![]() |
|
Dissenting per YBCA Section 193 - Printable Version +- ShareholdersUnite Forums (http://shareholdersunite.com/mybb) +-- Forum: Companies (http://shareholdersunite.com/mybb/forumdisplay.php?fid=1) +--- Forum: InterOil Forum (http://shareholdersunite.com/mybb/forumdisplay.php?fid=4) +--- Thread: Dissenting per YBCA Section 193 (/showthread.php?tid=11669) |
RE: Dissenting per YBCA Section 193 - 2126 - 01-24-2017
I've been out of touch for a week or so and haven't been able to respond to a few questions. First, there was a question about record date and the ability to dissent. Quick answer is that you must have owned the stock on the record date to be eligible to both vote on the deal AND, if you wish, dissent from the deal. You [or your broker, if you are a beneficial shareholder==making your broker the registered shareholder on the IOC books on record date] must either abstain or vote no in order to dissent as well. If you go through a broker, they will handle the dissent [though some may not provide for delivery to the IOC attorney in Whitehorse--Schwab will do this as part of their fee]. If you are the actual registered owner on the IOC books, you will need to file your written Objection [dissent] by no later than February 10 to the address of the IOC attorney in Whitehorse, Yukon. The address is in the MIC. JFT or CAC may be able to help anyone that needs legal help get in touch with an attorney in Whitehorse, but be aware that the main 3 law firms that have corporate merger experience have been retained by Exxon, IOC, and Phil, and none of those 3 are willing to represent any other shareholders. Second, there was a question regarding when one can withdraw one's dissent if desired. This is governed by Yukon statute 193. Section 6.1 provides that a shareholder can withdraw their dissent by written notice to the corporation [the IOC attorney in Whitehorse]. Doing so would put you back in the pool of general shareholders and you would reap the benefits of the deal only. Section 10 provides that a dissenting shareholder may accept any offer from IOC [including the required one which IOC must provide to all dissenting shareholders within 10 days of receiving notice that a shareholder has filed an application with the court for a fair value determination]. The dissenting shareholders may accept such an offer up to the time when the court sets the fair value for the dissenting shares under Section 13 [presumably after it receives the independent appraisal results which the court may order]. Once the court sets the fair value, any earlier offers from IOC are off the table. Finally, Section 14 provides that a dissenting shareholder may only withdraw their dissent up until the occurence of any of the following: 1] the deal is approved by the shareholders [and presumably by the court as well, though the statute does not specify this], 2] a shareholder accepts any offer from IOC under Section 10, or 3] the court sets the fair value for the shares under Section 13. Thus, once the shareholder vote passes and the court approves the deal [and I believe, that the Appelate court does not again overturn the lower court approval of the deal] then a dissenting shareholder is stuck with either the IOC offer to dissenters or the final court order setting the fair value. Again, once the Court sets the fair value, the dissenters are stuck with that value and may not then accept any earlier offer from IOC. Hope that helps a little. If your decisions are critical to your welfare and wealth, I strongly suggest that you try and get confirmation of my interpretation of the Yukon statutes from an attorney liceensed in the Yukon, of which I am most assuredly not. RE: Dissenting per YBCA Section 193 - jft310 - 01-24-2017 Thanks 2126 !! RE: Dissenting per YBCA Section 193 - bpjensen - 01-24-2017 I've just skimmed the MIC that I received today. I see that BMO valuation is considerably less than Exon offer. Does anyone have or know how to get a copy of the NPV calculations that Phil group presented to the Yukon court?
RE: Dissenting per YBCA Section 193 - Kaliboo - 01-24-2017
'bpjensen' pid='79122' datel Wrote: Note this quote in the MIC under Appendix E where the BMO fairness assessment is: "BMO Capital Markets has not, to the best of its knowledge, been denied access by the Company to any information under the Company’s control requested by BMO Capital Markets." I'm only skimming this too, but a word search for Bobcat and/or Raptor does not reveal any mentioning of these fields in their valuation. Could it be that IOC played a game of "don't ask, don't tell?" If BMO didn't ask specifically for records on Raptor and Bobcat, then IOC didn't offer it. XOM's offer doesn't mention them either. Seems really strange. Guess I'll have to read some more, but it looks like zero value there. RE: Dissenting per YBCA Section 193 - jft310 - 01-24-2017 Kali nailed it this is a flawed fairness opinion . Phil hired Patadigm Capital to do an independent NAV determination and the courts accepted that work and stated the deal substanially undervalued the assets . What else is there to know ???? |