown outcome. I would bet this intimidates and knocks probably 99.99% of retail shareholders out of the picture as dissenters unless they've done this before or are lawyers. As this chain gets longer and longer, it seems there are more and more things that one has to do to have a chance a getting properly compensated. I think CACs comment to call the Yukon will be my ultimate decider on dissenting. I don't want to open a "bar tab" with an attorney to do this.
*****
It is, at most, two things.
1) Serving a Notice of Objection (this is just a letter sent to the IOC designated representative), and
2) Filing an Application
As 2126 mentioned, it is possible that all dissenters will be able to piggyback off of the first dissenter's Application and be given an offer by IOC/XOM. If so, just doing #1 might end up being enough.
RE: Dissenting per YBCA Section 193 - 2126 - 01-12-2017
'Kaliboo' pid='78966' datel Wrote:
'2126' pid='78964' dateline='<a href="tel:1484147 Wrote:Here is the official Yukon Supreme Court Form for Notice of Application. I do not have a template for the actual Application. Form 52 (Rule 47 (1) ) S.C.__________ SUPREME COURT OF YUKON Between Plaintiff/ Petitioner and Defendant/ Respondent NOTICE OF APPLICATION To [party or person affected] TAKE NOTICE that an application will be made by [party] _________________ to the presiding judge at the The Law Courts, 2134 Second Avenue, Whitehorse, Yukon at a date and time to be set for an order that [set out orders sought in numbered paragraphs or attach a draft order in numbered paragraphs] _______ _______________________________________________________________. The applicant will rely on [set out Act, Statute, Regulation or Rule relied upon] _______________________________________________________________ _______________________________________________________________. At the hearing of the application, the applicant will rely on the following affidavit(s) and other documents [set out affidavits delivered with the Notice of Application and any other affidavits and other documents already in the court file on which the applicant will rely] _______________________________. The applicant estimates that the application will take ________ minutes (hours). If you wish to receive notice of the time and date of the hearing or to respond to the application, you must, within the proper time for response: (a) deliver to the applicant (i) 2 copies of a Response in Form 11, and (ii) 2 copies of each of the affidavits and other documents, not already in the court file, on which you intend to rely at the hearing, and (b) deliver to every other party of record (i) one copy of a Response in Form 11, and (ii) one copy of each affidavit and other document, not already in the court file, on which you intend to rely at the hearing. TIME FOR RESPONSE The Response must be delivered on or before the 8th day after the later of (a) the last date fixed for entry of appearance by you, and (b) the date on which the Notice of Application was delivered to you. Dated _______________________ _______________________ Party [or party’s lawyer]
Thanks. So there is (1) filing a dissent, (2) a Notice of Application, and (3) the actual Application with fees tucked in here and there to accomplish this, and an unknown outcome. I would bet this intimidates and knocks probably 99.99% of retail shareholders out of the picture as dissenters unless they've done this before or are lawyers. As this chain gets longer and longer, it seems there are more and more things that one has to do to have a chance a getting properly compensated. I think CACs comment to call the Yukon will be my ultimate decider on dissenting. I don't want to open a "bar tab" with an attorney to do this.
If one is a 'registered' shareholder, one can send a Notice of Dissent and Objection to IOC once the MIC provides the necessary address and deadlines for such action.[I have posted a template for this Notice elsewhere on this forum].
If one is a 'beneficial' shareholder, one can have their broker handle the dissent, per the various discussions on this thread.
Either way, once one's dissent is filed with IOC, one can hope that, as I have noted elsewhere, the application to the Yukon court for 'fair value' for shares by any shareholder should trigger the initial dissent fair-value offer from IOC to all dissenting shareholders. If so, one can accept the offer or decline and be in the group that will likely be joined by the judge for the court-ordered appraisal. If one needs to actually fila an application with the court [as CAC suggests], one can wait and see if a dissent offer appears within a few weeks of final approval. If not, at that time, one can go forward with filing an individual application and notice of application.
RE: Dissenting per YBCA Section 193 - Kaliboo - 01-12-2017
'2126' pid='78969' datel Wrote:
'Kaliboo' pid='78966' datel Wrote:
'2126' pid='78964' dateline='<a href="tel:1484147 Wrote:Here is the official Yukon Supreme Court Form for Notice of Application. I do not have a template for the actual Application. Form 52 (Rule 47 (1) ) S.C.__________ SUPREME COURT OF YUKON Between Plaintiff/ Petitioner and Defendant/ Respondent NOTICE OF APPLICATION To [party or person affected] TAKE NOTICE that an application will be made by [party] _________________ to the presiding judge at the The Law Courts, 2134 Second Avenue, Whitehorse, Yukon at a date and time to be set for an order that [set out orders sought in numbered paragraphs or attach a draft order in numbered paragraphs] _______ _______________________________________________________________. The applicant will rely on [set out Act, Statute, Regulation or Rule relied upon] _______________________________________________________________ _______________________________________________________________. At the hearing of the application, the applicant will rely on the following affidavit(s) and other documents [set out affidavits delivered with the Notice of Application and any other affidavits and other documents already in the court file on which the applicant will rely] _______________________________. The applicant estimates that the application will take ________ minutes (hours). If you wish to receive notice of the time and date of the hearing or to respond to the application, you must, within the proper time for response: (a) deliver to the applicant (i) 2 copies of a Response in Form 11, and (ii) 2 copies of each of the affidavits and other documents, not already in the court file, on which you intend to rely at the hearing, and (b) deliver to every other party of record (i) one copy of a Response in Form 11, and (ii) one copy of each affidavit and other document, not already in the court file, on which you intend to rely at the hearing. TIME FOR RESPONSE The Response must be delivered on or before the 8th day after the later of (a) the last date fixed for entry of appearance by you, and (b) the date on which the Notice of Application was delivered to you. Dated _______________________ _______________________ Party [or party’s lawyer]
Thanks. So there is (1) filing a dissent, (2) a Notice of Application, and (3) the actual Application with fees tucked in here and there to accomplish this, and an unknown outcome. I would bet this intimidates and knocks probably 99.99% of retail shareholders out of the picture as dissenters unless they've done this before or are lawyers. As this chain gets longer and longer, it seems there are more and more things that one has to do to have a chance a getting properly compensated. I think CACs comment to call the Yukon will be my ultimate decider on dissenting. I don't want to open a "bar tab" with an attorney to do this.
If one is a 'registered' shareholder, one can send a Notice of Dissent and Objection to IOC once the MIC provides the necessary address and deadlines for such action.[I have posted a template for this Notice elsewhere on this forum].
If one is a 'beneficial' shareholder, one can have their broker handle the dissent, per the various discussions on this thread.
Either way, once one's dissent is filed with IOC, one can hope that, as I have noted elsewhere, the application to the Yukon court for 'fair value' for shares by any shareholder should trigger the initial dissent fair-value offer from IOC to all dissenting shareholders. If so, one can accept the offer or decline and be in the group that will likely be joined by the judge for the court-ordered appraisal. If one needs to actually fila an application with the court [as CAC suggests], one can wait and see if a dissent offer appears within a few weeks of final approval. If not, at that time, one can go forward with filing an individual application and notice of application.
Thanks. I just talked to the court in Yukon. The lady was fairly helpful, but now I have to do a lot of reading to see if I can make sense of what she told me. Your suggestion above sounds safe IF one knows what the deadline is for filing with the court, if one has to file. But that's not clear to me.
I think I will try and contact Phil's group to see if they are willing to allow others to join them as regards the court application filing part, if required. If I'm going to lose some sleep over this, then I'd like to know that I hooked up with people who know what they are doing.
|