Here is a pitch from Money Morning. We’re not entirely sold, but there are some interesting titbits we’ll discuss at the end.
Six Profit Plays From South of the Equator
By Martin Hutchinson Contributing Editor Money Morning
- Like most other markets, Brazil has been battered by the credit crisis – the BOVESPA index is currently down 28% in October alone and no less than 52% from its peak as recently as May. It now appears to represent excellent value, with a historic Price/Earnings (P/E) ratio of only 7.0.
- But are Brazil’s prospects good enough to justify investing there?
- Brazil was included in the “BRIC” (Brazil, Russia, India and China) group of rapidly emerging markets that Goldman Sachs Group Inc. (GS) created in 2003. At that time the country didn’t deserve the distinction. Long-term growth since the 1970s had averaged less than 2% per capita, and the country had barely avoided bankruptcy in 2002. Every time the world had experienced a credit crunch, Brazil had been caught up in it, chiefly because of the country’s enormous international debt load.
- Brazil got lucky. First, socialist President Luis Inacio “Lula” da Silva proved to be surprisingly moderate, not much to the left, economically, of previous Brazilian governments, perfectly willing to welcome foreign investment and generally friendly to the United States. Also, in 2003, energy and commodity prices began their long climb as part of a worldwide commodities rally that saw prices peak at astronomical levels earlier this year.
- Since Brazil was not an oil exporter, there was no one single source of new wealth that the government could seize. Instead, revenue flowed to mining companies, the oil company Petroleo Brasileiro SA, better-known as Petrobras (ADR: PBR), and numerous agri-business operations that benefited from the rise in agricultural prices. It didn’t hurt at all when in November 2007 Petrobras discovered about 36 billion barrels of oil in an offshore Brazilian field.
- Even Brazil’s ethanol program, which had been a hopeless boondoggle for a generation since it started during the oil crisis of 1979-82, suddenly became the envy of the world, as rising oil prices made Brazilian sugarcane the world’s cheapest and most economically and ecologically efficient source of newly fashionable ethanol. With oil prices down in the $20-a-barrel range, the ethanol-from-sugar program was a typical example of misguided Third World government planning. But at $140 a barrel, it was a bonanza.
- Even at $60 a barrel, it is still a useful diversification from petroleum.
- Brazil’s debt position improved after 2002 in three ways:
- * The outstanding amount of debt has been reduced through modest repayments.
- * Its ratio to gross domestic product (GDP) has dropped sharply, as GDP in dollar terms has shot up with the revaluation of the Brazilian real against the dollar.
- * And its interest costs have dropped with Brazil’s improving creditworthiness and the generally low level of global interest rates.
- Brazil’s ascension to “investment grade” status in spring 2008 appeared to cement the improvement in place; its public sector debt to GDP ratio in June 2008 was around 40%, lower than Britain’s, for example.
- The financial crisis and economic downturn of 2008 has made life more difficult for Brazil. Oil and other commodity prices have sharply declined, reducing the value of Brazil’s exports. The real has declined over 30% against the dollar, increasing Brazil’s foreign debt, which is mostly dollar-denominated.
- The Brazilian stock market’s decline will undoubtedly have a substantial negative wealth effect, making it more difficult for Brazilian entrepreneurs to finance new projects. On the other hand, a forecast by The Economist has Brazil still growing at 4.6% in 2008 and 3.4% in 2009, with consumer prices rising 6.0%. The Central Bank of Brazil has a good grip on inflation, with its Selic short-term rate at no less than 13.75%, while it is injecting funds into the banking system to battle the global liquidity shortage.
- With continued economic growth, modest inflation, and stock prices at bargain levels for U.S. investors, Brazil is well worth considering. There are more than 30 Brazilian companies with full American Depository Receipt (ADR) listings on the New York Stock Exchange, plus 40 to 50 more traded on the over-the-counter market. A few attractive examples you might want to look include:
- Banco Itau Holding Financeira SA (ITU). This stock features a Price/Earnings There are three large banks listed on the New York Stock Exchange: The other two are the other two are Banco Bradesco SA (ADR: BBD) and Uniao Bancos Brasile SA (Unibanco) (ADR: UBB). However, Itau is the cheapest of the three, though only slightly.
- Companhia Vale do Rio Doce, now referred to only as Vale (ADR: RIO). This is one of the true global blue chips. It has a market capitalization of almost $56 billion, and its stock has fallen by fully 75% since May. It is an iron-ore company with ancillary operations in gold, nickel, copper and other metals, and its shares are trading about four times projected 2008 earnings. The stock features a 5.0% yield. As one of the world’s low cost producers of iron ore, it should bounce back once conditions become more clear.
- Petroleo Brasileiro SA, better known as Petrobras (ADR: PBR). Petrobras is one of the few emerging market oil companies with access to modern technology and willingness to work with the oil majors. Down by 60% in the last five months, the stock’s prospective P/E ratio is now only 5.5. It has a dividend yield of 1.3%. Petrobras remains a fairly low cost oil producer, since its production comes from conventional, albeit offshore sources.
- Companhia de Saneamento Basico, also known as Sabesp (ADR: SBS). This is the water-and-sewage system for Sao Paulo. Now that’s a growth business, and is one that’s not dependent on commodity prices or on rapid Brazilian economic growth. The shares feature a P/E ratio of only 3.1 and a yield of 8.0%. This one must surely be a bargain; it has very little dependency on the economy.
- Votorantim Celulose e Papel SA (ADR: VCP). This is a pulp-and-paper company, with a prospective P/E ratio of 6.0 and a dividend yield of 9.5%. Trees grow fast in the tropics; VCP benefits from that!
- Finally, you should consider the Brazilian ETF, the iShares MSCI Brazil Fund (NYSE: EWZ). The fund was more than $5 billion in size at Sept. 30, and currently trades at a P/E of about 7.0 with a dividend yield of 3.0%.
- As I said, Brazilian stocks are currently in the bargain-basement category, and well worth a look
We have a few comments:
- Brazil is not really growing that fast, certainly not comparable at the likes of China and India. Also, the down trend in emerging markets has begun in earnest only this month, and this is a down trend that works on three fronts, both on the stock market itself, but also on the currency and interest rates front, that is a bit of a risky play, we think. The reason is that stocks and bonds are sold pretty indiscriminately (“sell first, ask questions later”) as money is repatriated to the financial centers, and if that continues, getting in now can really lead to substantial losses, although we’re fairly sure in the longer-run the article is indeed right in arguing things are cheap.
- A p/e of 7 is not that bargain basement. The Dutch market is going for a p/e of 5 these days (although this can vary a bit by the hour), while the economy is still very solid (at least so far).
- Banks, well..
- Petrobras’ new fields it discovered are very expensive to develop (they are really in very deep sea). We are pretty sure energy prices will be going considerably higher again when the world economy recovers, in the mean-time, it suffers on both counts from the fall in energy prices, current production is much less profitable and exploring the deep sea fields has become more complicated as they need higher oil prices to be profitable. It’s not a big disaster, because by the time production is ready, prices will indeed be higher, but it might complicate matters on the credit side of things.
- On first sight, we very much like that water and sewage utility from Sao Paolo, we’re going to look into that one and we’ll report back here.
- The same holds for the paper and pulp play. A dividend yield of almost 10%, that sounds too good to be true..
- ETF’s are a good way to invest if you lack stockpicking qualities but still want some exposure
- On the other hand, Brazil is doing a lot better than it’s neighbour, Argentina, and that’s largely due to who’s in power. Lula is much better than Christina.